Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Mountain Biking (https://www.bikeforums.net/mountain-biking/)
-   -   Thomson or Race Face (https://www.bikeforums.net/mountain-biking/250193-thomson-race-face.html)

wheelhot 12-04-06 04:04 AM

Thomson or Race Face
 
Im looking for a reliable and lightweight seatpost and I believe these two is my best pick, just cant decide which one :
Race Face Deus
+ cheap
+ lighter then thomson
Thomson
+ strong
+ has a proven desing

which seatpost because I cant deside?, I wonder why Thomson make their seatpsot 410mm in length instead of 400mm, it seems the extra 10mm made their seatpost to weight extra 50 grams which made it a bit more heavier and Thomson is more expensive then RaceFace. Need your help guys :D

FlatFender 12-04-06 04:23 AM

Ive always had a soft spot in my heart for anything RaceFace.

erhan 12-04-06 04:28 AM


Originally Posted by wheelhot
it seems the extra 10mm made their seatpost to weight extra 50 grams

If it was true, the whole seatpost would weigh more than 2 kilos!

Go with the one you like, both are good seatposts.

wheelhot 12-04-06 04:39 AM

Oh kay thanks, I think I choose race face because its cheaper and im not soo heavy. Anyway here is my problem, I dont know whats my saddle rail diameter, Raceface Deus seatpost only accept 7 to 8mm saddle rail diameter. Im using a 07 WTB Silverado rails and I cant find any info bout it rail length.

LowCel 12-04-06 06:57 AM


Originally Posted by wheelhot
Im using a 07 WTB Silverado rails and I cant find any info bout it rail length.

Rail length doesn't matter, it's rail diameter that does. Most of them are pretty standard so you should be fine.

wheelhot 12-04-06 07:25 AM

oops did i say rail length, I mean rail diameter, sorry for the typo. Well its because RaceFace states on their installation of the saddle that its rail diameter can only accept 7 - 8mm so I dont know if mine is compatible or not.

LowCel 12-04-06 07:32 AM

If in doubt e-mail or call WTB and ask them the diameter.

wheelhot 12-04-06 07:56 AM

thanks, never thought WTB website to have a contact us page, unlike Giant which I never found the URL to email them about their paint issues.

Dannihilator 12-04-06 08:34 AM

Thomson, really no debate there.

pelts79 12-04-06 08:40 AM


Originally Posted by KonaRider24
Thomson, really no debate there.

I agree

wheelhot 12-04-06 08:45 AM

yeah, but Im talking bout weight, price and durability. I know that Thomson is the strongest comparing to RaceFace but its also more expensive and a bit more heavier and I dont want my Anthem to be any more heavier, trying to make it 13kg max.

Dannihilator 12-04-06 08:54 AM


Originally Posted by wheelhot
yeah, but Im talking bout weight, price and durability. I know that Thomson is the strongest comparing to RaceFace but its also more expensive and a bit more heavier and I dont want my Anthem to be any more heavier, trying to make it 13kg max.


HUH?:crash:

wheelhot 12-04-06 09:02 AM

well, Im looking for a reliable seatpost without spending too much money on, I would prefer lighter weight, that what I mean. I know that Thomson is stronger then RaceFace but its more expensive and heavier and after putting on some eggies on my Giant Anthem, it would weight almost 13kg, I dont want my bike to be heavier then 13kg

ed 12-04-06 09:09 AM

Are you racing? If not...then don't sweat a few ounces. 13kg (28.6lbs) really isn't that bad for a dually. Granted, I'd expect more than 3" of travel for a bike of that weight. My dually weighs 32.13lbs (14.5kg) as of my scales last night. I think it's fine unless I was gonna race it XC. It's be a decent Downieville'er.

wheelhot 12-04-06 09:10 AM

well I do race occasionally, I already own a 14.5kg hardtail, I dont want my full sus to be that weight :D, no offence though, I just like light bikes, easier to carry and faster to pedal

ed 12-04-06 09:15 AM

Sell the HT and buy a really nice set of wheels...that will make a huge diff on the Anthem.

wheelhot 12-04-06 09:18 AM

nah, Im keeping my hardtail for training and skill building :D, I dont mind crashing a USD250 bike rather then a USD1.7k bike

MattP. 12-04-06 09:28 AM

SDG I-Beam system :D

LowCel 12-04-06 09:31 AM

Come on everybody, he made a decision so let's leave it be. You all know how hard it is for him to reach a decision so let's just set back and enjoy it.

santiago 12-04-06 09:37 AM


Originally Posted by LowCel
Come on everybody, he made a decision so let's leave it be. You all know how hard it is for him to reach a decision so let's just set back and enjoy it.

"set back" You made a pun. heh heh heh

wheelhot 12-04-06 09:37 AM

nah, I think i'll choose RaceFace, Im only 150lbs (anyone here lighter? Whats your weight LowCel, Im very interested in knowing) I choose alu over carbon because of the previous posts about a guy got carbon on his butt

LowCel 12-04-06 09:48 AM

During race season my weight goes from about 165 - 172 pounds. I'm hoping to have my race weight go between 160 - 165 pounds this season. During the off season my weight goes around 180 - 185 pounds.

born2bahick 12-04-06 10:06 AM


Originally Posted by LowCel
During race season my weight goes from about 165 - 172 pounds. I'm hoping to have my race weight go between 160 - 165 pounds this season. During the off season my weight goes around 180 - 185 pounds.

Ain't it the truth! I'm not a racer, but I've already picked up 12 pounds since August, and the really cold weather just got here! :eek:

mx_599 12-04-06 10:23 AM

thomson posts have the largest clamping length of any of the posts i've seen...if you care. i think 41mm.

secondly, i have asked WTB what their rail dia. was and i believe they said 7mm. don't quote me on that.

MtbVA 12-04-06 12:08 PM

How about one from Pricepoint. Their house brand "sette apex" is light & cheap!!
I bought one for my S.S. mountain bike, when comparing to the Thomson I have on another bike it has the same construction & weight. I'm not sure if itís made of identical aluminum specs, so it might be a little weaker over the long run.
I weigh 200lbs and haven't had any problems. For the cost it I doubt you can find a better post.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:27 AM.


Copyright © 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.