E-Assist with Throttle? Or Internally Geared Hub? Or Both?
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 165
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 45 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 14 Times
in
14 Posts
E-Assist with Throttle? Or Internally Geared Hub? Or Both?
I'm giving serious thought to upgrading my Catrike Villager to a new trike in a few months, and I want this new trike to be my "forever" trike, so I'll spare (almost) no expense.
One of the situations I sometimes find myself in is having to make a sudden stop when I'm in a high gear. In a situation like that, not having a throttle can make it difficult to get going again. From what I know, either an e-motor with throttle (such as Bafang middrive <I prefer mid-drives>) OR an internally geared hub (like a Rohloff, which allows you to shift gears when stopped) would solve this problem, right?.
If so, what are the plusses/minusses of each? And does it ever make sense to have BOTH installed on a tadpole trike?
Thanks!
One of the situations I sometimes find myself in is having to make a sudden stop when I'm in a high gear. In a situation like that, not having a throttle can make it difficult to get going again. From what I know, either an e-motor with throttle (such as Bafang middrive <I prefer mid-drives>) OR an internally geared hub (like a Rohloff, which allows you to shift gears when stopped) would solve this problem, right?.
If so, what are the plusses/minusses of each? And does it ever make sense to have BOTH installed on a tadpole trike?
Thanks!
#3
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 165
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 45 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 14 Times
in
14 Posts
Also - what does the Rohloff hub add (other than easy shifting) if you already have a throottle which can get you going in any gear anyway?
Thanks again.
#4
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Lincoln Ne
Posts: 9,809
Bikes: RANS Stratus TerraTrike Tour II
Mentioned: 44 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 3235 Post(s)
Liked 1,001 Times
in
599 Posts
My electric trike has torque assist. It has settings from 0 to 9. I pretty much ride on a 2 setting. But then it also has a throttle lever. I often use it on start up from a stop to help get going.
So basically I have the best of both worlds. And I recommend both.
So basically I have the best of both worlds. And I recommend both.
Last edited by rydabent; 02-28-23 at 01:43 PM.
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: SF Bay Area
Posts: 3,429
Bikes: Trident Spike 2 recumbent trike w/ e-assist
Mentioned: 25 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1300 Post(s)
Liked 343 Times
in
268 Posts
I agree about a throttle. Even if you don't use it often to take off, it can (and has been for me) a life saver in situations where a car makes it necessary for you to move out of the way FAST, much faster than you could instantly pedal. I consider a throttle a safety device. Now whether it is redundant to an IGH, I would guess the constant throttle starts impact battery range somewhat so that might be a good reason to go IGH .... assuming you will do almost all your take-offs manually. But I thought IGH has other advantages (never had one) like being able to dial in gears anywhere within your range rather than being stuck with set gaps. Or is that only some IGH?
Likes For linberl:
#6
Philosopher of Bicycling
I can't say anything about using a throttle but I can offer a little info (I found it on the internet) about the Rohlof and another IGH hub, the Enviolo, available on some ICE models:
https://www.icetrikes.co/19-news-and...r-changing-hub
The Rohlof can be shifted when sitting still, so you're never stuck in a high gear at a stop. The gear range is 500% over 14 speeds, which are reportedly spaced fairly evenly (according to various YouTube videos I've seen).
The Enviolo is an automatic shifter based on the cadence preference you establish during the initial setup. There are no distinct gears (as with the Rohlof); the drive ratio is constantly changing so as to be the perfect amount at a constant cadence. The range spread is 380%.
The advantage of the two IGH hubs is allegedly little maintenance required, and also a higher clearance for the bottommost part of the chain. There is a chain tensioner in place of the derailleur.
The disadvantage of the IGH is the weight and the cost. The Enviolo, being a fairly new product (so far as I know) doesn't have a track record for reliability, but the Rohlof is reportedly very reliable. I hope this helps.
https://www.icetrikes.co/19-news-and...r-changing-hub
The Rohlof can be shifted when sitting still, so you're never stuck in a high gear at a stop. The gear range is 500% over 14 speeds, which are reportedly spaced fairly evenly (according to various YouTube videos I've seen).
The Enviolo is an automatic shifter based on the cadence preference you establish during the initial setup. There are no distinct gears (as with the Rohlof); the drive ratio is constantly changing so as to be the perfect amount at a constant cadence. The range spread is 380%.
The advantage of the two IGH hubs is allegedly little maintenance required, and also a higher clearance for the bottommost part of the chain. There is a chain tensioner in place of the derailleur.
The disadvantage of the IGH is the weight and the cost. The Enviolo, being a fairly new product (so far as I know) doesn't have a track record for reliability, but the Rohlof is reportedly very reliable. I hope this helps.
Last edited by DeadGrandpa; 02-06-23 at 08:46 PM.
#7
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 5,527
Mentioned: 24 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2208 Post(s)
Liked 534 Times
in
387 Posts
As much as I like the concept of human power and all that. At a certain point of cost/benefit ... get a car. Can't/won't drive? Uber or Lyft. There are 'green modes' on both where you can specify hybrid or electric vehicles. I know because I do it when (rarely) I need Lyft. A rohloff hub is around $1500 and a 500% gear range is not impressive even if they will say it is. Of course they will but your average triple crank plus 8sp - 12sp cassette is over 600%, half the weight, and 1/10 the cost. I also don't know how much e-assist torque a Rohloff can handle. It can probably do it if you are gentle but if you goose your mid-drive and crumple a cog on a 9sp cassette you aren't going to need therapy because of it. The practical e-assist trike does not make you think to yourself "a ten year old sedan would be cheaper".
#8
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 165
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 45 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 14 Times
in
14 Posts
As much as I like the concept of human power and all that. At a certain point of cost/benefit ... get a car. Can't/won't drive? Uber or Lyft. There are 'green modes' on both where you can specify hybrid or electric vehicles. I know because I do it when (rarely) I need Lyft. A rohloff hub is around $1500 and a 500% gear range is not impressive even if they will say it is. Of course they will but your average triple crank plus 8sp - 12sp cassette is over 600%, half the weight, and 1/10 the cost. I also don't know how much e-assist torque a Rohloff can handle. It can probably do it if you are gentle but if you goose your mid-drive and crumple a cog on a 9sp cassette you aren't going to need therapy because of it. The practical e-assist trike does not make you think to yourself "a ten year old sedan would be cheaper".
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: SF Bay Area
Posts: 3,429
Bikes: Trident Spike 2 recumbent trike w/ e-assist
Mentioned: 25 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1300 Post(s)
Liked 343 Times
in
268 Posts
As much as I like the concept of human power and all that. At a certain point of cost/benefit ... get a car. Can't/won't drive? Uber or Lyft. There are 'green modes' on both where you can specify hybrid or electric vehicles. I know because I do it when (rarely) I need Lyft. A rohloff hub is around $1500 and a 500% gear range is not impressive even if they will say it is. Of course they will but your average triple crank plus 8sp - 12sp cassette is over 600%, half the weight, and 1/10 the cost. I also don't know how much e-assist torque a Rohloff can handle. It can probably do it if you are gentle but if you goose your mid-drive and crumple a cog on a 9sp cassette you aren't going to need therapy because of it. The practical e-assist trike does not make you think to yourself "a ten year old sedan would be cheaper".
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 5,527
Mentioned: 24 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2208 Post(s)
Liked 534 Times
in
387 Posts
I've been car free for decades, equally because it is cheaper and it is good for the planet. I would (and did) get e-assist OR an IGH but not both, because neither is inexpensive and a $2k+ trike, $500+ mid-drive, $500+ battery, $1500 IGH, and $$$ labor to put it all together = car (IMO). Just came in from 9 miles in driving rain. A rain shroud for the trike (if I ever get a trike) would be worth more to me than an Igh.
#11
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: SF Bay Area
Posts: 3,429
Bikes: Trident Spike 2 recumbent trike w/ e-assist
Mentioned: 25 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1300 Post(s)
Liked 343 Times
in
268 Posts
I've been car free for decades, equally because it is cheaper and it is good for the planet. I would (and did) get e-assist OR an IGH but not both, because neither is inexpensive and a $2k+ trike, $500+ mid-drive, $500+ battery, $1500 IGH, and $$$ labor to put it all together = car (IMO). Just came in from 9 miles in driving rain. A rain shroud for the trike (if I ever get a trike) would be worth more to me than an Igh.
#12
Half way there
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 2,910
Bikes: Many, and the list changes frequently
Mentioned: 5 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 969 Post(s)
Liked 848 Times
in
508 Posts
The argument that "If you're going to spend that much, you should probably just buy a car" strikes me as a bit off because it narrows the focus down to just transportation. In fact, there are many other factors that would lead a person to spend money on a trike instead of a car. Hobbies are like that and one's passions are not likely to be distilled down to comparative price. When I'm out on the lake rowing, I see boats costing tens of thousands of dollars being used to haul in a few pounds of fish. The point is that we invest money in our passions just for the joy of the experience.
In response to the OP:
I installed a mid-drive motor on my wife's bike a few years ago and included a throttle. She pretty much uses it just for the reason you state: to get started after stopping or to scoot quickly when the need arises. That said, I'm planning on adding a mid-drive motor to my trike sometime this year and will probably not install a throttle for 2 reasons: 1) I have to think that with just a bit of planning when coming to a stop, one can assure being in a suitable gear for re-starting, at least most of the time. 2) It's one more thing to install on the limited steering bar space. A third reason is that in some jurisdictions, throttles are prohibited on some paths.
I happen to like IGHs, and have them on a number of my bikes. It is true that they have much less of a gear range than a derailleur system; however with e-assist, that should not be a significant issue except at the high end. One issue is that they have definite torque limits that will restrict your lower end gearing. As long as the gearing restrictions don't affect your riding style, I think you'll definitely enjoy having an IGH. I'm strongly considering installing an IGH when I do my mid-drive conversion, though I'm thinking about a hybrid hub: the Sturmey Archer CS-RK3. It's a 3 speed hub that accepts a 9 speed cassette. It seems to me to be a nice lower cost option that gives me a reasonable gearing range while making up for the loss of the triple chain set.
If I were to buy a new trike and money was not an important factor, I'd go with an ICE Adventure with full suspension, the Shimano STEPS EP8 e-assist package, and a Rohloff in the rear. But then again the MSRP of $12.5 K would buy a lot of fish at the market.
Good luck to your quest.
In response to the OP:
I installed a mid-drive motor on my wife's bike a few years ago and included a throttle. She pretty much uses it just for the reason you state: to get started after stopping or to scoot quickly when the need arises. That said, I'm planning on adding a mid-drive motor to my trike sometime this year and will probably not install a throttle for 2 reasons: 1) I have to think that with just a bit of planning when coming to a stop, one can assure being in a suitable gear for re-starting, at least most of the time. 2) It's one more thing to install on the limited steering bar space. A third reason is that in some jurisdictions, throttles are prohibited on some paths.
I happen to like IGHs, and have them on a number of my bikes. It is true that they have much less of a gear range than a derailleur system; however with e-assist, that should not be a significant issue except at the high end. One issue is that they have definite torque limits that will restrict your lower end gearing. As long as the gearing restrictions don't affect your riding style, I think you'll definitely enjoy having an IGH. I'm strongly considering installing an IGH when I do my mid-drive conversion, though I'm thinking about a hybrid hub: the Sturmey Archer CS-RK3. It's a 3 speed hub that accepts a 9 speed cassette. It seems to me to be a nice lower cost option that gives me a reasonable gearing range while making up for the loss of the triple chain set.
If I were to buy a new trike and money was not an important factor, I'd go with an ICE Adventure with full suspension, the Shimano STEPS EP8 e-assist package, and a Rohloff in the rear. But then again the MSRP of $12.5 K would buy a lot of fish at the market.
Good luck to your quest.
Likes For Moe Zhoost:
#13
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 165
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 45 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 14 Times
in
14 Posts
Moe - OP here. Thanks for bringing this thread back on point. And thanks for your thoughts and recommendation. FWIW, which mid-drive motor with throttle did you install on your wife's bike afew years ago?
Likes For newbert:
#14
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: SF Bay Area
Posts: 3,429
Bikes: Trident Spike 2 recumbent trike w/ e-assist
Mentioned: 25 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1300 Post(s)
Liked 343 Times
in
268 Posts
The argument that "If you're going to spend that much, you should probably just buy a car" strikes me as a bit off because it narrows the focus down to just transportation. In fact, there are many other factors that would lead a person to spend money on a trike instead of a car. Hobbies are like that and one's passions are not likely to be distilled down to comparative price. When I'm out on the lake rowing, I see boats costing tens of thousands of dollars being used to haul in a few pounds of fish. The point is that we invest money in our passions just for the joy of the experience.
In response to the OP:
I installed a mid-drive motor on my wife's bike a few years ago and included a throttle. She pretty much uses it just for the reason you state: to get started after stopping or to scoot quickly when the need arises. That said, I'm planning on adding a mid-drive motor to my trike sometime this year and will probably not install a throttle for 2 reasons: 1) I have to think that with just a bit of planning when coming to a stop, one can assure being in a suitable gear for re-starting, at least most of the time. 2) It's one more thing to install on the limited steering bar space. A third reason is that in some jurisdictions, throttles are prohibited on some paths.
I happen to like IGHs, and have them on a number of my bikes. It is true that they have much less of a gear range than a derailleur system; however with e-assist, that should not be a significant issue except at the high end. One issue is that they have definite torque limits that will restrict your lower end gearing. As long as the gearing restrictions don't affect your riding style, I think you'll definitely enjoy having an IGH. I'm strongly considering installing an IGH when I do my mid-drive conversion, though I'm thinking about a hybrid hub: the Sturmey Archer CS-RK3. It's a 3 speed hub that accepts a 9 speed cassette. It seems to me to be a nice lower cost option that gives me a reasonable gearing range while making up for the loss of the triple chain set.
If I were to buy a new trike and money was not an important factor, I'd go with an ICE Adventure with full suspension, the Shimano STEPS EP8 e-assist package, and a Rohloff in the rear. But then again the MSRP of $12.5 K would buy a lot of fish at the market.
Good luck to your quest.
In response to the OP:
I installed a mid-drive motor on my wife's bike a few years ago and included a throttle. She pretty much uses it just for the reason you state: to get started after stopping or to scoot quickly when the need arises. That said, I'm planning on adding a mid-drive motor to my trike sometime this year and will probably not install a throttle for 2 reasons: 1) I have to think that with just a bit of planning when coming to a stop, one can assure being in a suitable gear for re-starting, at least most of the time. 2) It's one more thing to install on the limited steering bar space. A third reason is that in some jurisdictions, throttles are prohibited on some paths.
I happen to like IGHs, and have them on a number of my bikes. It is true that they have much less of a gear range than a derailleur system; however with e-assist, that should not be a significant issue except at the high end. One issue is that they have definite torque limits that will restrict your lower end gearing. As long as the gearing restrictions don't affect your riding style, I think you'll definitely enjoy having an IGH. I'm strongly considering installing an IGH when I do my mid-drive conversion, though I'm thinking about a hybrid hub: the Sturmey Archer CS-RK3. It's a 3 speed hub that accepts a 9 speed cassette. It seems to me to be a nice lower cost option that gives me a reasonable gearing range while making up for the loss of the triple chain set.
If I were to buy a new trike and money was not an important factor, I'd go with an ICE Adventure with full suspension, the Shimano STEPS EP8 e-assist package, and a Rohloff in the rear. But then again the MSRP of $12.5 K would buy a lot of fish at the market.
Good luck to your quest.
Likes For linberl:
#15
Half way there
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 2,910
Bikes: Many, and the list changes frequently
Mentioned: 5 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 969 Post(s)
Liked 848 Times
in
508 Posts
I've got a triple on my e trike and have not once left the big chain ring. My cassette is 11-32. you must have huge mountains to climb if you think you'll need that kind of range with e-assist - or you run out of power when you're riding, lol. I think you mentioned your wife's bike had the Tongsheng torque mid-drive. Since a throttle is optional with those, you could always add one later (assuming you get the right display) if you change your mind. I've been pricing them and while the Eco Cycle price isn't the cheapest, I like that they already have all the wires set up for recumbent trikes so you have the added lengths and don't have to deal with that and they have the newer bushing. I don't think you mentioned how long you wife has had it or how many miles she's put on it, I'd be curious about that in terms of durability. And finally, with the IGH you mention with the cassette, is a rear flat still a big hassle?
TSDZ2 durability: Probably a bit more than a thousand miles on it so far with no issues, even with the nylon gear. Her cadence is rather slow so she tends to ride in a higher gear than I would for any condition.
Flats with IGHs are just a bit more challenging. I commuted for close to 10 years with a 5 speed Sturmey hub and recall only 3 flats. This bike also had drum brakes, which made the wheel removal even more of a hassle, though with practice it wasn't too bad. 2 of the flats were repaired without removing the wheel. I just unseated the tire on one side, pulled the tube out, and patched the hole- easy peasy. Also available are split tubes that can be inserted into a mounted wheel. Expensive, though.
Apologies to the OP for the topic detour.
Likes For Moe Zhoost:
#16
Half way there
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 2,910
Bikes: Many, and the list changes frequently
Mentioned: 5 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 969 Post(s)
Liked 848 Times
in
508 Posts
I used the Tong Sheng TSDZ2 kit that I bought from Eco Cycles. David Hall was wonderful to deal with. The TSDZ2 is a torque sensing unit that, in my opinion, gives a much more natural assist than the cadence sensing systems. The torque sensing also pretty much alleviates the need for brake lever cutouts.
Likes For Moe Zhoost:
#17
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: SF Bay Area
Posts: 3,429
Bikes: Trident Spike 2 recumbent trike w/ e-assist
Mentioned: 25 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1300 Post(s)
Liked 343 Times
in
268 Posts
Yes, apologies Newbert, for any derailing. Hopefully you find some of it informative. I did notice that Eco Cycle will program your Tongsheng initially to your stated needs. So if you just want a tiny bit of assist in the first steps or you want lots of help taking off or whatever they can do that. You can also get a programming cable and program yourself. It would be interesting to see if one could eliminate the need for a throttle for take off by the programming. But the throttle isn't expensive, anyway. When my hub system dies, I will replace with a mid drive (then i can put back my original rear wheel) and was considering the Bafang cadence, but have decided the Tongsheng with throttle will be my choice. the ability to program to my preference won me over along with the non-issue when shifting compared to a cadence system. I have looked and have not found any other torque systems for a trike that are so affordable.
Likes For linberl:
#18
Palmer
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Parts Unknown
Posts: 7,913
Bikes: Mike Melton custom, 1982 Stumpjumper, Alex Moulton AM, 2010 Dawes Briercliffe, 2017 Dahon Curl i8, 2021 Motobecane Turino 1x12
Mentioned: 34 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1355 Post(s)
Liked 1,258 Times
in
763 Posts
The Enviolo CVT hubs used to be marketed as NuVinci. They've been around since 2006.
#19
Philosopher of Bicycling
I apologize for my lack of knowledge, and it's not the first time I have shown (or been shown) my ignorance of various things. But in my defense, I did offer the disclaimer "as far as I know".
#20
Newbie
Join Date: Aug 2019
Posts: 1
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
The famous nuvinci 171 is still available on ebay, it only has a 330% gear range is built like a tank.
Enviolo has some models that are rated for ebikes.
But, I saw on youtube an Ice trike with an automatic enviolo.
Enviolo has some models that are rated for ebikes.
But, I saw on youtube an Ice trike with an automatic enviolo.
#21
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Layton, UT
Posts: 1,604
Bikes: 2011 Bent TW Elegance 2014 Carbon Strada Velomobile
Mentioned: 6 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 624 Post(s)
Liked 698 Times
in
415 Posts
Last time I looked at Bicycle Evolution, they had an e-WAW velomobile for sale. Pricey, yes, but it could easily be a forever ride with proper maintenance.