Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   SRM + Garmin = deal? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/451714-srm-garmin-deal.html)

merlinextraligh 08-08-08 08:03 AM

SRM + Garmin = deal?
 
This struck me as a very good deal.

http://www.competitivecyclist.com/ro..._67_FALSE.html

At that price, it's not much more than a wireless ANT+ compatible powertap plus Garmin, built up with a nice wheel.

I can't imagine your missing that much from the 2009 Dura Ace SRM, and it's $500 cheaper, and you get the Garmin to boot.

Now what can I get for a wired PT SL built up with a Zipp 404?

azdroptop 08-08-08 08:53 AM

Wow. 3500! That is some serious cash!

simplyred 08-08-08 09:05 AM

Pretty sweet deal [relative to SRMs].

Makes you wonder how much SRM believes their PowerControl is worth. [like 850 on CC - yes?]
The Garmin is 710 on CC.

140 dollar difference between computers.
425 dollar difference between combinations.

Somebody's accountant is going to get in trouble.

biffstephens 08-08-08 09:06 AM


Originally Posted by merlinextraligh (Post 7231601)
This struck me as a very good deal.

http://www.competitivecyclist.com/ro..._67_FALSE.html

At that price, it's not much more than a wireless ANT+ compatible powertap plus Garmin, built up with a nice wheel.

I can't imagine your missing that much from the 2009 Dura Ace SRM, and it's $500 cheaper, and you get the Garmin to boot.

Now what can I get for a wired PT SL built up with a Zipp 404?


Ouch....but I guess your right...still OUCH!!!

bdcheung 08-08-08 09:08 AM

Excel has it with free overnight shipping
http://www.excelsports.com/new.asp?p...jor=3&minor=15

and you also get CyclingPeaks ($99 value)

for $10 less.

merlinextraligh 08-08-08 09:12 AM

Do you think there jsut trying to clear out 2008 inventory, in front of DA 7900?

Anything you're giving up going with the 2008 version?

bdcheung 08-08-08 09:14 AM

DA7900 cranks are not compatible with the SRM spider, so you won't see any. The pricing is what it is, and will likely go up as the supply of 7800 cranks dwindles.

kensuf 08-08-08 12:46 PM

Why not get a CinQo and 705? The extra $1k left over could be used for all sorts of goodies.

bdcheung 08-08-08 12:50 PM

Because CinQo is first-generation, and I'd rather sink my money in tenured technology.

/hence why I didn't buy the first-generation iPhone

Booger 08-08-08 12:53 PM

SRM does not belong in the same sentence as the word "deal."

foretexas 08-08-08 12:58 PM

I think they are trying to clear them out for this.

http://www.saris.com/athletes/Commen...931e27920.aspx


http://www.velonews.com/article/77542


With the price of a 705, and a Powertap. I think you could get in for under $2,000.

kensuf 08-08-08 01:21 PM


Originally Posted by bdcheung (Post 7233512)
Because CinQo is first-generation, and I'd rather sink my money in tenured technology.

/hence why I didn't buy the first-generation iPhone

Oh right, the Garmin 705 has been on the market for so long now. ;)

And, FWIW, the two guys I know with 705s have had some weird glitches, but love them.

bdcheung 08-08-08 01:25 PM

To add another data point, I've not had any glitches with my 705.

kensuf 08-08-08 02:13 PM


Originally Posted by bdcheung (Post 7233794)
To add another data point, I've not had any glitches with my 705.

And the ANT+SPORT SRM has been on the market for awhile too. ;)

bdcheung 08-08-08 02:16 PM

I can use the wireless SRM with a regular wired PC V if need be. Redundancy ftw.

kensuf 08-08-08 02:25 PM


Originally Posted by bdcheung (Post 7234181)
I can use the wireless SRM with a regular wired PC V if need be. Redundancy ftw.

Yeah but think about the wasted grams. Granted, it's probably not much more than you'd drop by drinking a cup of coffee and taking a dump in the morning, but OCP correctness requires that every component be strictly weighed and minimized accordingly.

:lol:

Oh yeah, and the original post mentioned nothing about using a PC V (because the combo doesn't come with it). So now add $750 to the $3600 price -vs- the CinQo/705 combo at around $2100.

WheresWaldo 08-08-08 06:13 PM


Originally Posted by kensuf (Post 7234243)
Yeah but think about the wasted grams. Granted, it's probably not much more than you'd drop by drinking a cup of coffee and taking a dump in the morning, but OCP correctness requires that every component be strictly weighed and minimized accordingly.

:lol:

Oh yeah, and the original post mentioned nothing about using a PC V (because the combo doesn't come with it). So now add $750 to the $3600 price -vs- the CinQo/705 combo at around $2100.

But the CinQo is only available with some pretty crappy crank sets contributing to much of the price difference, not anything near DA quality. Now gen 2 of the CinQo might be worth waiting for.

mkbruch 08-14-08 02:59 PM


Originally Posted by WheresWaldo (Post 7235506)
But the CinQo is only available with some pretty crappy crank sets contributing to much of the price difference, not anything near DA quality. Now gen 2 of the CinQo might be worth waiting for.

FYI, The FSA cranks that SRM uses are the same ones Quarq uses, just labeled differently. https://www.srm.de/store_usa/product...ional-FSA.html

If you compare just the sensor and cranks, without a computer, the CinQo still about 1/2 the cost. So it's not necessarily the cranks that are contributing to the price difference. :)

We plan to introduce CinQos compatible with the Specialized S-Works, Cannondale Hollowgram SI, Rotor Agilis and Lightning (when they get to market) cranks this Fall.

Mieke
Quarq Technology

botto 08-14-08 03:05 PM

SRM = über kool

Garmin = über fred

merlinextraligh 08-14-08 04:57 PM

In general, I'd agree. However if you're using the 705 Head Unit to replace the SRM head unit, adding next to no weight, picking up some functions, and costs less than just the SRM unit, it seems like you're ahead with the garmin head unit.

pegleg 08-14-08 05:40 PM


Originally Posted by botto (Post 7272841)
Garmin = über fred

I got your über fred right here...

http://www.cyclingweekly.co.uk/image...6ispa-0017.jpg

bdcheung 08-14-08 06:29 PM

yeah but he gets paid to use it.

WheresWaldo 08-14-08 06:55 PM


Originally Posted by mkbruch (Post 7272810)
FYI, The FSA cranks that SRM uses are the same ones Quarq uses, just labeled differently. https://www.srm.de/store_usa/product...ional-FSA.html

If you compare just the sensor and cranks, without a computer, the CinQo still about 1/2 the cost. So it's not necessarily the cranks that are contributing to the price difference. :)

We plan to introduce CinQos compatible with the Specialized S-Works, Cannondale Hollowgram SI, Rotor Agilis and Lightning (when they get to market) cranks this Fall.

Mieke
Quarq Technology

Not going to argue that you guys will have some awesome stuff in the future, but SRM is available now with DA and Cannondale SI cranksets, not just the FSA you mentioned. Your CinQo on SI cranks will be something to wait for!

mkbruch 08-14-08 11:33 PM


Originally Posted by WheresWaldo (Post 7274136)
Not going to argue that you guys will have some awesome stuff in the future, but SRM is available now with DA and Cannondale SI cranksets, not just the FSA you mentioned. Your CinQo on SI cranks will be something to wait for!

If you are comparing the number of choices between us and SRM, they obviously have more options to choose from at the moment. I just didn't want folks to think that the price difference between our powermeter and theirs was because of the cranks.

We'll be getting additional versions out as soon as we can, but most likely the next ones will be this fall.

Mieke
Quarq Technology

botto 08-15-08 03:10 AM


Originally Posted by pegleg (Post 7273661)
I got your über fred right here...

[IMG]ht tp://www.c yclingweekly.co.uk/imageBank/0/080416ispa-0017.jpg[/IMG]

you're boring me.


Originally Posted by bdcheung (Post 7273958)
yeah but he gets paid to use it.

exactly.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:15 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.