![]() |
Originally Posted by seypat
(Post 23361755)
The back one might be shielding the ST/seatpost junction. I just noticed how low the front part of the rear one goes. The location could be about protection from something other than moisture.
Also, if you going to mount one, mount them both. Got to be matchy-matchy. :D Q: is there any value to "grease sealing" the seatpost after the correct ride height is dialed in? not in a goopy mess way, but a good fingering including the tube slot if applicable, and then wiping all the excess off to a showroom sparkle. |
Originally Posted by southpier
(Post 23362710)
provoking my memory to something which i thought of last week . . .
Q: is there any value to "grease sealing" the seatpost after the correct ride height is dialed in? not in a goopy mess way, but a good fingering including the tube slot if applicable, and then wiping all the excess off to a showroom sparkle. Serious note though, yeah of course grease is a good idea to put on a seat post. It helps reduce water getting into the seat tube and creating corrosion/rust in the tube or bottom bracket. |
Originally Posted by squirtdad
(Post 23362576)
his moto style fenders for aero, are not for sale so he is not hawking that
|
I had a Schwinn Super Sport with shortie fenders. Neon green. Cool, man. Love it when old ideas recycle. Go Jan.
|
Originally Posted by tomato coupe
(Post 23362955)
His moto-style fenders are Rene Herse fenders that have been trimmed a bit.
and he does cover the bike cultures of Japan & France with equal aplomb. i need to remind myself of that when my subscription is up for renewal. |
Originally Posted by squirtdad
(Post 23362576)
ok my post was a bit more snarly than needed, mea culpa
I guess I don't understand the dissing of Jan. yes he is iconclastic bordering on eccentric, and I don't buy everything he does, but I do think he is sincere and he bikes the talk himself, but is not a luddite. His bigger tires are not slower (to some logical point) have been embraced by tour de france riders with many riding 30mm (with more like 32 measured tires) his moto style fenders for aero, are not for sale so he is not hawking that his focus is long solo rides like the long gravel rides and paris-brest-paris so aero is in that context of having to bring things along but the key point is he rides what he is pitching, and gets some top times. Is it the rider, the experience the gear? as always a bit of both. will it work for everyone, probably not....especially super thing flexy frames and bigger riders like me I could go on for paragraphs about why Jan Heine irks me, but it boils down to an apparent unwillingness to just acknowledge that he likes what he likes. It has to actually be the best stuff. Which leads to years of tests purporting to show that the fastest bike is a round tube, steel frame bike with cantilever brakes and non-aero levers*. I don’t think he’s deliberately cooking the books with his tests, but I also don’t find them at all convincing. *I’m being a bit hyperbolic here, but I hope I’ve made my point. SIDEBAR: There’s also an annoying tendency among some people more predisposed to like Jan Heine to credit him with discovery of the arcane truth about wide tires, and even with having been among the influencers that lead to the adoption of wider tires in professional road cycling and the road cycling marketplace. In reality, the rolling resistance benefits of a wider contact patch have been known for literal decades and no performance director at a professional team would’ve been unaware of this fact. The reasons for wider tires finally appearing on road bikes are complicated, but they have to do with disc brakes, tubeless technology, improved aerodynamic testing and design among others, and very little to do with roll down tests published in BQ. |
i will admit he's no Peter Weigel.
but when you're good at anything, there's always going to be controversy. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:26 PM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.