Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Mountain Biking (https://www.bikeforums.net/mountain-biking/)
-   -   Bikes without sloping top tubes (https://www.bikeforums.net/mountain-biking/493197-bikes-without-sloping-top-tubes.html)

flats 12-09-08 04:03 PM

Bikes without sloping top tubes
 
I'm looking for a hardtail without a sloping top tube. Suggestions?

ca7erham 12-09-08 04:15 PM

Whats wrong with sloping top tubes?

cryptid01 12-09-08 04:25 PM

run a 20" front wheel

Metzinger 12-09-08 04:25 PM


Originally Posted by ca7erham (Post 7993363)
Whats wrong with sloping top tubes?

1. They're slopey
2. When you hang your bike on a top tube hook rack it sits at a weird angle.
3. Seatpost has to be longer - seat looks detached from bike.
4. Bad experience in BMX as a kid.

That enough?

scrublover 12-09-08 04:31 PM

1. personal preference i know, but i find level top tubes fugly.

2. so? shouldnt' be hurting anything

3. again, a personal preference. looks cleaner, and lets you drop the seat far more. if you're into that sort of thing.

4. a couple inches less to drop to the tube isn't going to spare the boys any pain if you really rack 'em on there...

as forks have gotten taller, top tubes have gotten more sloped to give more standover.

either custom, or something XC oriented around a short fork is going to have to be it. though even most short travel bikes have more slope than older rides.

rankin116 12-09-08 04:38 PM


Originally Posted by Metzinger (Post 7993414)
1. They're slopey
2. When you hang your bike on a top tube hook rack it sits at a weird angle.
3. Seatpost has to be longer - seat looks detached from bike.
4. Bad experience in BMX as a kid.

That enough?

Seriously? How the bike hangs on a rack will make you decide that you don't want it?

dminor 12-09-08 05:06 PM

I think my old Barracuda frame is spoken for already (**note to self: take pics for YB**) - - but I think chelboed still has one of available ;).

ed 12-09-08 05:09 PM

http://i60.photobucket.com/albums/h2...02455-Copy.jpg

ed 12-09-08 05:11 PM

This one's not sloping too much in the pic:
http://i60.photobucket.com/albums/h2...e/DSC01925.jpg

dminor 12-09-08 06:17 PM

That camp-chair-frame splice looks a little sketch though. You sure that stuff's 6061?:


Originally Posted by chelboed (Post 7993629)


Dannihilator 12-09-08 06:54 PM

You're going to have to go the custom route.

ed 12-09-08 08:35 PM


Originally Posted by dminor (Post 7993947)
That camp-chair-frame splice looks a little sketch though. You sure that stuff's 6061?:

I never said it was...(ti).

c_m_shooter 12-09-08 09:58 PM

Surly Cross Check.

M_S 12-09-08 10:10 PM

Transition TransAM with an nos Judy, 63mm travel.

You'll have to run rim brakes on the front and a disc rear, but I hear that's a sweet setup for skidzzzzz.

All joking aside, you will have to go custom if you want a true mountain frame. As mentioned the cross check comes close, but it only has clearance for 700c x 1.8 inch rubber, you only get rim brakes, and it's not corrected for a supension fork.

Your first three reasons don't really seem that important, and I don't understand your fourth, but perhaps you could elaborate?

EDIT: actually the surly 1x1 has a fairly straight top tube, but it is singlespeed only.

roccobike 12-09-08 10:20 PM

You can search for some old steel from the mid-90's. Some were made with 1 1/8 heads so you can upgrade the fork. Keep in mind, they won't have disc brake mounts for the rear. I recently picked up a 97 Hoo Koo E Koo that I plan to use for MUP riding and the top tube has very little slope to it.
But man, that design is gonna hurt if you ever come off the bike at the wrong angle and try to land on your feet while stradling the top tube.

Metzinger 12-10-08 02:05 AM

I'm glad everyone had such fun with my four reasons.
I guess if they'd been funnier they would have been taken less seriously.
But now the OP hasn't returned to give his/her actual reason for the preference. And the OP is carfree and carefree, which I dig.
My bad.
As penance, I'll try to think of some actual reasons for wanting a non-slopey top tube.

1. More space for a shoulder carry cyclo-cross style.
2. Proper tube angle for one of those inside-the-frame bags.
3. In the case of smaller frames, enough room for a full sized water bottle in the seat tube cage.
4. Old school aesthetics.

How's that?

dminor 12-10-08 10:46 AM


Originally Posted by Metzinger (Post 7996164)
As penance, I'll try to think of some actual reasons for wanting a non-slopey top tube.

1. More space for a shoulder carry cyclo-cross style.
2. Proper tube angle for one of those inside-the-frame bags.
3. In the case of smaller frames, enough room for a full sized water bottle in the seat tube cage.
4. Old school aesthetics.

How's that?

Awesome! Those are even better than the first ones. You have a gift; keep it coming.

ed 12-10-08 11:19 AM


Originally Posted by dminor (Post 7997506)
Awesome! Those are even better than the first ones. You have a gift; keep it coming.

I'd say just get a big frame and slam the seat/run a shorty stem.

22" should do it.

barturtle 12-10-08 11:26 AM

1 Attachment(s)
How about something like this...no slopey top tube to bother your aesthetic sensibilities

Attachment 88784

Metzinger 12-12-08 05:27 AM

Final
 
1 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by dminor (Post 7997506)
... keep it coming.

Herewith, my final and probably most awsome reason to be anti-slopey.

The OP is fascinated by the concepts of force, acceleration, and inclined planes.
The plan is to attach a carpenters spirit level to the top tube and use it as an accelerometer while riding on flat surfaces.
Bubble moves forward = acceleration
Bubble moves back = hitting the brakes
Bubble is centered while on a downhill = downhill acceleration or constant speed / stopped level ground
Many bubbles in the chamber = something bad just happened (check fingers and toes)

Don't encourage me in this.

dminor 12-12-08 08:11 AM

Half a bubble shy of plumb, I'd say.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:32 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.