Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Madone Failure (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/626149-madone-failure.html)

Nate552 03-05-10 06:36 AM


Originally Posted by botto (Post 10483654)
wookie legs break treks.

:lol:

SteelCan 03-05-10 07:04 AM


Originally Posted by caloso (Post 10483435)
I'm wondering if something like that would be covered by Trek's warranty.

Ahh, It's gonna be a great day. That simple comment referenced so much history that I had a genuine LOL roflmaoooooooooo moment.

BTW I never commented in that historical thread, but my personal opinion is that if it was a mfr defect during the mfr process, the frame should have been warrantied - even though it was purchased second-hand. If WR would have been in a crash due to that defect, he would have a good case of liability against Trek regardless that it was 2nd hand.

ComesATime71 03-05-10 07:17 AM

"My old man is a television repairman, he's got this ultimate set of tools. I can fix it"

a_thomasmr23 03-05-10 07:33 AM

So there the threaded part is glued in to opening then the bb is threaded into it? If thats the case then the there doesn't need to be much area to glue it on too because the bb bearings should let the cranks rotate freely

waterrockets 03-05-10 07:56 AM


Originally Posted by wanders (Post 10483275)
What did you expect? The candy coated shell on that thing had been compromised.

:roflmao:


Originally Posted by Hunt-man (Post 10483286)
What size is the frame?

60


Originally Posted by punkncat (Post 10483304)
Just out of curiousity, would you mind posting a pic of the other side for comparison?

Both sides are in there. At some point I flipped the frame over and started shooting. They both look the same, just flaked epoxy. No cracks.


Originally Posted by Racer Ex (Post 10483307)
6. He's been hoping to squeeze into a 4 before the prom.

Great, now when I show up in an 8 everyone's going to giggle.


Originally Posted by plasticmaam12 (Post 10483537)
So, you are trying to repair the frame now? Your definition of disgust must be quite different than mine.

No, I'm thinking about selling it with full disclosure.


Originally Posted by Metzinger (Post 10483583)
First photos are the left side. Last photo is right.
WR needs to make friends in the performance sailing crowd. I14s etc.
Those guys eat CF repairwork for breakfast.

Correct about the photos. Regarding the Madone, I'm done with it.


Originally Posted by KiddSisko (Post 10483607)
I could fix that frame. JB Weld would definitely take part, as would a sheet of CF cloth. The following picture showing a possible crack through the bearing support diameter bothers me most. If that is cracked, then nothing can be done except use the frame as trolling fodder for the foreseeable future.

Yeah, that's just a flake.

The term is 'bait', like this:

I'd have had better light for the photos, but I recently changed all my extension cord storage to coiled, and I couldn't get any of them untangled in time for the photo shoot.


Originally Posted by botto (Post 10483654)
wookie legs break treks.

akworcacraakc rooohuwhrr'c scoowahuanhuc wwoorc aoacahc rrrcrawawo ooww oararcrhoowh wwahrhworc ahc aooooo ohworaor? akooccahrhanro aoacwo anrarohuak ohrac ahwhchuwwwwahoaahwowhao, oorc scrarorhwo aoacwo rrhuro ohacoo rhhuahanao ahao ohrac aorcroahwhrr aooo rrwoao acooscwo aooo acahc akoorcwh.


Originally Posted by gsteinb (Post 10483730)
pffft. I'd have torn the shell clear ****ing off. HTFU

This is why I didn't post this in the 33. I was hoping you wouldn't call me out for only breaking it loose. :o


Originally Posted by ComesATime71 (Post 10483880)
"My old man is a television repairman, he's got this ultimate set of tools. I can fix it"

http://www.ridelust.com/wp-content/u...emont_high.jpg

lazerzxr 03-05-10 08:03 AM

I thought Trek gave a life time warranty, cant it just go back for a replacement? Or am i being a bit nieve on that one?

availpunk9 03-05-10 08:06 AM

^He's not original owner. Trek told him to beat it.

Nate552 03-05-10 08:16 AM


Originally Posted by waterrockets (Post 10483206)
Background story for the imaginary BFer who hasn't heard it: my 4-year-old Madone died when the BB shell came loose inside the frame. A repair attempt was made, but it didn't hold.


Originally Posted by lazerzxr (Post 10484032)
I thought Trek gave a life time warranty, cant it just go back for a replacement? Or am i being a bit nieve on that one?

Found one!

gsteinb 03-05-10 08:17 AM


Originally Posted by lazerzxr (Post 10484032)
I thought Trek gave a life time warranty, cant it just go back for a replacement? Or am i being a bit nieve on that one?

http://cultivatingcareers.files.word...nched_fist.jpg.

?

Daytrip 03-05-10 08:20 AM

Even though it's second hand, maybe you can work something out with Trek. Maybe a discount on a new frame?

That sounds about right.

Quel 03-05-10 08:23 AM


Originally Posted by lazerzxr (Post 10484032)
I thought Trek gave a life time warranty, cant it just go back for a replacement? Or am i being a bit nieve on that one?

I agree. WR should just contact Trek about it. I'm sure they will help him out, even though it isn't the original owner. They seem like nice guys. :innocent:

BikesAreCool123 03-05-10 09:32 AM


Originally Posted by Quel (Post 10484109)
I agree. WR should just contact Trek about it. I'm sure they will help him out, even though it isn't the original owner. They seem like nice guys. :innocent:

This is an excellent idea. Keep us updated WR.

waterrockets 03-05-10 09:36 AM

Better idea. Who here wants to buy it and work out the non-original-owner warranty with Trek? I'm taking bids.

Hunt-man 03-05-10 09:49 AM

$10.00 but no more.... Would be a good wall hanger.

JohnDThompson 03-05-10 10:15 AM


Originally Posted by Hunt-man (Post 10483515)
Slip some duct tape in there and put er back together, good as new.

Nah, this is a carbon fiber frame, so we need to go high-tech with the repair. Use fiber reinforced strapping tape instead.

YOJiMBO20 03-05-10 10:24 AM


Originally Posted by Hunt-man (Post 10484506)
$10.00 but no more.... Would be a good wall hanger.

I'll give you $10.01

waterrockets 03-05-10 10:28 AM

...
http://cache.gawkerassets.com/assets...dingwar_01.jpg

crash66 03-05-10 10:34 AM

Oh, for a minute there I thought you were talking about a frame getting damaged.

Remember, folks: water rockets don't work unless they're topped off with a lot of air.

waterrockets 03-05-10 10:47 AM

Good one. That'll teach me :rolleyes:

Voodoo76 03-05-10 10:55 AM


Originally Posted by JohnDThompson (Post 10484612)
Nah, this is a carbon fiber frame, so we need to go high-tech with the repair. Use fiber reinforced strapping tape instead.

Gorilla Tape. Has a lot higher thread count.

coasting 03-05-10 11:14 AM

this didn't get damaged. this is a manufacturing flaw. trek should stand by their product.

Am i right, waterrocket?

bostongarden 03-05-10 11:23 AM


Originally Posted by lazerzxr (Post 10484032)
I thought Trek gave a life time warranty, cant it just go back for a replacement? Or am i being a bit nieve on that one?

You are not being "nieve." However, were you to believe that x-bar (the sample mean) were to equal mu (the true population mean), then you would be naïve.

Ygduf 03-05-10 11:33 AM


Originally Posted by waterrockets (Post 10484439)
Better idea. Who here wants to buy it and work out the non-original-owner warranty with Trek? I'm taking bids.

You just need to ***** loudly enough on Twitter/Facebook/internets that they decide it's better to make it a positive story than a "treks break" trend.

KiddSisko 03-05-10 01:45 PM


Originally Posted by waterrockets (Post 10483999)
I recently changed all my extension cord storage to coiled, and I couldn't get any of them untangled in time for the photo shoot.

Coiled: big mistake.

P.S. your recent head smack certainly hasn't hurt your memory.:thumb:

ultraman6970 03-05-10 02:57 PM

Brano Meres can tell you how to fix that, he has done that a few times already.

http://www.bmeres.com/


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:17 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.