Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Best Saddle Bag? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/1079455-best-saddle-bag.html)

webberjames95 09-06-16 11:24 PM

Best Saddle Bag?
 
Whats the best saddle bag? Post a picture too! Looks/ functionality are important. What does everyone think? Post below!

Jean3n16 09-06-16 11:40 PM

thats going to matter on a lot of factors..

What you need to store in it
What style/size/type
Where on your bike ( you say saddle but do you mean actual saddle or any bag)
Weather
rollup? zipper?

I use an old camera bag and a roll up bag. Im on a 1980s Nishiki.

webberjames95 09-06-16 11:40 PM

its not a specific question for me, i just want to know what people are rolling

Silvercivic27 09-07-16 04:12 AM

Arundel Dual

chaadster 09-07-16 05:22 AM

I use a couple of Scicon clamshell bags (Elan and 430 Carbon) with the very handy Roller mount, and those are pretty sweet, but my absolute favorite is my Cyckit Aeroclam:

https://c2.staticflickr.com/2/1719/2...3813f215_b.jpg

memebag 09-07-16 05:57 AM

Timbuk2 small seat pack. Not the best but it works.

http://cdn.timbuk2.com/static/Produc...6053_front.jpg

dr_lha 09-07-16 06:31 AM

If you're interested in as minimal as possible, I like this one:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...?ie=UTF8&psc=1

https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon....L._SL1500_.jpg

It fits what I need: 1 tube, small multi-tool, 2 CO2 cartriges and valve (I use a minimal one), tire levers, emergency butt cream, and nothing else. The way it attaches to the saddle means it doesn't swing like a pair of pendulous bollocks, unlike some bags I've seen.

EDIT: Just to be sure, the one I'm recommending is the "Small" on Amazon's page.

StephenH 09-07-16 06:45 AM

J and D Mountain Wedge III, www.jandd.com, big bag for longer rides. They make several sizes.
Carradice bag, even bigger bag for carrying more gear on longer rides.
Currently shopping for smaller bag for a new bike.

katzenfinch 09-07-16 07:42 AM

I have an Acorn, which is large enough to accommodate my rain jacket and basic tool collection.
Medium Saddlebag ? Acorn Bags
Waxwing also makes a nice assortment.
- Saddle Bags - Waxwing Bag Co.

DrIsotope 09-07-16 07:57 AM

I think style and frequency of riding really determine what bag you need. For me, it's the Axiom Fondo H2O. It's not horribly huge (1L capacity,) but it holds tools, CO2, tube, bottle of Stan's, a couple of Clif bars (with room left over) and it has a neat part on the back that holds a water bottle. Some days, the ability to carry a third bottle is just a revelation. On those particularly hot days, I feel like that bag is the best thing I've ever purchased for a bike.

So... if you ride 20-30 miles twice a week, probably not your bag.

Hermes1 09-07-16 08:17 AM

Personally I do not think it matters as long as it holds all you need and want to carry in it as functions well for you. I bought mine at my LBS and cannot recall the brand, but I looked at all they had to offer, found the size that was large enough to carry the stuff I wanted to include and mounted securely, yet easy to remove. Mine has an expandable capability which can be handy.

Maelochs 09-07-16 08:38 AM

That CyKit Aeroclam would be on my bike if I was not broke from building my bike. Love it.

Scarbo 09-07-16 08:42 AM


Originally Posted by StephenH (Post 19038316)
J and D Mountain Wedge III, www.jandd.com, big bag for longer rides. They make several sizes.
Carradice bag, even bigger bag for carrying more gear on longer rides.
Currently shopping for smaller bag for a new bike.


+1

These bags are excellent!

Scarbo 09-07-16 08:43 AM


Originally Posted by chaadster (Post 19038210)
I use a couple of Scicon clamshell bags (Elan and 430 Carbon) with the very handy Roller mount, and those are pretty sweet, but my absolute favorite is my Cyckit Aeroclam:

https://c2.staticflickr.com/2/1719/2...3813f215_b.jpg

I'd never seen these. They're quite stylish!

seypat 09-07-16 08:48 AM

Except for those clammy things they all look fairly generic. I'm sure they will all work. For the stuff that can't get wet/sweaty, I carry that in a small dry bag in my middle jersey pocket.

dr_lha 09-07-16 09:48 AM


Originally Posted by Scarbo (Post 19038578)
I'd never seen these. They're quite stylish!

One man's stylish is another man's "fugly", apparently.

chaadster 09-07-16 10:00 AM

If given the choice-- and sometimes there isn't one, for example if you want a zebra print bag-- I will always prefer a clam style opening bag to an end-loader for the simpler packing and unpacking.

I also find the quick release Roller Mount Scicon uses to be a great ease-of-use item, which makes removing the bag (to take into a store/cafe, or just to access the stuff in it easier) a simple, quick task. No threading velco straps through seat rails, or fiddling around looking for the end of the strap to pull it free; just twist and go.

As a bonus, the Scicon Roller Mount integrates tire levers into the bag itself, making for one less thing to figure into the pack scheme. Convenient and tidy.

In the pic below, of the Scicon Elan Roller, you can see the ends of one tire lever where it slides under the mount on the bag. The other lever is directly below it, in a sleeve inside the bag.

http://www.bikemania.biz/media/catal...5614xxxx-5.jpg

Oh, and the only zebra hair seat bag I could find, from Krieg:

https://c2.staticflickr.com/4/3929/1...ff6fafdb_b.jpg

Bandera 09-07-16 10:03 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Carradice

Dan333SP 09-07-16 10:03 AM

@PepeM should weigh in here on bike purse vs. saddle bag.

I use a generic small black saddle bag that my shop had in a parts bin. Holds a tube, a lever, 2 CO2s and inflator, a multi tool, $6,000 cash, a patch kit, some gummy bears, and a flare gun. Works for me.

1Mule 09-07-16 10:16 AM


Originally Posted by Bandera (Post 19038832)
Carradice


Boom! Lol I have that bag, use when I'm out on longish rides, 50 thru 100 miles. I can fit my rain shell, a water bag, snacks and a f#&k ton of PBJ sandwiches in it. :D

PepeM 09-07-16 10:26 AM


Originally Posted by Dan333SP (Post 19038834)
@PepeM should weigh in here on bike purse vs. saddle bag.

I use both. My saddle bag carries two tubes and a patch kit. My bike purse (which goes inside a jersey pocket) carries 3 CO2 cannisters, an inflator, tire levers, a $1 bill, a multitool, a chain breaker, a spare quick link, and maybe something else I am forgetting. I also carry a mini-pump on another jersey pocket. For the winter I might add a bike satchel to bring warm rice cakes, rain gear, bluetooth speaker, and some deer food with me.

stockae92 09-07-16 10:37 AM

This is what I have as well on my road bike. I like it so far, but i might go for the road candy and move this to the MTB


Originally Posted by dr_lha (Post 19038292)
If you're interested in as minimal as possible, I like this one:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...?ie=UTF8&psc=1

https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon....L._SL1500_.jpg

It fits what I need: 1 tube, small multi-tool, 2 CO2 cartriges and valve (I use a minimal one), tire levers, emergency butt cream, and nothing else. The way it attaches to the saddle means it doesn't swing like a pair of pendulous bollocks, unlike some bags I've seen.

EDIT: Just to be sure, the one I'm recommending is the "Small" on Amazon's page.


caloso 09-07-16 10:45 AM


Originally Posted by silvercivic27 (Post 19038139)
arundel dual

+1

http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y18...psainqnhao.jpg

SpeshulEd 09-07-16 12:20 PM

On a modern road bike, the correct answers to this question are:

1. None.
2. Tool roll.
3. This:


Originally Posted by Silvercivic27 (Post 19038139)
Arundel Dual


Nachoman 09-07-16 01:01 PM

http://www.wigglestatic.com/product-...=430&h=430&a=7
Because most saddle bags rub against my massive guads,
I need the saddle bag set further back
so I use this one.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:14 AM.


Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.