EDIT: Insert 04 Kona Dawg Frameset here.
http://www.konaworld.com/shopping_ca...1&parentid=188 http://wheelworld.com/merchant/129/i...wg04frm360.jpg |
Actually I would consider you current bike an AXC, I would not call it an urban bike. I don't really see much difference between that and the other you posted.
I don't see any reason why your current hardrock can't handle epic trails. |
Originally Posted by DMN
Actually I would consider you current bike an AXC, I would not call it an urban bike. I don't really see much difference between that and the other you posted.
I don't see any reason why your current hardrock can't handle epic trails. |
I would say your LBS has been telling lies. The stand over height of the top tube is far to high for real urban use (think trying to pull a move and getting your foot trapped under the top tube at the worst possible moment). Simple as.
If you look at a completed FX compared to a Hardrock there apears to be very little difference to me. If you want to spend the doller and change it then go for it, its your bike after all, but I would spend my money else where. |
How's this?
|
At that price, thats a steal. :D
|
The price is great but would you consider it an XC/epic trail bike?
|
Troie, What specifically bothers you about your bike? Not nimble? Heavy? Saddle trouble? Riding position?
If you really want a new bike, that's swell, but I'd at least futz around with your current one and try to spot the "problem" first... |
What is "epic trail"?
Let's not get carried away with upgrades now... |
Werd, Im with brad on this one, how long have you had this current rig?
|
His bike is an 03 I think. Not super old...
|
Originally Posted by Psyko
Werd, Im with brad on this one, how long have you had this current rig?
|
Originally Posted by troie
I borrowed a friends Stumpy FSR for about 5 minutes and in 5 seconds I knew that Ive been riding the wrong bike.
Or maybe its something like handlebars, stem, or seat position? |
Originally Posted by Brad01
Troie, What specifically bothers you about your bike? Not nimble? Heavy? Saddle trouble? Riding position?
If you really want a new bike, that's swell, but I'd at least futz around with your current one and try to spot the "problem" first... |
Originally Posted by swifferman
What is "epic trail"?
Let's not get carried away with upgrades now... Too late, Ive already gone upgrade crazy. |
Originally Posted by spleck
Or maybe its something like handlebars, stem, or seat position? |
I know you're starting to sound pretty adamant about needing a new frame, but have you looked at the difference in geometry between the Hardrock and the StumpJumper? .5 deg for the head and seat angle. Other than that, the standover height is about 3 inches shorter. Were they the same size?
As far as that Kona goes, I would definitely try the bike first considering your fit issues. It's geometry seems considerably different than the Stumpy. You might end up in the same situation, less $600. |
Originally Posted by troie
The price is great but would you consider it an XC/epic trail bike?
I can quite happliy ride for 3 hours plus on my DJ bike (with seat post extended), so you should be able to do all you want on the Dawg. As the Kona site says its for getting you out to the fun spot and all the way back. |
Originally Posted by spleck
It's geometry seems considerably different than the Stumpy. You might end up in the same situation, less $600.
|
If it's just a feel issue and you want a new bike, I'd say ride a completed version of the Kona or if all else fails, compare its specs- handlebar style and stem included- to the Stumpy.
|
I thought you said you weren't into XC. You didn't want clipless pedals and you wanted shin guards. Now you want an XC frame? Doesn't make sense. 3 hour long XC rides I'm not entirely sure require a different type of XC bike. Stop pouring money into your hardrock/dawg/komodo/whatever and just wait for an XC bike that you want. Makes a heck of a lot more sense than doing this. But then again, since you have all the components, it might be too late.
Also, what do you classify "Aggresive XC" as? Do you have skinnys, drops, log rides small jumps etc.? |
Originally Posted by swifferman
I thought you said you weren't into XC. You didn't want clipless pedals and you wanted shin guards. Now you want an XC frame? Doesn't make sense. 3 hour long XC rides I'm not entirely sure require a different type of XC bike. Stop pouring money into your hardrock/dawg/komodo/whatever and just wait for an XC bike that you want. Makes a heck of a lot more sense than doing this. But then again, since you have all the components, it might be too late.
Also, what do you classify "Aggresive XC" as? Do you have skinnys, drops, log rides small jumps etc.? Im an XC rider no doubt about it. Maybe Im just being a whiney little b|tch and Im tired of having the HR? Maybe Im jealous of all the nice bikes and full-spension rigs I see at the trails? Maybe Im ashamed of my bike because when people look at it they laugh and think I belong at some skatepark? Maybe I need to take a break from the forums for about a week? Here is the bottom line: 1. Do you think the HR frame is designed for XC? 2. Will the Dawg be a worthy purchase and will help me take my riding to the next level or will I just end up wasting $600? 3. Could be something as simple as switching to clipless pedals to help improve my technique i.e. climbing, speed, endurance? 4. Am I a whiney little b|tch? |
Originally Posted by troie
I thought I was, then I wasnt, then I thought I was, then I didnt. The trails one rides determines the type of riding they are limited to right? We dont have north shore type trails here, its mainly XC singletrack. There is a FR/DH park about an hour from me but I'll rarely drive down there as it is too far and the trails are very limited compared to the 150+ miles of intertwined trails about 15 minutes from my house.
Im an XC rider no doubt about it. Maybe Im just being a whiney little b|tch and Im tired of having the HR? Maybe Im jealous of all the nice bikes and full-spension rigs I see at the trails? Maybe Im ashamed of my bike because when people look at it they laugh and think I belong at some skatepark? Maybe I need to take a break from the forums for about a week? Here is the bottom line: 1. Do you think the HR frame is designed for XC? 2. Will the Dawg be a worthy purchase and will help me take my riding to the next level or will I just end up wasting $600? 3. Could be something as simple as switching to clipless pedals to help improve my technique i.e. climbing, speed, endurance? 4. Am I a whiney little b|tch? http://www.leaderbikeusa.com/products/frameStore.htm I rode their 2004 frame for a few months and was very happy. The only thing is that you need zero stack (maybe the 05 frame doesnt) which is a nice headset but you might be fixed on using a King or something. If your doing XC switch to clipless, try this before a frame. Clipless is a huge power boost. i would not suggest going and buying 200 dollar shoes to match 300 dollar pedals so for 120 a real nice deal from pricepoint can be found here: http://www.pricepoint.com/detail/138...ome-Pedals.htm Endurance and speed come in time. And lastly, keep your seat high. I know with free riding your probably not concerned with maximum pedal efficiency, but for what your doing it will help you a lot |
Originally Posted by troie
I thought I was, then I wasnt, then I thought I was, then I didnt. The trails one rides determines the type of riding they are limited to right? We dont have north shore type trails here, its mainly XC singletrack. There is a FR/DH park about an hour from me but I'll rarely drive down there as it is too far and the trails are very limited compared to the 150+ miles of intertwined trails about 15 minutes from my house.
Im an XC rider no doubt about it. Maybe Im just being a whiney little b|tch and Im tired of having the HR? Maybe Im jealous of all the nice bikes and full-spension rigs I see at the trails? Maybe Im ashamed of my bike because when people look at it they laugh and think I belong at some skatepark? Maybe I need to take a break from the forums for about a week? Here is the bottom line: 1. Do you think the HR frame is designed for XC? 2. Will the Dawg be a worthy purchase and will help me take my riding to the next level or will I just end up wasting $600? 3. Could be something as simple as switching to clipless pedals to help improve my technique i.e. climbing, speed, endurance? 4. Am I a whiney little b|tch? 2 - Dawg kick ass and has a similar geometry and selling point to a stumpy (I would love to post a comparison to make sure but specialized site SUCKS!!!! so I can't be bothered going through the trouble, I am pretty sure they are similar in geometry). Its a bit more of a xc bike than the current stinky so I guess now a days it is an all mountain machine. Based on the exact design of the 2001 stinky it will be a good all round bike, but the bobby bob bob might counteract that too ;) 3 - Yes it well could. A fork length change, stem change and saddle position change could easily fix the problem. But without someone there looking at how you sit and how the bike fits and knowing the measurements you could spend a long time 'fitting' an ok bike to you. This is where it helps to be as picky as me (and other riders) you know your exact geometry and can buy online. Sounds to me like, even with your experience, you shouldn't buy blind. If you can't test it then right now, in your head anyways, the only bike that fits is that stumpy. Anything else might cause problems. 4 - sometimes. :D ;) :p As everyone here always says. Comfort is all that matters. Good or bad bike you need one that fits you. Obviously you have come to the point where you found something better. But look at this yourself. Is this like someone thats hungry, do you NEED food or do you want it so bad your brain has convinced itself its hungry? If you NEED it, then get to work finding your next bike. Comfort is what counts. |
Three hours is an epic ride?
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:37 PM. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.