Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Mountain Biking (https://www.bikeforums.net/mountain-biking/)
-   -   Merida or Specialized? (https://www.bikeforums.net/mountain-biking/1019745-merida-specialized.html)

Stuntex 07-20-15 09:10 AM

Merida or Specialized?
 
Hello.
I want to buy one of these bikes.
The first is:Merida big 7 300,and the second is Specialized Rockhopper sport
What should i buy for city riding?
Speed/Leans/Wheelies,and abit offroad.
Thanks.

Menel 07-20-15 09:48 AM


Originally Posted by Stuntex (Post 17996454)
Hello.
I want to buy one of these bikes.
The first is:Merida big 7 300,and the second is Specialized Rockhopper sport
What should i buy for city riding?
Speed/Leans/Wheelies,and abit offroad.
Thanks.

"What should i buy for city riding?"
Neither bike. Find something without suspension, and without knobby tires.

Stuntex 07-20-15 11:31 AM


Originally Posted by Menel (Post 17996586)
"What should i buy for city riding?"
Neither bike. Find something without suspension, and without knobby tires.

Why not?
I used to ride a 26 mtb,and it was great,but the wheel was bought broken.
I want something better now,even to start racing abit.
What's a better bike then?

Mumonkan 07-20-15 11:57 AM

racing what?

theyre called mountain bikes for a reason. look at almost anything except a mountain bike if youre going to be riding roads and the street

roccobike 07-20-15 12:26 PM

Not sure why you want a mountain bike for the road, but of those two, I'd go with the Specialized for the larger 29 wheels. First thing you have to do is get rid of the knobbies and put some city tires on that bike.
The problem is, a hybrid or a road bike is better suited to the type of riding you described (except the racing part). Mountain bikes are designed to be ridden on dirt over obsticles on narrow mountain trails. They really don't work as well as other designs on paved roads or even dirt MUPS/rails to trails.
If you are dead set on buying a mountain bike to ride on the road, I'd recommend you look at a Trek 820. It's a very good, all around bike that's at home in the city, on gravel and even some light single track.

Stuntex 07-20-15 10:32 PM


Originally Posted by Mumonkan (Post 17997077)
racing what?

theyre called mountain bikes for a reason. look at almost anything except a mountain bike if youre going to be riding roads and the street

For example?
I don't want a road bike.


Originally Posted by roccobike (Post 17997177)
Not sure why you want a mountain bike for the road, but of those two, I'd go with the Specialized for the larger 29 wheels. First thing you have to do is get rid of the knobbies and put some city tires on that bike.
The problem is, a hybrid or a road bike is better suited to the type of riding you described (except the racing part). Mountain bikes are designed to be ridden on dirt over obsticles on narrow mountain trails. They really don't work as well as other designs on paved roads or even dirt MUPS/rails to trails.
If you are dead set on buying a mountain bike to ride on the road, I'd recommend you look at a Trek 820. It's a very good, all around bike that's at home in the city, on gravel and even some light single track.

I was riding a k2 zed 2.1,which was great for me,but the bike was broken with broken wheel,and now I can't even ride it.
I just want a new bike.
I was told that the merida will fit me,because it's faster on the road.

Mumonkan 07-21-15 02:12 AM

who is telling you this information? whats wrong with a road bike?

theres like half a dozen kinds of racing in the mtb corner of bikes alone. xc, dh, enduro, etc.




...im out

Stuntex 07-21-15 03:27 AM

I don't want a road bike!
What about buying the merida,and replacing the tires to road tires?

Menel 07-21-15 06:26 AM


Originally Posted by Stuntex (Post 17999089)
I don't want a road bike!
What about buying the merida,and replacing the tires to road tires?

That's fine, but you still have a heavy, bouncy suspension robbing you of efficiency. Even if you have a lockout, its still heavy.

And you're paying extra to replace perfectly fine tires. When you could get a purpose built from the get go. You don't even need a 'road bike', a hybrid works as well. Some companies have a commuter series. Built tough for potholes and sidewalks, fender and rack mounts, still smoothtire efficient rigid bike.
e.g.
http://www.specialized.com/us/en/bik...s/sirrus#specs
flatbar with 700x32c tires

Stuntex 07-22-15 08:29 AM


Originally Posted by Menel (Post 17999312)
That's fine, but you still have a heavy, bouncy suspension robbing you of efficiency. Even if you have a lockout, its still heavy.

And you're paying extra to replace perfectly fine tires. When you could get a purpose built from the get go. You don't even need a 'road bike', a hybrid works as well. Some companies have a commuter series. Built tough for potholes and sidewalks, fender and rack mounts, still smoothtire efficient rigid bike.
e.g.
Specialized Bicycle Components
flatbar with 700x32c tires

I don't want hybrid/road bike.
Just mtb with road tires.
Should I buy 27.5 maxxis road tires,or stay with this ones?
I will race offroad then.

emanuel_v19 07-22-15 09:57 AM

I don't understand why people keep insisting about the road/hybrid bike. The dude wants a mountain bike! That's all. My opinion won't matter but probably the specialized

Stuntex 07-22-15 10:28 AM


Originally Posted by emanuel_v19 (Post 18003373)
I don't understand why people keep insisting about the road/hybrid bike. The dude wants a mountain bike! That's all. My opinion won't matter but probably the specialized

The questions is:Why?
27.5 Is faster on the road.
29 is faster offroad.
I will ride 95% of the time,on the road.

Menel 07-22-15 10:43 AM


Originally Posted by emanuel_v19 (Post 18003373)
I don't understand why people keep insisting about the road/hybrid bike. The dude wants a mountain bike! That's all. My opinion won't matter but probably the specialized

because of this:


Originally Posted by Stuntex (Post 18003488)
The questions is:Why?
27.5 Is faster on the road.
29 is faster offroad.
I will ride 95% of the time,on the road.

He asks for advice, we supply it, being honest. He of course doesn't have to take our advice.

Stuntex 07-22-15 11:48 AM


Originally Posted by Menel (Post 18003568)
because of this:



He asks for advice, we supply it, being honest. He of course doesn't have to take our advice.

Plans changed!
I met a guy,who is going to buy a new bike aswell,we are going to go offroad.
The merida costs 150$ more,than the specialized,but now it's 15% discount.
WHAT DO I BUY THEN?

Darth Lefty 07-22-15 01:10 PM

They're going to be pretty similar, both 9-speed hardtail sport bikes with nearly the same fork. The drivetrain on the Merida looks slightly better but the fork on the Spec looks slightly better, but neither is a big difference. I'd pick the one you think looks cooler, honestly.

Stuntex 07-22-15 01:48 PM


Originally Posted by Darth Lefty (Post 18004030)
They're going to be pretty similar, both 9-speed hardtail sport bikes with nearly the same fork. The drivetrain on the Merida looks slightly better but the fork on the Spec looks slightly better, but neither is a big difference. I'd pick the one you think looks cooler, honestly.

Yeah,but it's 27.5 vs 29er.
I will go offroad every weekend,and ride on the road everyday.

emanuel_v19 07-22-15 01:57 PM

I understand you want to give advice but why suggest more than once to a hybrid/road bike when he keeps saying he wants an opinion on those 2 mountain bikes only!!!

Darth Lefty 07-22-15 04:07 PM


Originally Posted by Stuntex (Post 18004115)
Yeah,but it's 27.5 vs 29er.
I will go offroad every weekend,and ride on the road everyday.

Slicks are available in both sizes. Plenty of us commute on 38mm slicks on our 26ers.

Stuntex 07-22-15 11:08 PM


Originally Posted by Darth Lefty (Post 18004512)
Slicks are available in both sizes. Plenty of us commute on 38mm slicks on our 26ers.

27.5 tires,don't exist in my country.
I'm staying with the stock tires.

Stuntex 07-23-15 07:09 AM

I'm going to the shop in 20 minutes,what TO GET??


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:39 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.