Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Best Saddle Bag? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/1079455-best-saddle-bag.html)

Sy Reene 01-27-17 03:36 PM


Originally Posted by snidely (Post 19340669)
Bag has to be removed from the bike to access contents.


I liked my Arundel Dual, except it would always slip out of the velcro strap that was supposed to secure it.

that should be impossible, unless you didn't notice the sewn-on loop on the bottom of the bag that the velcro strap was supposed to thread under.

snidely 01-27-17 03:38 PM


Originally Posted by Sy Reene (Post 19340679)
that should be impossible, unless you didn't notice the sewn-on loop on the bottom of the bag that the velcro strap was supposed to thread under.



Oh, mine didn't have that. Must be a newer feature.

Hiro11 01-27-17 03:44 PM

Not a fan of saddle bags. If you're just carrying a tube, a multitool, $20, a tire lever and a CO2 inflator (which is about all you can fit in any of these small bags), I'd carry them all in a Ziploc in my jersey pocket. This is the case 95% of the time for me. If I needed more room, a bar bag or Bento is far more useful as you can grab stuff while riding.

the sci guy 01-27-17 03:56 PM


Originally Posted by snidely (Post 19340685)
Oh, mine didn't have that. Must be a newer feature.

My dual doesn't have that either. I just cinch it tight as i can.

Sy Reene 01-27-17 05:23 PM


Originally Posted by the sci guy (Post 19340731)
My dual doesn't have that either. I just cinch it tight as i can.

Weird. Wonder if there was a bad batch or it was a feature added later?

memebag 01-27-17 05:30 PM


Originally Posted by Hiro11 (Post 19340698)
Not a fan of saddle bags. If you're just carrying a tube, a multitool, $20, a tire lever and a CO2 inflator (which is about all you can fit in any of these small bags), I'd carry them all in a Ziploc in my jersey pocket. This is the case 95% of the time for me. If I needed more room, a bar bag or Bento is far more useful as you can grab stuff while riding.

My jersey is full. I've got my phone, one credit card, driver's license, key to get back into a car or house, 3rd bottle, stroop waffles and mocha shots in there. I don't need to grab the stuff in my saddle bag while riding.

woodcraft 01-27-17 09:08 PM


Originally Posted by Sy Reene (Post 19340653)
To me, but not having tried it.. it looks like a lot of this bag's bulk is made up of the individual pockets and a lot of excess material. For similar size (by appearance), my Arundel dual holds a good amount more than shown here, including a 2nd tube, spoke wrench, patch kit and tire boots, tire levers, and some nitrile gloves. Also not clear if you can get anything out of this bag without removing it from the bike first?

https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/03...g?v=1481647019


That's cool- a tube and patch kit-holding beanie!

Sy Reene 01-27-17 09:18 PM


Originally Posted by woodcraft (Post 19341396)
That's cool- a tube and patch kit-holding beanie!

LOL.. that's what I thought too when I saw this. A helmet cover, but then you could have 6 pockets and completely surround the head.

noodle soup 01-27-17 10:59 PM


Originally Posted by the sci guy (Post 19340731)
My dual doesn't have that either. I just cinch it tight as i can.

My Dual has the little loop. The Dual is a little bit bulkier than I need, but the Uno is far too small.

noodle soup 01-27-17 11:02 PM

I loved the size of this bag, but the velcro straps always failed.

TransIt Small Ultra Wedge

if you don't mind using a toe strap to hold it in place, it's a great bag.

kbarch 01-28-17 07:34 AM


Originally Posted by a1penguin (Post 19047351)
I have the ever-popular Topeak medium Aero Wedge (with straps!). I see a lot of these while out riding. They last forever. The medium holds a lot.

Yes - very popular. So popular that I can't believe there's room in the world for so many others as have been posted here.
My philosophy is: bike parts and tools belong on the bike, not on me. (Just like I believe luggage belongs in the cargo compartment of an airplane, not the passenger cabin - pet peeve - gotta take every opportunity to get that out there ;) ) Add to that the fact that if it's always already on the bike, I won't be forgetting to put it in my pocket.

Sy Reene 01-28-17 07:53 AM


Originally Posted by kbarch (Post 19341857)
Yes - very popular. So popular that I can't believe there's room in the world for so many others as have been posted here.
My philosophy is: bike parts and tools belong on the bike, not on me. (Just like I believe luggage belongs in the cargo compartment of an airplane, not the passenger cabin - pet peeve - gotta take every opportunity to get that out there ;) ) Add to that the fact that if it's always already on the bike, I won't be forgetting to put it in my pocket.

+1 on all of the above. I especially hate being asked to take my smaller backpack down from the overhead compartment and to sit with it, just to make room for someone's large carry-on that they can't fit at their feet. I think they should have to sit with my carry-on at the very least :-)

franswa 01-28-17 08:39 AM

I use the Evoc saddle bag race on my bikes. It's really simple and sleek and will hold the essentials.

Saddle Bag Race | Evoc Sports USA


http://geareduk.co.uk/ekmps/shops/97...1%5Bekm%5D.jpg

Johnny Rad 01-28-17 09:13 AM


Originally Posted by TimothyH (Post 19041957)
Wrap it in a few dollar bills and put it in a ziplock bag.

The dollar bills can be used as tire boots or to buy an emergency Powerade.


-Tim-

Great suggestion. I take tubes out of the box and wrap a couple elastic bands around them to keep them compact before sliding them into a ziploc bag.

Johnny Rad 01-28-17 09:20 AM

I'm currently using a PRO Mini. It can (barely) accommodate two tubes, two irons, two CO2 cartridges and the inflator. It's slim and stays out of the way. I also appreciate the small loop on the back of the bag for my clip-on tail light.

PRO - Strap Saddlebag Mini / Medi/ Maxi

Speedsleev

http://i.imgur.com/zKE3Iewl.jpg

I'm looking forward to trying out Speedsleev's new Ranger. First off, their ad turned me on to the Cannondale-branded tubes that are shrink-wrapped down tight ... saves me having to unbox a tube, expel all the air and elastic band it down tight. As for the Ranger, it looks a hair bigger than the PRO Mini while appearing to stay out of the way. Fingers crossed.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects...ssentials-pack

http://i.imgur.com/oTugSlCl.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/4XB7QZ1l.jpg

chaadster 01-28-17 09:43 AM


Originally Posted by Johnny Rad (Post 19341996)
I'm currently using a PRO Mini. It can (barely) accommodate two tubes, two irons, two CO2 cartridges and the inflator. It's slim and stays out of the way. I also appreciate the small loop on the back of the bag for my clip-on tail light.

PRO - Strap Saddlebag Mini / Medi/ Maxi

I'm looking forward to trying out Speedsleev's new Ranger. First off, their ad turned me on to the Cannondale-branded tubes that are shrink-wrapped down tight ... saves me having to unborn a tube, expel all the air and elastic band it down tight. As for the Ranger, it looks a hair bigger than the PRO Mini while appearing to stay out of the way. Fingers crossed.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects...ssentials-pack

I haven't seen the C-dale shrink wrapped tubes, and am not keen on the idea of generating extra rubbish on a flat fix stop, but I wonder if a) that's all they come packaged in, and b) if they're more compact than the Panaracer R'Air tubes, which are the most compact out of the box as I've seen.

Sy Reene 01-28-17 09:47 AM


Originally Posted by Johnny Rad (Post 19341990)
Great suggestion. I take tubes out of the box and wrap a couple elastic bands around them to keep them compact before sliding them into a ziploc bag.

just thought of this, but haven't tried it yet.. how bout putting each tube in a nitrile glove with talc.. easier to mount tire, and get the gloves on!

Johnny Rad 01-28-17 09:51 AM

Is this the Panaracer R'Air tube?

I hear you about dealing with more trash during a flat fix, but it's an itty bitty plastic wrapper and you're already packing your tube out or at least to the next available trash can.

On the other hand, the C'dale tubes don't seem to come in a giant plastic retail case or cardboard box so maybe it's already generating less waste. Just the shrink wrapping.

http://i.imgur.com/IMQlCkll.png

I've already bought a handful of these Cannonade tubes and they're every bit (or more) as tightly wrapped as what I can do - plus they come ready to go without me having to do it myself. I'm confident the C'dale tubes are more tightly wrapped than the Panaracer pictured above.

Sy Reene 01-28-17 09:56 AM

I've been using Nashbar's "Lite" tubes which are relatively very compact. ymmv

chaadster 01-28-17 12:46 PM


Originally Posted by Johnny Rad (Post 19342059)
Is this the Panaracer R'Air tube?

I hear you about dealing with more trash during a flat fix, but it's an itty bitty plastic wrapper and you're already packing your tube out or at least to the next available trash can.

On the other hand, the C'dale tubes don't seem to come in a giant plastic retail case or cardboard box so maybe it's already generating less waste. Just the shrink wrapping.

http://i.imgur.com/IMQlCkll.png

I've already bought a handful of these Cannonade tubes and they're every bit (or more) as tightly wrapped as what I can do - plus they come ready to go without me having to do it myself. I'm confident the C'dale tubes are more tightly wrapped than the Panaracer pictured above.

Yes, those are the R'Air tubes I use.

Yes, I agree the C-dale tube wrapper is not a big deal, and I was thinking it might even be handy to use for grabbing the chain if a rear tire fix is in order! I also agree about the "green" aspect of just shrinkwrap vs. typical retail packing; I'd prefer the R'Air just came in unbleached cardboard insofar as that goes.

I'm telling you though, if you haven't had the R'Air tube in your hand, it's tiny. I've not seen the C-dale tubes to compare, but I'd be most interested to compare costs and pack sizes.

DrIsotope 01-28-17 12:46 PM


Originally Posted by chaadster (Post 19342036)
I haven't seen the C-dale shrink wrapped tubes, and am not keen on the idea of generating extra rubbish on a flat fix stop, but I wonder if a) that's all they come packaged in, and b) if they're more compact than the Panaracer R'Air tubes, which are the most compact out of the box as I've seen.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v3...pseg3cadyy.jpg

4" x 2" x 1". I've not found smaller. As a bonus, they have black stems (in 48 or 60mm) and removable cores.

chaadster 01-28-17 12:52 PM


Originally Posted by Carbonfiberboy (Post 19340414)
Ortlieb Large:

https://ortliebusa.com/wp-content/up...9401_front.jpgThese are very common in the PNW where we tend to do long rides in variable conditions. Saturday's 71 mile SIR ride will start at 35° and finish at 55°. Overflow from jersey pockets will go in this bag which will already have extra food, wallet, extra gloves, wind vest, 2 tubes, patch kit, boot kit, spare tire, and the usual small tools. This bag is waterproof, very durable, and clips easily from bike to bike.

Our tandem carries 3 bags: this bag, a small Co-Motion bag under the stoker stem, and a FuelBox on the captain's top tube.

Man, that Ortlieb Large is large! It'd be hand for some rides, I'm sure.

https://ortliebusa.com/wp-content/up...ag_mounted.jpg

chaadster 01-28-17 12:58 PM


Originally Posted by DrIsotope (Post 19342350)
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v3...pseg3cadyy.jpg

4" x 2" x 1". I've not found smaller. As a bonus, they have black stems (in 48 or 60mm) and removable cores.

Cool, thanks. I went to grab a R'Air, but realized both of the bikes that are at hand in the house have pre-used, patched tubes (both are tubeless, so besides being a rare need, I don't mind running patched tubes temporarily).

I need some new bar tape anyway, so I'll see if I can't order up some R'Air tubes, too, and measure their packed size.

Thanks again.

dmanthree 01-28-17 03:37 PM


Originally Posted by Silvercivic27 (Post 19040266)
That is really cool. I also use this one on my MTB because more room for bigger tube and MTB people are more laid back and have a sense of humor about cycling:
http://i63.tinypic.com/nlz79v.jpg

Do those come in sizes? Like Hamburger, Quarter Pounder, and Big Mac?

eja_ bottecchia 01-28-17 05:19 PM


Originally Posted by TimothyH (Post 19340300)
Buying a bag that needs to be modified with a dremel and reinforced with zip ties in order for it to work properly is a non starter for me.

I'd have thrown the thing in the garbage or returned it long before it got to that point.



-Tim-

You have never, ever, modified a product to improve upon the original design??? How odd! :twitchy:


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:37 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.