Commuting & Training, Same Bike?
 

Hi, I have two questions that go hand in hand in this forum. First, I'm well aware that I'm not going to find a bike that can do both of these things in exactly the same way at the same level, however, I can't exactly afford to buy two ideal bikes.

That said, I'm looking at two intriguing used bikes that seem to offer two different sets of pluses and minuses. I was hoping that someone could shed some light on the two bikes as well as give me their opinion of the asked for price.

The first is an '88 Italian Steel Pinarelli, 14 speed with Campy Record and Chorus components.

The second is an '06 Trek 2200zr with ultegra brakes and rear derailler, shimano 105 front derailler, candy red.

The Pinarelli is selling sans pedals for almost 600 and the Trek is a steal I think at around 900. Now, my initial inclination is to say that the Trek is a bargain for the quality even though I'm hesitant to spend that much, and the Pinarelli, though a beautiful bike, must be overpriced for being 20 years old.

That said, I'm also planning on using this bike for my daily rides to campus (6+ miles with some good hills). My thinking is that the Pinarelli with the steel frame might be a more stable bike when I have to carry a bag with books. Also, it looks less expensive which would be comforting when I lock it up on campus.

What is your opinion and/or what light can you shed on these two bikes for me. I'd especially appreciate anyone with experience or perspective on the Pinarelli. I'm new to road bikes so I don't have the expertise to appraise that older model.

Thank you in advance,
Jonathan

I won't address the Pin/Trek issue (because you know I am biased in favour of the Pin--it's steel, it's lugged, what more could I ask for except that it would be better in my size!), but I think you would be fine with either one commuting/training.

The Trek's a good deal, but the Pinarello is not overpriced at $600. However, the Trek is aluminium, with carbon stays. The ride could be harsher than the Pinarello (because steel usually gives a smoother ride). Oh, and the components on the Pinarello are easier to work on (because you don't have brifters).

If it's possible for you to test ride the Trek and Pinarello, I would do that.

You are correct, the Trek is probably more likely to get stolen, too.

East Hill