Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Thomson Masterpiece... (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/462036-thomson-masterpiece.html)

lung 09-05-08 07:10 AM

Thomson Masterpiece...
 
Ordered today for my new Ridley. The Ridley has a 31.6 post...(my previous ride was a 27.2) a GREAT excuse to get a new Thomson. This is the only place where you can write enthusiastically about a seat post and people "getit"! Is this a great country or what!

RudeSiggy 09-05-08 07:22 AM

...and its also the only place someone would be jealous of a... seatpost.

i want a thomson.

Hammertoe 09-05-08 07:23 AM

Thomson Masterpiece on all my road bikes...

And an Elite on my cross bike...

Love 'em (although it is a seatpost)...

WheresWaldo 09-05-08 07:25 AM


Originally Posted by Hammertoe (Post 7405998)
Thomson Masterpiece on all my road bikes...

And an Elite on my cross bike...

Love 'em (although it is a seatpost)...

If you could love and inanimate object I guess it might as well be a Thomson seat post. Except there is no love for the setback version.

Hammertoe 09-05-08 07:29 AM


Originally Posted by WheresWaldo (Post 7406012)
Except there is no love for the setback version.

All mine are non-setback...

No love for the setback version!!!

lung 09-05-08 07:30 AM

Mine... of course... is NON-setback.:love:

WheresWaldo 09-05-08 07:33 AM


Originally Posted by Hammertoe (Post 7406027)
All mine are non-setback...

No love for the setback version!!!

Fugly :(

And not enough setback (only 16 mm).

Sinn 09-05-08 08:15 AM

What Ridley are you getting?

I've never fondled a Masterpiece, or ridden one, but I do have Elites. Great posts. I love the seatclamp mechanisms.

CastIron 09-05-08 08:16 AM

A word of caution about the Masterpiece: Due to sizing vagaries, it may not be lighter than an Elite. In my case it was like 3 grams.

Caveat emptor.

Still a heckuva product either way.

lung 09-05-08 08:26 AM


Originally Posted by Sinn (Post 7406321)
What Ridley are you getting?

I've never fondled a Masterpiece, or ridden one, but I do have Elites. Great posts. I love the seatclamp mechanisms.

Excalibur. I love the sloping geometry, the stiffness... and the gigantic downtube. A great price on a great frameset.

bigtea 09-05-08 08:42 AM

Just a week ago I replaced my Ritchey Carbon Comp (came with my new bike last spring) with the Thomson I had on my old bike. It was a huge improvement My Litespeed now has a unitary, solid feeling that I did not have with the carbon post. No sqeaks, no clicks, no vibration; it's as if my frame has been extended to my saddle.

stilgore 09-05-08 09:33 AM

Congrats on the new ride and seatpost!!

I have REALLY! been thinking about ordering the new Noah but I am a little hesitant not having a chance to ride one. There are no Ridley dealers near me.

Stil

dalava 09-05-08 11:05 AM

I know I want one too to replace my Ritchey Carbon Pro, but not sure why. Anyone can enlighten me on the greatness, of which I have no doubts, of Thomson posts?

RIC0 09-05-08 11:12 AM

I have thomson stem and seatpost on my mountain bike but MUST have carbon bling on the road bike. Thomson claims you save 40 grams between elite and masterpiece but yet there's a $60 price difference. :twitchy:

CharlieWoo 09-05-08 11:12 AM

I use the Elite with them set-forward. Very solid.

tekhna 09-05-08 11:13 AM

Where are people finding these Excalibur framesets so cheap? It seems like a lot of them have been popping up.

CastIron 09-05-08 11:16 AM


Originally Posted by dalava (Post 7407550)
I know I want one too to replace my Ritchey Carbon Pro, but not sure why. Anyone can enlighten me on the greatness, of which I have no doubts, of Thomson posts?


Thomson isn't so much great as rare in this world.

It's as light (often lighter) than most carbon posts.

It works, not that it's hard for a post, though an amazing number of companies really butcher the job.

It's reasonably priced (more or less).

It's still made by machinists in the U.S. by a family company that actually supports cycling.

How many other production component manufacturers still fit that bill?

bigtea 09-05-08 11:17 AM


Originally Posted by RIC0 (Post 7407603)
I have thomson stem and seatpost on my mountain bike but MUST have carbon bling on the road bike. Thomson claims you save 40 grams between elite and masterpiece but yet there's a $60 price difference. :twitchy:

Bling is right..carbon provides no functional benefit in the case of a seatpost.

Booger 09-05-08 12:08 PM


Originally Posted by CastIron (Post 7407632)
Thomson isn't so much great as rare in this world.

It's as light (often lighter) than most carbon posts.

It works, not that it's hard for a post, though an amazing number of companies really butcher the job.

It's reasonably priced (more or less).

It's still made by machinists in the U.S. by a family company that actually supports cycling.

How many other production component manufacturers still fit that bill?


A recipe for awesome. I come from a background in manufacturing and am horribly cynical about the whole process ("who needs engineers or production facilities when we have stickers, paint, and ads?"), but Thomson is one of the few companies I will go out of my way to support.

Namenda 09-05-08 12:16 PM


Originally Posted by dalava (Post 7407550)
I know I want one too to replace my Ritchey Carbon Pro, but not sure why. Anyone can enlighten me on the greatness, of which I have no doubts, of Thomson posts?

I have the Ritchey Carbon Pro on my road bike, and a Thomson on my mtb. The Thomson is everything everyone says it is, set-it and forget-it. Looks good, if you like simple black alloy. Fairly utilitarian, but what more do you need in a seatpost?

I really like my Ritchey. The only drawback is that the bolts are 6mm, unlike everything else on my bike, and I don't want to carry another allen key just for the seatpost. I have a double-ended allen key that I carry (4mm on one end, 5mm on the other) that I could use to tear down essentially my entire bike, if necessary. I don't know why Ritchey has to be contrary in this regard.

lung 09-05-08 01:09 PM

it's funny... I have a brand new Ridley carbon race rocket framset... brand new ZIPP 303 tubulars that have yet to tough pavement... and I'm talking about my seatpost! Thomson rocks.

Sinn 09-05-08 01:56 PM

Does anyone here have an argument about functionality that would press me to get a Thomson road stem over another brand, say, Deda or Ritchey, of comparable price or more?

dalava 09-05-08 03:00 PM


Originally Posted by CastIron (Post 7407632)
Thomson isn't so much great as rare in this world.

It's as light (often lighter) than most carbon posts.

It works, not that it's hard for a post, though an amazing number of companies really butcher the job.

It's reasonably priced (more or less).

It's still made by machinists in the U.S. by a family company that actually supports cycling.

How many other production component manufacturers still fit that bill?

I love the "all-business, no nonsense" look of their seatpost, yet it conveys precision and reliability. Come think of it, it's almost like the Scotty Cameron putter in golf; it's the sum of all that small great qualities makes them very desirable. I am sold. eBay, here I come.

dalava 09-05-08 04:13 PM

A really stupid/lazy question, what size is my seatpost for a Scott CR1?

BananaTugger 09-05-08 05:40 PM

http://lh4.ggpht.com/ilguslo/SMBdS-G...6/P9040278.JPG

http://lh3.ggpht.com/ilguslo/SMBdQzL...6/P9040276.JPG

http://lh4.ggpht.com/ilguslo/SMBdRwl...6/P9040277.JPG


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:34 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.