Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   How Can the Sub9 Produce Negative Drag? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/405391-how-can-sub9-produce-negative-drag.html)

ProFail 04-07-08 08:40 PM

How Can the Sub9 Produce Negative Drag?
 
In other words, if you threw the wheel through a gravityless chamber, even if the chamber had air, the Sub9 would suposedly accelerate endlessly. I by no means am a physics genius, but isn't (EDIT- I'm questioning this, as in IT'S IMPOSSIBLE.)


A) Perpetual motion impossible
and
B) It impossible for an object with surface area to have zero (or less than) drag?

Voodoo76 04-07-08 08:43 PM

A new source of renewable energy? Just build a giant Sub9 and hook a generator to it.

ElJamoquio 04-07-08 08:46 PM


Originally Posted by ProFail (Post 6479140)
In other words, if you threw the wheel through a gravityless chamber, even if the chamber had air, the Sub9 would suposedly accelerate endlessly. I by no means am a physics genius, but isn't


A) Perpetual motion impossible
and
B) Impossible for an object with surface area to have zero (or less than) drag?

The earth is flat, sailboats cannot make headway against the wind, and the Dallas Cowboys are America's team.

elemental 04-07-08 08:46 PM

It can't.

ravenmore 04-07-08 08:52 PM

uhm - what's a sub9?

ProFail 04-07-08 08:53 PM


Originally Posted by elemental (Post 6479171)
It can't.

So why is Zipp saying it can?

ProFail 04-07-08 08:54 PM


Originally Posted by ravenmore (Post 6479212)
uhm - what's a sub9?

Disc wheel.

mrt10x 04-07-08 08:56 PM

use search

Fat Boy 04-07-08 09:00 PM


Originally Posted by ProFail (Post 6479217)
So why is Zipp saying it can?

You sell more.

There is _no_ way that a wheel makes true thrust. I've done a fair bit of aerodynamic testing (tunnels and real world). It ain't F'n happenin'.

What sucks is that all they have to say is 'It's really, really good', which is true. But, no, that's not good enough. They have to say that it violates the 2nd law of thermodynamics. Sorry folks, you don't get _anything_ for free.

Fat Boy 04-07-08 09:01 PM


Originally Posted by ElJamoquio (Post 6479167)
The earth is flat, sailboats cannot make headway against the wind, and the Dallas Cowboys are America's team.

And your engineering degree is from where?

scotch 04-07-08 09:01 PM

for $4k a set, they should provide sexual favors along with the negative drag.

AEO 04-07-08 09:05 PM


Originally Posted by ElJamoquio (Post 6479167)
The earth is flat, sailboats cannot make headway against the wind, and the Dallas Cowboys are America's team.

The earth is flat - That's not what the last hill I had to go up said.
sailboats cannot make headway against the wind - Modern designs zig zag into the wind.
the Dallas Cowboys are America's team - Who?

As for the "negative drag" I think the marketing department couldn't understand what the engineers were saying.

Dubbayoo 04-07-08 09:12 PM

If you buy one Fabian Cancellara rides beside you and gives you a push.

ElJamoquio 04-07-08 09:13 PM


Originally Posted by Fat Boy (Post 6479264)
And your engineering degree is from where?

Which one?

ElJamoquio 04-07-08 09:16 PM


Originally Posted by Fat Boy (Post 6479260)
You sell more.

There is _no_ way that a wheel makes true thrust. I've done a fair bit of aerodynamic testing (tunnels and real world). It ain't F'n happenin'.

What sucks is that all they have to say is 'It's really, really good', which is true. But, no, that's not good enough. They have to say that it violates the 2nd law of thermodynamics. Sorry folks, you don't get _anything_ for free.

Sorry, but no.

ElJamoquio 04-07-08 09:18 PM


Originally Posted by AEO (Post 6479301)
The earth is flat - That's not what the last hill I had to go up said.
sailboats cannot make headway against the wind - Modern designs zig zag into the wind.
the Dallas Cowboys are America's team - Who?

Two out of three ain't bad.

AEO 04-07-08 09:19 PM

I like it when people use big words they don't understand, like the marketing department for sub9s and thermodynamics. :D

BarracksSi 04-07-08 09:26 PM

Zipp's side of it is that at a given angle of attack from the wind, the wheel gains some lift, in a sense similar to a Frisbee or a sailboat's sail.

Possible? Sure, probably. Worth my money? HA. My inherent drag will negate any possible benefit. ;)

Bike enthusiast 04-07-08 09:31 PM

^^^ We should all carry sails with us then!!!!!! :)

Cdy291 04-07-08 09:31 PM

At the right speed and wind angle its as if it wasn't there.

AEO 04-07-08 09:38 PM


Originally Posted by Bike enthusiast (Post 6479453)
^^^ We should all carry sails with us then!!!!!! :)

You need a fin, not just the sail actually :D

essentially you have one wing sticking in the wind and the other wing in the water which makes a sail boat that generates lift and propels it upward, but the angle the ship tilts at makes it go forward.

Bnjmn 04-07-08 09:49 PM

This may help- http://nyvelocity.com/article.aspx?ID=2125&CID=54

oilman_15106 04-07-08 10:14 PM


Originally Posted by BarracksSi (Post 6479430)
Zipp's side of it is that at a given angle of attack from the wind, the wheel gains some lift, in a sense similar to a Frisbee or a sailboat's sail.

Possible? Sure, probably. Worth my money? HA. My inherent drag will negate any possible benefit. ;)

If that is the case pretty soon we will start seeing rear spoilers on bikes.

BarracksSi 04-07-08 10:17 PM


Originally Posted by Bnjmn (Post 6479535)

Neat. Also his prior article:
http://www.velocitynation.com/articl...ID=1755&CID=54

Interesting how Zipp arrived at that shape by building the bulge to reinforce their disc wheel for a clincher rim.

And in his closing in the first article, "So in the end we're talking about an $1875 wheel with undeniable geek appeal that saves you 24 seconds over 40k." Somebody will find value there, just not me.

BarracksSi 04-07-08 10:19 PM


Originally Posted by oilman_15106 (Post 6479688)
If that is the case pretty soon we will start seeing rear spoilers on bikes.

I have seen modified kites used for propulsion on bikes. Kind of like windsurfing or kite boarding, only drier. ;)


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:52 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.