$250 Entry level Hybrid
Hope this is the right place to post. Please no flames on the budget.
Objective: start riding Me: 43 yr, 220 lb, 6"1' Trying to make life changes. Began working out about 10mth ago and have dropped 45lbs since but have plateau in the last few months. Still sedentary on the weekends (computer geek). Just looking to dip my toe into biking and see if it's for me. Looking to buy a bike or have one fixed. Fixed: I have an old mountain bike. Diamond Back Outlook. Shimano SIS. Missing a pedal. Been sitting in the garage a decade. Is it better to fix it up? Maybe upgrade components or ... Buy New: I think a Hybrid is the way to go. I have a local county park with a paved 7.8mi path I could use. It seems a hybrid would be better at this and/or citi streets and more comfortable than a road bike. I have a low budget so I'm looking at the big box stores (bbs) like WalMart, Target, Amazon, etc. I did look at the local bike shops but their entry was $400. Have considered the following: Schwinn Midmoor Schwinn Avenue Open to suggestions within my budget on purchase or components. Questions: 1. I'm a big guy. Is there a hybrid tire size I should favor due to my weight? 2. Is the 'one size fits all' of the big box stores ok for my size? 3. 21 gears vs 7/8? What should I favor? Why? Sorry. A Trek is not in my first bike budget. I don't feel confident enough to try Craigslist so I think a fixer up mountain bike or a new hybrid are my choices. BBS is a plus as I could just go and pick it up. I'm on vacation right now so it's a good time to pick up a new routine. Sorry for the long post. Appreciate all the help and insight you can provide. |
Congrats on your progress, 45 pounds is quite an accomplishment. I lost 15 pounds by just biking ever day to work.
My bike suggestion would be a KHS Green. It's a little different than the bikes you've considered - it's more of a true hybrid. It's geared toward people who want to use their bikes to get placed and get things done (rack, 3 speed). It should be availabe in your price range. I have it and quite happy with it. Think about if you need all those gears, I started out with my old mountain bike, wasn't too much to get it fixed. My local bike shop was quite helpful in that regard. Keep us posted what you decide on doing... |
I appreciate the response and did look at the KHS Green. I didn't see dealers in my area. I did notice it was a steel frame. Actually I've been avoiding steel frames in favor of aluminum and the weight difference. I'm not convinced that weight is such a big deal at this level of experience or price point though I have read reviews complaining of frame flex in aluminum frames.
I may do some shopping tomorrow. If I do buy locally from a bbs I can at least return it conveniently if it doesn't perform. |
I would suggest buying used. I just found a nice Trek 7100 for $100, I kind of got good luck knowing someone that had one laying around though. Some towns/cities have bike co-ops even.
|
Thanks for the response nal13.
I checked craigslist and local classified but just didn't find anything. There's a guy with a Trek 7.3fx with great specs but I imagine he's firm on price as he's lowered his ask $25 in a month of posting. Still well above what I want to spend. http://cincinnati.craigslist.org/sea...breviation=bik Actually still looking bbs and thought the specs on this Forge Saranac at Target were quite good. Shimano Altus shifters, deraileurs. I'll make a trip tomorrow to Wally World and Target. |
http://dayton.craigslist.org/bik/1652596301.html
That might be too short for you, but that's a nice bike. |
I always hear department store bikes are crap, but that could just an elitist thing.
|
Yeah I've read the same in some forums but how much is there to a bike? If you have a solid frame, good components and a good build certainly it will serve as an entry level bike? Was really hoping someone new of a great cheap sleeper bike not often touted but haven't head from anyone yet. I think you do get what you pay for but you can also overbuy against your needs.
|
I wonder if Target would let you take one outside and test it out, it's only fair, right?
|
Originally Posted by nal13
(Post 10569217)
I wonder if Target would let you take one outside and test it out, it's only fair, right?
I rode all over a thrift store once. It was kinda fun. |
Originally Posted by nightrider1
(Post 10568698)
I did notice it was a steel frame. Actually I've been avoiding steel frames in favor of aluminum and the weight difference. I'm not convinced that weight is such a big deal at this level of experience or price point though I have read reviews complaining of frame flex in aluminum frames.
At the price points you are looking at, you're not going to find a light bike. Consider this: http://www.trekbikes.com/us/en/bikes...v/navigator10/ or this: http://www.globebikes.com/us/en/glob...?pid=10CAR7003 Both have better build, quality, and SUPPORT than dept store bikes. A little more but not much. PLUS your LBS will typically provide a life time adjustments. |
Originally Posted by nightrider1
(Post 10567155)
Fixed: I have an old mountain bike. Diamond Back Outlook. Shimano SIS. Missing a pedal. Been sitting in the garage a decade. Is it better to fix it up? Maybe upgrade components or ... Take it to an LBS and pay the $45 to have it adjusted. Tell them you are streeting it not trailing it. If tires are still OK, wear them out, then put some smooth treaded tires on it, later. A hybrid is just a mountain bike with smooth tires, for the most part.i |
That diamondback probably has some life left in it. If you have stored it indoors the cables, bearings and other assemblies should be good.
A good set of platform pedals can be had for $20 at the local bike shop. A tune up around $50. A set of smooth tread tires for road use less than $40. Ask the bike shop to fit you on the bike. There are 3 problems with department store level bikes. The first is assembly quality. I have bought a few in the past, and have had to basically disassemble the bike down to the frame and properly preload bearings, brakes, true wheels and set derailleurs. The second, most department store bikes use the bottom bin for parts, you get longer lasting, better quality, better performing parts on a bike shop bike. It is difficult to get good service or replacement parts on department store bikes. Most bike shop bikes are designed to give years of service, most department store bikes are not. The third issues is sizing. Most big box store bikes only come in 1 or 2 sizes. Most name bike shop bike come in 5 to 9 sizes. If the bike doesn't fit, it will be uncomfortable and you are less likely to use it. Be that as it may, the best deals going are used bikes, look on Craigslist and you local newspaper. It hard to go wrong with Trek, Specialized, Jamis, or Raleigh. Avoid Schwinn, Mongoose, Huffy, Roadmaster, Next, or Pacific. |
Based on your specific requirements - take a look online - You will get free shipping and no sales tax :thumb:
Shimano 21Spd 2010 Motobecane Jubilee $249.95 Full SRAM/Shimano 21 Speed, 6061 Aluminum Frame, Suspension Fork & Seatpost + 2.35 tires http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/...cane/jub_x.htm http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/...vm_jub_600.jpg |
Good find 911, Your going to have to assemble it but you will have a nice modern bicycle with all the braze-on's to add stuff to it as you go. Bikesdirect has a pretty good rep as far as I know.
|
Thanks very much for all the responses.
I'm having trouble discerning the advantage of something like the Motobecane over that Forge. If I can't afford an lbs bike due to price then it seems my options are online (BikesDirect, Amazon) or a local big box store. The choice is probably immediate gradificaiton vs tax/shipping. Comparing that Motobecane to the Forge The specs seem comparable to me. Am I missing something. Same frame construction/material. Same brakes. Same shifter, defaileur manufacturer but different models. Same tires essentially. I mean if I buy it online and have to assemble it or have it assembled what's the difference from buying from a big box store and having them at least try to assemble it? What am I missing? Motobecane Jubilee Frame 6061 Aluminum ComforTuned with Rear Rack/Baby Seat Mounts, H2O brazeons Fork / Headset RST 191 suspension, 1.125" / CH 1.125 inch, threaded, black finish Stem/ Handlebar Comfort-rise aluminum, black finish / Medium-rise comfort-bend, black finish Derailleurs Shimano Tourney RD-TX51 rear / Shimano FD-C051 Dual-pull SIS front Shifters SRAM MRX 7 Speed (21spd Total) Brakes / Levers Tektro Forged Aluminum Linear-Pull 'V" type black finish/ Tektro for V-brake, silver/black finish Hubs Dust Sealed Ball Bearing with quick release front & rear Rims CH-6N Anodized Aluminum 36 hole, silver finish Crank SR Suntour Aluminum arms, Triple-ring 28/38/48T Freewheel Shimano HyperGlide MegaRange 14-34T, 7 Speed (21 gears total) Saddle VeloPlush, Super Comfort w/ Gel+elastomer spring support Seatpost Suspension Comfortpost, black finish Pedals VP Comp, ResinComfort body, Alloy cage, 9/16 axle Tires Kenda K935 (Semi-slick) 26 x 2.35 blackwall Forge Saranac Frameset Size: 17.5 17.5" Frame / STANDOVER HEIGHT 30.5" Fits most riders 5'5 to 5'8 Size:19" 19" Frame/ Standover Height 31.5" Fits most riders 5'9 to 6'0" Color: SPORT GREEN / SILVER Frame: 6061 DOUBLE-BUTTED ALUMINUM, WITH RACK, CHILD SEAT AND FENDER MOUNTS Front Suspension: SR NEX WITH ADJUSTABLE PRELOAD Wheels Rims: ALLOY 32H CH-03 BLACK Hubs: JOYTECH ALLOY 32H Spokes: 14G STAINLESS STEEL Tires: KENDA K-892 26x1.95” Drivetrain Speed: 21 Shifters: SHIMANO ALTUS ST-EF50 SPORT RAPID FIRE Front Derailleur: SHIMANO TOURNEY TX SERIES FD-C051 Rear Derailleur: SHIMANO ALTUS RD-CT95 Crankset: SR SUNTOUR XCC-T208 TRIPLE 48/38/28T 175MM Bottom Bracket: VP SEALED CARTRIDGE Cassete: SHIMANO MF-TZ31 Chain: KMC Z51 Pedals: ALLOY PLATFORM Components Saddle: WTB COMFORT V COMP Seat Post: ALLOY 27.2X350MM, SUSPENSION WITH QUICK RELEASE Handlebar: MTB –154 AL ALLOY Stem: ALLOY ADJUSTABLE THREADLESS Grips: VELO SPORT FORM Brake Set: TEKTRO ALLOY LINEAR-PULL W/ SHIMANO ALTUS BRAKE LEVERS Extras: CATEYE REFLECTOR SET, TWO WATER BOTTLE MOUNTS, STORAGE RACK & FENDER MOUNTS, CLEAR COAT PAINT FINISH AND OWNERS MANUAL |
Make sure you size the bike out for your body dimensions. It doesn't matter what you pay for it if it doesn't fit you and uncomfortable to ride. There is no 1 size fits all with bikes.
|
Given those two choices, the Motobecaine wins, hands down. Better wheels, tires, slightly better components, and better looking, IMHO.
|
Also, do you have a Performance Bike near you. They have reasonably cheap bikes
|
Originally Posted by nal13
(Post 10569126)
I always hear department store bikes are crap, but that could just an elitist thing.
Another thing to consider is that the majority of the Schwinn bikes (maybe all) on Amazon are the same bikes you can get at the local x-mart. Schwinn has two distinct lines- one for the mass market (department stores), and one sold through LBSs. The Schwinn you get from your local bike shop will have better components and build quality than what you can get from Amazon/x-mart. My LBS does a fair amount of work on bikes that were bought at department stores, they tend to refer to them as BSOs (Bike-Shaped Objects). |
Originally Posted by nightrider1
(Post 10569404)
Thanks very much for all the responses.
I'm having trouble discerning the advantage of something like the Motobecane over that Forge. If I can't afford an lbs bike due to price then it seems my options are online (BikesDirect, Amazon) or a local big box store. The choice is probably immediate gratification vs tax/shipping. Comparing that Motobecane to the Forge The specs seem comparable to me. Am I missing something. Same frame construction/material. Same brakes. Same shifter, dérailleur manufacturer but different models. Same tires essentially. I mean if I buy it online and have to assemble it or have it assembled what's the difference from buying from a big box store and having them at least try to assemble it? What am I missing? BTW, the Moto has better specs http://www.bikesdirect.com/instructionhelp.htm |
i have had friends who have gone to police auctions and did well -- don't know if they get picked over first ?
|
The 36 spoke wheels on the Motobecaine are a HUGE difference ----- worth mentioning. They are MUCH stronger, than 32 holers.
|
Or, if you're not in a rush, you can spend some time on here and other bike websites (to learn what you want and how you want to fit), and then troll the Craigslist for a month or so to get a feel for the pricing in your area and then start seriously trying to get a bike off the CL. That's what I did. Took me a couple of months to get the right bike, but I really like what I ended up with.
If you're in more of a rush than that, AND your mountain bike fits you, I'd say get that fixed up at the lbs. That's essentially what I have now. Just getting things working and throwing on some slicks (currently have the forte slick city tires on it https://www.performancebike.com/weba...ductId=1035134, hey cost me $30 for a set) that you can put some extra air in and reduce the rolling resistance will make a ton of difference. And then you can spend all the money you save on your second bike once you decide you like it (or like me in getting a bunch of other stuff to make your first bike that much better). |
Originally Posted by himespau
(Post 10592673)
Or, if you're not in a rush, you can spend some time on here and other bike websites (to learn what you want and how you want to fit), and then troll the Craigslist for a month or so to get a feel for the pricing in your area and then start seriously trying to get a bike off the CL. That's what I did. Took me a couple of months to get the right bike, but I really like what I ended up with.
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:40 AM. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.