Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Gels vs bars? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/398040-gels-vs-bars.html)

Jarery 03-16-08 04:51 PM

The OP is still only working up to 30-40 mile rides. What I see all too often is people getting caught up in the marketing and spending 10 bucks a ride on crap they dont need. None of it 'improves' your performance, its all to replenish electrolytes and ingest calories. If your not depleting your glycogen stores you dont need to worry about replenishing them while on the bike. Depleting them takes close to 3 hours. Anything 2 hours and less save it for after the ride and eat real food, that has taste and enjoyment to it, and costs less.

I see people go on 2 hour rides and they start with a sportsdrink to hydrate prior to the ride, eat 4 gells, a cliff bar or 2, add in 2 bottles of water mixed with accelerade/cytomax, then have a designer recovery drink costing a few bucks. You can drive a car the same distance for cheaper. And they would have rode the same without it all.

Pablo. 03-16-08 04:58 PM

Even if I'm riding 20 miles or so, I always bring a gel, just in case I hit the wall.

mloywhite 03-16-08 05:00 PM

I have started to use Sports Beans from Jelly Belly. I use them in place of gels, which I like but always seem to get all over me.

LifeIsSuffering 03-16-08 05:04 PM


Originally Posted by Jarery (Post 6353806)
The OP is still only working up to 30-40 mile rides. What I see all too often is people getting caught up in the marketing and spending 10 bucks a ride on crap they dont need. None of it 'improves' your performance, its all to replenish electrolytes and ingest calories. If your not depleting your glycogen stores you dont need to worry about replenishing them while on the bike. Depleting them takes close to 3 hours. Anything 2 hours and less save it for after the ride and eat real food, that has taste and enjoyment to it, and costs less.

I see people go on 2 hour rides and they start with a sportsdrink to hydrate prior to the ride, eat 4 gells, a cliff bar or 2, add in 2 bottles of water mixed with accelerade/cytomax, then have a designer recovery drink costing a few bucks. You can drive a car the same distance for cheaper. And they would have rode the same without it all.

I don't think anyone here is going to disagree with you. Many of the responses included simple/basic/inexpensive snacks. Even I suggested the traditional foods.

The OP sounds like he would venture on to more challenging distances (for him it's 30-40 miles; for others it could be double century +) and wanted feedback on gels and bars. And that's what this thread is about. Gels and various other supplements do have a place in most riders' arsenal. Should it replace everything the rider eats? Of course not. At the same time, if it's a viable option, why not research it?

Jarery 03-16-08 05:20 PM


Originally Posted by LifeIsSuffering (Post 6353856)
The OP .. wanted feedback on gels and bars. And that's what this thread is about. Gels and various other supplements do have a place in most riders' arsenal. Should it replace everything the rider eats? Of course not. At the same time, if it's a viable option, why not research it?

Yes but simple answers of " i take a gell every 30 min and take 2 bottles of cytomax" without the clarification that the rider is going for 7 hours would lead the OP into thinking he NEEDS a gell every 30 min for a 2 hour ride.

I agree, research is essential for both enjoyment and safety when venturing past new milestones in any sport. Unfortunately as is the case with most forum threads, many people responding respond to the title of the post, and not the actual content of the post. Such is the ever evolving intrerweb :)

As to what i prefer, i used to like cliff bars but find them too dry. Now I use gells, either hammer or cliff shots, and for rides over 6 hours I usually take cliff blocks, gells and a bar, so that i can mix it up a bit.

LifeIsSuffering 03-16-08 05:26 PM


Originally Posted by Jarery (Post 6353939)
Yes but simple answers of " i take a gell every 30 min and take 2 bottles of cytomax" without the clarification that the rider is going for 7 hours would lead the OP into thinking he NEEDS a gell every 30 min for a 2 hour ride.

Botto (or whatever he goes by) actually called me on that. My response to him qualified what you raised. Just below my original post, you'll see his and mine.


Originally Posted by Jarery (Post 6353939)
I agree, research is essential for both enjoyment and safety when venturing past new milestones in any sport. Unfortunately as is the case with most forum threads, many people responding respond to the title of the post, and not the actual content of the post. Such is the ever evolving intrerweb :)

There's always going to mis-interpretation in any forum. But the crux of the OPs question is the other members' take on gels vs bars. In that regard, I'd say he got a pretty nice collection of feedback.

Jarery 03-16-08 05:31 PM


Originally Posted by LifeIsSuffering (Post 6353975)
Botto (or whatever he goes by) actually called me on that. My response to him qualified what you raised. Just below my original post, you'll see his and mine.

Thats fine. My replies were not aimed at you, or about you. Many people responded similarly.

Dubbayoo 03-16-08 06:03 PM

I like gels because they're easier to get down. I put 3-4 into a flask for a long ridel

Porter20 03-16-08 09:23 PM

I prefer the Gels to the Bars. I just find the Bars are too hard to eat while riding and sit heavy in my stomach. I like the GU Gels & the Hammer Gels. I find that the GU go down easier, but the Hammer's seem to give me a little more power (but that is probably mental). They are nasty and there are only a handful of flavors I like. Also, the I am big fan of the Clif Gel Blocks. That are easy to pop in as you ride a long.

In regards to the arguments over 2 hour rides vs. other rides & what you need/don't need. It's your ride, spend it however you want. If you want to suck down a gel every 15 mins & are enjoying it; go for it! It's hard to the group you are riding with, the terrian, the pace, etc. To each his own. On a two hour ride, I normally carry 2 gels but don't take them unless I know I am doing some serious climbing, then I will have one. I do normally have Gel Blocks pack open to just to snack on depending on the pace. Also, I like to Cytomax in my water bottle whenever I ride. I just like it a whole lot better than water.

s4one 03-17-08 12:39 AM

Thanks for the replies.

Im going to give gels a try.

cuski 03-17-08 02:44 AM


Originally Posted by timmyquest (Post 6352635)
We are all there for you as you move to this next stage of your life
http://www.consumermedhelp.com/Image...ndsGds4Men.jpg

Kind of stringy, aren't they? I imagine they'd be hard to chew on.

stonecrd 03-17-08 06:08 AM

I generally just do a bottle of diluted gatoraide on 2hr or less rides and take a couple of gels for >2hr rides. In a 4hr ride probably just do one gel and a couple of bottles depending on time of the year. Summer I need three bottle. I always carry a gel with me though for those days when you go out and run out of gas for whatever reason. Very seldom use it but a couple of times it was nice to have.

Phantoj 03-17-08 07:24 AM


Originally Posted by Nessism (Post 6351769)
A gel is a good idea for rides past the one hour point. Energy bars are more substantial food and better if your rides exceed two hours.

Why is a more substantial (i.e. more indigestible) food better for rides exceeding two hours?

Sorry, I'm a gel fan... what do the kooks who do RAAM eat?



To the OP's question, I like to get a variety of stuff, try different flavors and brands. This works fine for me. But you might be more sensitive and some flavors might disgust you.

Picking up a few gels is an easy way to "support your local BS" each time you drop in...

logdrum 03-17-08 01:19 PM

How about fried chicken drumstick fried in pig fat and chitlins, about the size of a foldable tire, your sweat could season it and fits in the back jersey pocket

Seriously what's wrong with honey with ascorbic acid (Vitamin C)... I just rinse old eye drop bottles and fill with honey and the vitamin c powder.

recursive 03-17-08 02:31 PM


Originally Posted by Jarery (Post 6353806)
The OP is still only working up to 30-40 mile rides. What I see all too often is people getting caught up in the marketing and spending 10 bucks a ride on crap they dont need. None of it 'improves' your performance, its all to replenish electrolytes and ingest calories. If your not depleting your glycogen stores you dont need to worry about replenishing them while on the bike. Depleting them takes close to 3 hours. Anything 2 hours and less save it for after the ride and eat real food, that has taste and enjoyment to it, and costs less.

I see people go on 2 hour rides and they start with a sportsdrink to hydrate prior to the ride, eat 4 gells, a cliff bar or 2, add in 2 bottles of water mixed with accelerade/cytomax, then have a designer recovery drink costing a few bucks. You can drive a car the same distance for cheaper. And they would have rode the same without it all.

I remember reading a thread once about some poor guy's first century. Apparently he ate (consumed) eight (8) powerbars during the course of the ride. I LOLed.

DataJunkie 03-17-08 02:36 PM

ew.

Did he finish relatively fast or just constipate?

My stomach tends to be fairly unreceptive to solid foods after 70 miles. That would easily make me sick.

recursive 03-17-08 02:38 PM


Originally Posted by DataJunkie (Post 6359603)
ew.

Did he finish relatively fast or just constipate?

My stomach tends to be fairly unreceptive to solid foods after 70 miles. That would easily make me sick.

I seem to recall that he did indeed finish, but under some gastro-intestinal distress.

wfrogge 03-17-08 02:44 PM


Originally Posted by LifeIsSuffering (Post 6352652)
I prefer to take in one gel every half hour. My body seems to absorb it faster than solid food (don't know if there's any science behind that). This, along with Cytomax, fulfills my caloric needs, generally speaking.

One of my friends prefers the Cliff bar; every 20 minutes or so, he'll take just a nibble. This might be an option if you prefer the type of calories that you chew on.

As far as which brand, that's pretty subjective. I like Hammer gel apple for the flavor; however, I also use the Powerbar gel 4x sodium on the summer rides because I'm what is referred as a salty sweater. You'll have to experiment to see which brand works for you.

And don't forget the traditional options such as bananas, potatoes, sandwiches. Depending the length of your ride, it can't hurt to take in some protein (liquid or solid).


Every half hour along with Cytomax??? Hello weight gain!

snoboard2 03-17-08 02:44 PM


Originally Posted by Phantoj (Post 6356791)
what do the kooks who do RAAM eat?

Mcdonalds and cans of beanee weanees

wfrogge 03-17-08 02:47 PM


Originally Posted by snoboard2 (Post 6359660)
Mcdonalds and cans of beanee weanees


You are not far off to be honest......


Burning calories like they do it would require a lot of "healthy" food to get what they need. So much that they would be eating non-stop.

recursive 03-17-08 02:59 PM


Originally Posted by wfrogge (Post 6359653)
Every half hour along with Cytomax??? Hello weight gain!

Not really. Gels are about 100 calories per. You'd still be operating at a net loss even with any reasonable amount of cytomax.

merlinextraligh 03-17-08 03:53 PM


Originally Posted by recursive (Post 6359744)
Not really. Gels are about 100 calories per. You'd still be operating at a net loss even with any reasonable amount of cytomax.

General rule of thumb is you can process about 300 calories an hour. So with a reasonable amount of Cytomax you'd be on that target.

Of course it depends on length and intensity of the ride. 100 mile plus race in the mountains, you need to eat like that early, or you'll pay late.

30 mile training ride, you eat like that, you are likely to gain weight.

botto 03-17-08 04:03 PM


Originally Posted by recursive (Post 6359620)
I seem to recall that he did indeed finish, but under some gastro-intestinal distress.

dysentery, as ol' marble mouth ligget likes to refer to it.

rogerstg 03-17-08 05:51 PM


Originally Posted by s4one (Post 6351089)
Bars seem annoying to consume so I probably will look into gels. What gels do you guys recommend?

I like the Hammer apple and cinnamon flavor. I bring a gel on my 25ish mile daily rides in case I bonk. I'm still dieting so I don't always have a surplus of glycogen. I learned the hard way that if I push it at that point recovery is a bear. The gels seem to work within minutes.

On a 40 mile ride I usually bring along a couple fig newtons. I usually stop briefly at about 20 miles to eat one. Gels are easier for me to eat while riding.

bad_mojo 03-17-08 06:31 PM

I prefer to eat candy on my bike in all honesty. I'm no nutritionist but the labels look similar. Milk duds really lend themselves well to eating on a ride what with the nifty little box and they taste better than any bar or gel I've come across.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:56 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.