Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Ceramic vs standard bottom bracket bearings is there a difference? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/1037114-ceramic-vs-standard-bottom-bracket-bearings-there-difference.html)

CNC2204 11-03-15 06:49 PM

Ceramic vs standard bottom bracket bearings is there a difference?
 
4K miles on 2015 TARMAC, have Praxis Works crank, getting replacement Praxis bearings.

HAWK Ceramic seemed way too expensive, don't even know if it could be retrofitted.

Is there a difference ceramic vs standard ?

I'm sure it's subjective.

rpenmanparker 11-03-15 06:51 PM

Not one which is important at bicycle crank rotation speeds. Just a difference in cost, one of which (ceramic) is inflated beyond all reason. It is just **** and pillage.

So why are you replacing the bearings? Just bored?

datlas 11-03-15 06:53 PM

Waste of time and money.

CNC2204 11-03-15 06:54 PM


Originally Posted by rpenmanparker (Post 18292409)
Not one which is important at bicycle crank rotation speeds. Just a difference in cost, one of which (ceramic) is inflated beyond all reason. It is just rale and pillage.

So why are you replacing the bearings? Just bored?

Noisey ..... it's time.
Not impressed with SPECIALIZED stock bearings.

Headset was contaminated & replaced 4 months ago with upgrade bearings.

BoSoxYacht 11-03-15 06:55 PM


Originally Posted by CNC2204 (Post 18292402)
Is there a difference ceramic vs standard ?

I'm sure it's subjective.

Yes there is a difference, but not one you'll ever notice. Ceramic bearings make a difference in performance at very high speeds, but a bicycle crank never spins that fast.

Save the $$ and get the standard bearings.

rpenmanparker 11-03-15 07:01 PM


Originally Posted by CNC2204 (Post 18292418)
Noisey ..... it's time.
Not impressed with SPECIALIZED stock bearings.

Headset was contaminated & replaced 4 months ago with upgrade bearings.

There are tons of brand name bb30 bearings on ebay for cheap.

bikepro 11-03-15 10:03 PM


Originally Posted by CNC2204 (Post 18292402)
4K miles on 2015 TARMAC, have Praxis Works crank, getting replacement Praxis bearings.

HAWK Ceramic seemed way too expensive, don't even know if it could be retrofitted.

Is there a difference ceramic vs standard ?

I'm sure it's subjective.

Save your money. I put ceramic bearings in a Campy BB -- no difference.

bikepro 11-03-15 10:05 PM


Originally Posted by BoSoxYacht (Post 18292420)
Yes there is a difference, but not one you'll ever notice. Ceramic bearings make a difference in performance at very high speeds, but a bicycle crank never spins that fast.

Save the $$ and get the standard bearings.

They might be worthwhile for something like inline skates. Those small wheels must turn very fast.

rpenmanparker 11-03-15 10:35 PM


Originally Posted by bikepro (Post 18292778)
They might be worthwhile for something like inline skates. Those small wheels must turn very fast.

Or your next jet engine.

caloso 11-03-15 10:55 PM


Originally Posted by bikepro (Post 18292775)
Save your money. I put ceramic bearings in a Campy BB -- no difference.

Same with SRAM. There was a definite weight difference, but mostly in your wallet.

Marcus_Ti 11-03-15 11:06 PM

If you're going to get ceramic BB bearings, be sure to get these ceramic bearing rear mech pulleys. All that friction will slow you waaaaay down.

catgita 11-03-15 11:09 PM

A friend of mine insists that his ceramic BB saves him 7 watts over steel. Good trick, since even a crappy BB consumes less than 1 watt. Here is an article with tests that say ceramic is no better.
Friction Facts: measuring bottom bracket drag - BikeRadar USA

Silvercivic27 11-04-15 06:18 AM

Your crank spins at 100ish rpm. Do you think the friction change makes a lot of difference at 100 rpm?

lupy 11-04-15 07:39 AM

I've used wheels manufacturing/ enduro stainless steel bearing BB on two bikes and really like them. I don't have much to compare them to though. You can get them on ebay or amazon fairly cheap too. They also offer ceramic, but I'm under the impression it isn't worth it. I went for the angular contact ones because I'm gullible, but I haven't had any issues with them.

popeye 11-04-15 10:32 AM


Originally Posted by rpenmanparker (Post 18292435)
There are tons of brand name bb30 bearings on ebay for cheap.

Can someone explain to me why pressed fit BB's fail so often? Is it rain? The old DA7800 BB's last a lifetime.

BoSoxYacht 11-04-15 10:41 AM


Originally Posted by popeye (Post 18293750)
Can someone explain to me why pressed fit BB's fail so often? Is it rain? The old DA7800 BB's last a lifetime.

r The same thing happens here in Phoenix AZ, and we get very little rain. I think the DA7800 BB is just far superior to the bearings used in other BBs.

redlude97 11-04-15 01:10 PM


Originally Posted by popeye (Post 18293750)
Can someone explain to me why pressed fit BB's fail so often? Is it rain? The old DA7800 BB's last a lifetime.

hollowtech 2 style outboard bearings failed all the time, contamination is relatively easy, moreso with cheaper outboard BB like the ones from FSA. BB30 fail in 2 different methods, creaking from the cartridge in the shell which is usually an easy fix with the correct loctite, and from the bearings themselves, oftentimes from the use of inferior cartridges.

rpenmanparker 11-04-15 03:57 PM


Originally Posted by popeye (Post 18293750)
Can someone explain to me why pressed fit BB's fail so often? Is it rain? The old DA7800 BB's last a lifetime.

In the past I have had to replace the balls in a cup and cone BB after a few thousand miles.

nemeseri 11-04-15 04:06 PM


Originally Posted by catgita (Post 18292867)
A friend of mine insists that his ceramic BB saves him 7 watts over steel. Good trick, since even a crappy BB consumes less than 1 watt. Here is an article with tests that say ceramic is no better.
Friction Facts: measuring bottom bracket drag - BikeRadar USA


Originally Posted by CNC2204 (Post 18292402)
4K miles on 2015 TARMAC, have Praxis Works crank, getting replacement Praxis bearings.

HAWK Ceramic seemed way too expensive, don't even know if it could be retrofitted.

Is there a difference ceramic vs standard ?

I'm sure it's subjective.

I second [MENTION=391744]catgita[/MENTION]'s post. I'm so happy that friction facts put together a few studies on this topic. Since then I just open the reports and decide wether I want to invest in something better. The bottom line: there are better and worse BBs and you can save some power by picking a good BB. On the other hand it's very subjective if it's worth to pay that much for such a small advantage. And also based on the reports ceramic BBs not necessarily better than steal ones.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:05 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.