Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Professional Cycling For the Fans (https://www.bikeforums.net/professional-cycling-fans/)
-   -   Why not TT a course like stage 11? (https://www.bikeforums.net/professional-cycling-fans/832121-why-not-tt-course-like-stage-11-a.html)

letitsnow 07-13-12 07:38 PM

Why not TT a course like stage 11?
 
That would be fun to watch!!

letitsnow 07-14-12 08:31 AM

It looks like I am alone on this one. It would be fun to watch each rider do these climbs on their own. No looking at each other, no team helpers - just a race against the clock, through the mountains...

thenomad 07-14-12 11:33 AM

No, too boring. Might as well watch baseball.



You get a better dynamic for drame when there's a rider you want to beat or have to catch. It's also scientifically proven that head to head competition brings out the absolute best in riders.

Bacciagalupe 07-14-12 12:40 PM

Actually, in the past many ITT's included significant climbs; e.g. 1987, stage 18 was an ITT up Mt Ventoux. The Giro did an ITT through Cinque Terre a few years ago. 2001 was the most recent year the TdF did a real uphill ITT.

They also did more ITT's then. E.g. the average (including prologues) in the 80s was 3.6, in the 90s was 3, in the 00's 2.3.

YMCA 07-14-12 01:39 PM

Long, hilly TT's are a relic of early 20th century stage racing.
The time gaps would be to be big to keep the excitement intact these days.

Although, personally I'd like to see longer TT's occasionally too.

MinnMan 07-14-12 02:52 PM


Originally Posted by YMCA (Post 14480977)
Long, hilly TT's are a relic of early 20th century stage racing.
The time gaps would be to be big to keep the excitement intact these days.

Although, personally I'd like to see longer TT's occasionally too.

On a course like that, you couldn't keep the riders spread out enough to keep them from bunching up.

curiouskid55 07-14-12 03:20 PM

Pretty sure la clinched one of his tour victories with a n itt victory on alp du juez

Bacciagalupe 07-14-12 04:06 PM


Originally Posted by curiouskid55 (Post 14481225)
Pretty sure la clinched one of his tour victories with a n itt victory on alp du juez

Hinault, Merckx and Anquetil (aka "Monsieur Chrono") had much more impressive ITT records than Armstrong -- especially given that "Tour specialists" did not exist in their day, that they often had hilly TT's, and the earlier Tours had split stages (e.g. a stage race followed by a 12km ITT on the same day).

There's a lot more to cycle racing than one Yank....

curiouskid55 07-14-12 04:55 PM

Not an Armstrong fan myself. My point is to the original post that there have been mountain itt in the past and there will be mountain itt in the future

letitsnow 07-14-12 10:58 PM


Originally Posted by curiouskid55 (Post 14481467)
Not an Armstrong fan myself. My point is to the original post that there have been mountain itt in the past and there will be mountain itt in the future

Ok, thanks. I was assuming that the TT's were mainly held on flat ground. I will look forward to the next mountain ITT.

Bacciagalupe 07-15-12 04:22 AM


Originally Posted by letitsnow (Post 14482469)
Ok, thanks. I was assuming that the TT's were mainly held on flat ground. I will look forward to the next mountain ITT.

Your assumption is correct. Again, they haven't done a hilly TT in over 10 years. You also won't see split stages (2 stages on the same day), which ended around the same time.

diphthong 07-15-12 05:01 AM

still want downhill tt's! am i the only one?! absolutely love to watch descending techniques...

Keith99 07-19-12 01:58 PM


Originally Posted by letitsnow (Post 14482469)
Ok, thanks. I was assuming that the TT's were mainly held on flat ground. I will look forward to the next mountain ITT.

One problem now is that there seems to be a set in stone formula. One is exactly 2 ITTs. Making one of those shifts things too far in favor of the climbers.

I'd like to see an ITT that includes both climbing and significant decending. But there are significant problems. The differences in ability get magnified and worst case one rider catches and passes the one before him just before the top and the one passed is a better decender.

Not to mention issues with a crashed rider on course on a decent (and the impact it wouldhave on following riders).

daveF 07-19-12 02:06 PM


Originally Posted by Bacciagalupe (Post 14482784)
Your assumption is correct. Again, they haven't done a hilly TT in over 10 years. You also won't see split stages (2 stages on the same day), which ended around the same time.

8 years ago. 2004 TDF stage 16 Alpe d'Huez ITT 15.5km
http://autobus.cyclingnews.com/road/...esults/stage16

byhsu 07-19-12 02:48 PM


Originally Posted by Bacciagalupe (Post 14480841)
2001 was the most recent year the TdF did a real uphill ITT.

Who won that stage?

Thanks

Keith99 07-19-12 05:03 PM


Originally Posted by Bacciagalupe (Post 14482784)
Your assumption is correct. Again, they haven't done a hilly TT in over 10 years. You also won't see split stages (2 stages on the same day), which ended around the same time.

There have not been 2 stages on one day for far longer than 10 years.

EDIT: Loks like the last split stage TDF was 1982, a bit more recent than I thought it was. But jsut a bit. I knew there had split stages in 1974.

rex615 07-19-12 06:10 PM

What about a team time trial, has that ever been done in a tour? I guess it would have to be done early in the race before attrition whittled the teams down.

Laggard 07-19-12 06:18 PM


Originally Posted by rex615 (Post 14504443)
What about a team time trial, has that ever been done in a tour? I guess it would have to be done early in the race before attrition whittled the teams down.

Many times. Hate them.

Riders dislike them but many fans enjoy them.

rex615 07-19-12 06:23 PM


Originally Posted by Laggard (Post 14504465)
Many times. Hate them.

Riders dislike them but many fans enjoy them.

How do Team Time Trials affect each individual's time in the GC? Does everyone in the team just get added the teams time?
Sorry about the noob questions, but this is very interesting.

nun 07-20-12 05:51 AM


Originally Posted by daveF (Post 14503455)
8 years ago. 2004 TDF stage 16 Alpe d'Huez ITT 15.5km
http://autobus.cyclingnews.com/road/...esults/stage16

Yeah I was thinking of Alp d'Huez too

nun 07-20-12 05:56 AM


Originally Posted by rex615 (Post 14504489)
How do Team Time Trials affect each individual's time in the GC? Does everyone in the team just get added the teams time?
Sorry about the noob questions, but this is very interesting.

If you have a 9 man team you might give the first 5 guys over the line the time of the 5th guy. Then cyclists that come in after that get their own time. Some TTs also have time penalties for being slower by certain amounts than the winning team.

rex615 07-20-12 06:50 AM


Originally Posted by nun (Post 14505848)
If you have a 9 man team you might give the first 5 guys over the line the time of the 5th guy. Then cyclists that come in after that get their own time. Some TTs also have time penalties for being slower by certain amounts than the winning team.

Thanks. Could get a bit complicated for some teams but it might be fun to watch.

Keith99 07-20-12 09:29 AM


Originally Posted by rex615 (Post 14504443)
What about a team time trial, has that ever been done in a tour? I guess it would have to be done early in the race before attrition whittled the teams down.

It has been done a lot and with a lot of variations. At one point it did not count toward individual standings. Others had just a small bonus impact on the individual standings. Recently it has been eitehr the actual time (of the 5th rider) counting for individual standing, though fairly recently it has been that with a maximum that can be lost.

As you point out it has to be early and if the total time is used the result is contenders are all but eliminated before they even have a chance to do anything as an individual. Which is why the tour organizers, most riders and many fans are not thrilled with TTTs.

Today there is a problem with super profesionalism. That is in the sense of being focused on just one goal. The TTT has to count for the GC or many teams will not try much, but if theams can get a large payoff it can ruin hte race. 30 years ago winning the TTT itself was enough to get a good if not total effort.

Kind of Blued 07-20-12 12:36 PM

The uphill TT in the 2010 Giro was awesome.

Also, the obvious joke here is that Team Sky has been doing a team time trial this whole tour, including uphill TTTs on the mountain stages.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:33 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.