Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Anybody 190-200lbs riding/racing a Cervelo R3? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/274887-anybody-190-200lbs-riding-racing-cervelo-r3.html)

USCswimming 03-05-07 03:24 PM

Anybody 190-200lbs riding/racing a Cervelo R3?
 
I am curious if anybody out there in the 190-200lb range is riding/racing the Cervelo R3? I am considering getting an R3 and am curious if they can withstand a larger rider.

shawneebiker 03-05-07 04:06 PM

Yes. . I'm 200lbs.. Cervelo makes some of the strongest lightest frames...Thats why I bought my R3.

I went to a Cervelo Service School awhile back and they said even If I was a monster at 350lbs. there would be a problem with the frame/forks they make.

Thats why they give a lifetime warranty. (According to Cervelo)
http://www.imagehosting.com/out.php/...3zippwhite.gif[/URL]

richphoto 03-05-07 05:22 PM

yes, just watch the testing video at the Cervelo site. that would say it all.
I just took mine on its first ride Sunday, built it up with SRAM force (hence my photo in the sig)

FrankBattle 03-05-07 05:43 PM

Is 190 - 200 that heavy .. if you are 6'3" and up?

Isn't Boonen about that weight and height (maybe not today, but on occasion). I know Backstedt is ..

Just curious.

I don't own a Cervelo. Nor do I race :)

DrPete 03-05-07 06:03 PM


Originally Posted by USCswimming
I am curious if anybody out there in the 190-200lb range is riding/racing the Cervelo R3? I am considering getting an R3 and am curious if they can withstand a larger rider.

I'm 200-205, and when I was shopping for a bike primarily for crit racing, the R3 was in the final two. It came very highly recommended, but I liked the Pinarello's handling a little better.

jschen 03-05-07 06:19 PM

Cancellara's a bit under that weight, but I'd bet he puts out crazy big wattage compared to you. I think you'll be okay.

DesFlurane 03-05-07 09:18 PM

R3 + 200lbs
[IMG]http://img78.imageshack.us/img78/2112/picture008hq6.jpg[/IMG]

USCswimming 03-05-07 09:46 PM

Thanks for all the responses! I assumed that it wouldn't be that big of a deal but I keep hearing people in Norcal chirp about how the big guys ride the Carbon Soloist.

How does everybody like the R3?

Thanks again.

jschen 03-05-07 09:59 PM

I'm a 140-ish pounder, so my experience may be a bit different, but I absolutely love my R3. It's like taking the best attributes of my Specialized Roubaix Comp (extremely comfortable) and my Specialized Allez Sport (lively feel, confident handling, precise tracking at high speed) and subtracting a bunch of weight at the same time. They're all perfectly competent bikes (I've done a century on each one) but the one I truly love is the R3. But as they say, YMMV.

Bobby Lex 03-06-07 06:32 AM


Originally Posted by FrankBattle
Is 190 - 200 that heavy .. if you are 6'3" and up?

Height is not relevant in determining a component's breaking-point. 200 lbs. is 200 lbs., regardless of whether it's on a 5'5" body, or a 6'5" body.

Bob

shawneebiker 03-06-07 07:44 AM


Originally Posted by DesFlurane

Damn Des! How tall are you? You barely fit in the garage.:D

botto 03-06-07 08:37 AM


Originally Posted by jschen
Cancellara's a bit under that weight, but I'd bet he puts out crazy big wattage compared to you. I think you'll be okay.

Never realized that 14-24 lbs counted as "a bit under".

Chad's Colnago 03-06-07 08:55 AM


Originally Posted by shawneebiker
Yes. . I'm 200lbs.. Cervelo makes some of the strongest lightest frames...Thats why I bought my R3.

I went to a Cervelo Service School awhile back and they said even If I was a monster at 350lbs. there would be a problem with the frame/forks they make.

Thats why they give a lifetime warranty. (According to Cervelo)
http://www.imagehosting.com/out.php/...3zippwhite.gif[/URL]


Oh my...great looking ride.

DocRay 03-06-07 09:39 AM


Originally Posted by USCswimming
Thanks for all the responses! I assumed that it wouldn't be that big of a deal but I keep hearing people in Norcal chirp about how the big guys ride the Carbon Soloist.

The R3 has been tested to be the strongest frame in EFBe testing currently on the market. It also has one of the stiffest BBs and torsional stiffness, these are real numbers, not just the usual BF BS. It's actually stiffer than the CF Soloist. The closest thing to it is the Scott CR1 (they are made in the same plant).
Despite that, the frame is almost as vertically compliant as titanium. It feels like ti on the flats and bumps, but definitely feels different on climbs and high-speed cornering.
190lb, 6'4". I found that this frame excelled in large frame sizes over others. Most manufacturers frames are not well designed at 58+ cm sizes.

shawneebiker 03-06-07 09:57 AM


Originally Posted by botto
Never realized that 14-24 lbs counted as "a bit under".

Assuming you believe what is printed about their weights. I saw him at the TOC and he didn't look 175.

botto 03-06-07 09:58 AM


Originally Posted by shawneebiker
Assuming you believe what is printed about their weights. I saw him at the TOC and he didn't look 175.

fair enough, but i seriously doubt that he's "a bit under" 200 lb.

DocRay 03-06-07 10:07 AM

He's a little stocky, but he's not that tall. I'd be surprise to hear he's over 185.

Duke of Kent 03-06-07 11:02 AM


Originally Posted by DocRay
The R3 has been tested to be the strongest frame in EFBe testing currently on the market. It also has one of the stiffest BBs and torsional stiffness, these are real numbers, not just the usual BF BS. It's actually stiffer than the CF Soloist. The closest thing to it is the Scott CR1 (they are made in the same plant).
Despite that, the frame is almost as vertically compliant as titanium. It feels like ti on the flats and bumps, but definitely feels different on climbs and high-speed cornering.
190lb, 6'4". I found that this frame excelled in large frame sizes over others. Most manufacturers frames are not well designed at 58+ cm sizes.

1)Canyon
2) R3
3) SystemSix
4) CR1

Tour Test scans: http://weightweenies.starbike.com/ph...e+test&start=0

The top point of the pentagon is BB stiffness (higher is theoretically better) and the upper right is head tube stiffness (again, high is better).

josephvman 03-06-07 11:34 AM


Originally Posted by DesFlurane


Killer garage door!

USCswimming 03-06-07 11:41 AM

Desflurane - did you build that up? or did you switch out the FSA Megaexo crankset? Just curious if you switched it out? How do you like those ES's on there as well?

I am not 100% sold on the carbon cranksets and was thinking of swapping it out for a regular ole dura-ace crank set. Anybody have any thoughts on the FSA Megaexo crankset vs. Dura-ace?

DocRay 03-06-07 12:50 PM


Originally Posted by Duke of Kent
1)Canyon
2) R3
3) SystemSix
4) CR1

Tour Test scans: http://weightweenies.starbike.com/ph...e+test&start=0

The top point of the pentagon is BB stiffness (higher is theoretically better) and the upper right is head tube stiffness (again, high is better).

I forgot about the Canyon, but it weighs 200g more.

DesFlurane 03-06-07 07:05 PM


Originally Posted by USCswimming
Desflurane - did you build that up? or did you switch out the FSA Megaexo crankset? Just curious if you switched it out? How do you like those ES's on there as well?

I am not 100% sold on the carbon cranksets and was thinking of swapping it out for a regular ole dura-ace crank set. Anybody have any thoughts on the FSA Megaexo crankset vs. Dura-ace?

Built it up with a R700 crank I already had + Dura ace for the rest.
Too much negative vibe on the FSA to consider swapping from a crank I know to be a great shifter.
The ES wheels were great, stiff, easy to accelerate and bullet proof, however I have sold them to fund my Powertap.
The PT has improved my riding more than the ESs ever did.
I sold the wheels to a riding friend so I still see them on rides, but as I can now ride him off my wheel I don't see them that often:D
He used to be over one hour quicker on a hilly century:eek: How the worm has turned:)

hornytoad 05-22-08 03:55 PM

5'10" 215 lbs when purchased

175 lbs now --- want to pedal off another 20 lbs before attempting to race

200 lbs is imo

grahny 05-22-08 04:34 PM

I was. The frame can handle you - if anything the frame might say "that all you got?" when you sit on it. Worry about wheels.

Matt Gaunt 05-22-08 04:47 PM


Originally Posted by DrPete (Post 3974734)
I'm 200-205, and when I was shopping for a bike primarily for crit racing, the R3 was in the final two. It came very highly recommended, but I liked the Pinarello's handling a little better.

You got a Prince Dr. Pete?

OP - I'm around 180lbs at the moment and would really hope not to be troubling any stock components just yet! I would re-evaluate if you get to 230+lbs. Would people say this is fair? Am I being naive in thinking my weight is ok for cycling?!


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:50 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.