Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Out of the saddle is tough (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/655824-out-saddle-tough.html)

GarySMelbourne 06-20-10 04:49 PM

draft while climbing
 
Umd...do you find any benefit to drafting while climbing or does the climb itself neglect any effect of the draft?

Nice video.

umd 06-20-10 04:51 PM


Originally Posted by kleinboogie (Post 10991584)
He was probably maintaining a relatively constant power so 250W on a climb may be say 10mph but that same 250W on the flat may be 22mph. That versus what most people do which is 350W on the climb then have to recover on the top and drop to 200W. These numbers are just for demonstration purposes, yours may vary.

Yeah, I see that a lot. Optimum pacing strategy for time trials is generally to do flats at FTP (or appropropriate critical power for the duration of the event), climbs a tiny bit above, and descents a tiny bit below. People that are JRA tend to push harder on hills and rest on flats. A power meter is great for learning all this stuff about yourself.


Originally Posted by bianchi10 (Post 10991638)
umd-that was a good video to watch, thanks for sharing that. What kind of video system are you using?

It is a Contour HD, and I use DashWare to overlay the data from my Garmin Edge 705/Quarq CinQo.

umd 06-20-10 04:53 PM


Originally Posted by chasm54 (Post 10991595)
Thanks, nice video. Quite a climb. My ancient engine would struggle to stay with you guys, I'm afraid. How did you do?

I did ok the first two times up it, couldn't stay with the attacks the last time up and got 25th of 73.
http://connect.garmin.com/activity/37474096

umd 06-20-10 04:54 PM


Originally Posted by GarySMelbourne (Post 10991700)
Umd...do you find any benefit to drafting while climbing or does the climb itself neglect any effect of the draft?

You always benefit somewhat from a Draft. It is much lower at 10mph but it is not negligible.

roadiejorge 06-20-10 06:27 PM

I've been practicing riding out of the saddle a lot more when on climbs and so long as you pace yourself and don't burn out early it's a really handy way to give yourself that final push once you're close to the end of the climb.

SteelCan 06-20-10 07:03 PM

UMD, Thanx for the video clip. I also enjoyed the harmonic "whooshing" tone.
Was that shot with a VHoldr? (Sounded great without wind noise) Or did you also do some audio tweaking/noise cancellation editing?

DScott 06-20-10 09:09 PM


Originally Posted by rousseau (Post 10991243)
Yeah, I'll definitely stand up more. But I'm guessing that shedding a few saddle bags will be the key here.

Yeah, if you make a point of getting out of the saddle more, you get better at it, no matter what your weight.


Great video, umd! What a beautiful place to ride!

shelleyspins 06-20-10 09:49 PM


Originally Posted by umd (Post 10991345)
In addition, many people push harder when they are out of the saddle, making it "harder". But you don't have to. Do some drills concentrating on standing and going easier, and then you will detrain the standing = go harder response.

Thanks for this, it totally makes sense. The video is very nice, again thank you.

umd 06-20-10 10:38 PM


Originally Posted by SteelCan (Post 10992210)
UMD, Thanx for the video clip. I also enjoyed the harmonic "whooshing" tone.
Was that shot with a VHoldr? (Sounded great without wind noise) Or did you also do some audio tweaking/noise cancellation editing?

Yes, VHoldr Contour HD 720. No auddio tweaking, there isn't much wind noise cause we weren't going that fast ;)


Originally Posted by shelleyspins (Post 10992932)
The video is very nice, again thank you.


Originally Posted by DScott (Post 10992782)
Great video, umd! What a beautiful place to ride!

Thanks. I had never been up there but I had heard how nice it was. I couldn't really appreciate it much while hypoxic so I'm glad I have the videos to review. I will probably post some descent in the ride video thread tomorrow.

thump55 06-21-10 06:37 AM

When climbing out of the saddle, you have a smaller "cadence zone" than while seated. It requires more shifting to stay in that zone.

You may be able to do a climb (or section of a climb) seated, in one or two gears. That same climb done standing may require 3-4 gears.

mathwheels 06-21-10 07:09 AM


Originally Posted by umd (Post 10991345)
In addition, many people push harder when they are out of the saddle, making it "harder". But you don't have to. Do some drills concentrating on standing and going easier, and then you will detrain the standing = go harder response.

+1 big time

When I first started I would put in to hard of an effort out of the saddle and I was only able to be up for short distances. legs killing and totally out of wind. Almost like an attack, just poor technique being new to riding road. Then when i sat down I was just shot and recovering spinning in lowest gear. I have found that you really do need to find YOUR pace up hills out of the saddle and get in good peddle/breathing rhythm. It might be in lowest gear at 5 mph on steep inclines but you will be to sustain much longer and recover much faster.

My pace is slower up hill than my riding buddies but I make it to the top in reasonable time, I am not maxed out and able to push pace back to them on ensuing flat. I am getting better each ride on hills.

echappist 06-21-10 10:34 AM


Originally Posted by umd (Post 10991711)
You always benefit somewhat from a Draft. It is much lower at 10mph but it is not negligible.

not to mention that if gets breezy on the way up, you still get shielded

bloomieracer 06-21-10 10:40 AM

Nice video! I like to stay on the seat as much as possible personally and move forward for climbs. One reason I've stuck with my Serfas Furnano saddle, nice long nose.

7bmwm3gtr 06-21-10 11:19 AM

I find no benefit in standing while climbing, unless I'm shifting up. For me, I get better results seated. I shift up one or two times and stand when I reach a switchback though.

Oh and just because your light, doesn't mean climbing is going to be easy. I'm 120 lbs, I still have a hard time climbing sometimes. And the reason for that, is that I need more power to the push.

But my goal is to make climbing my primary strength. I'm surrounded by hills anyways.

DScott 06-21-10 02:11 PM

There's a difference between a short power-burst over the top of a hill and long sustained climbs out of the saddle. This is how the latter is done:




I love this guy's videos...

rumrunn6 06-21-10 02:57 PM

riding and climbing out of the saddle, like spinning at a higher cadence are both techniques I found challenging and requiring practice but I've found that getting better with these techniques has improved my performance and enjoyment quite a bit. keep at it and you'll get better! :)

chasm54 06-21-10 03:01 PM


Originally Posted by 7bmwm3gtr (Post 10995273)
Oh and just because your light, doesn't mean climbing is going to be easy. I'm 120 lbs, I still have a hard time climbing sometimes. And the reason for that, is that I need more power to the push.

But you can train for power. To weigh 120 lbs I'd have to amputate an arm and a leg, and I don't think that's going to help.

deep_sky 06-21-10 03:57 PM


Originally Posted by umd (Post 10991548)
It's my experience, that if I stand and don't increase my power, that my HR usually goes down, unless I'm standing because I'm overgeared. That said, I still usually prefer to climb seated unless I need the extra power. I usually use it like an afterburner.

Anyway, show and tell is more fun. Here is a video of a climb from yesterday's race. Shows some riders standing at times. You can tell when I stand when the video gets all wibbly-wobbly.

Good old haskins! :) One of my favorite climbs, although I take probably 3 times as long to climb it as you do :) I prefer that direction, I think. Coming back the other way looks significantly harder.

Blackdays 06-21-10 05:20 PM


Originally Posted by GarySMelbourne (Post 10991700)
Umd...do you find any benefit to drafting while climbing or does the climb itself neglect any effect of the draft?

Nice video.

I feel a little more nervous sitting on someones wheel up a hill because people tend to get squirrely on climbs.

umd 06-21-10 05:26 PM


Originally Posted by Blackdays (Post 10997302)
I feel a little more nervous sitting on someones wheel up a hill because people tend to get squirrely on climbs.

This was a hilly cat 3 road race. The squirrely people who can't climb don't come or were already shelled.

Terex 06-21-10 06:18 PM

I have motored past lots of standers while I've been seated, but it sure is nice to be able to switch up muscle groups from time to time. I DO stand most of the time on climbs around 20%. Keeps the front end down, and allows better use of arms to leverage downstroke.

ktanner777 06-21-10 06:24 PM


Originally Posted by rousseau (Post 10990200)
Why is climbing out of the saddle so tough for me? It really wears me out when I do it, but I do enjoy it. I'm a recreational rider, so it matters not, aside from the fact that I'd like to do it more for my own enjoyment.

I'm a heavy guy at 104 kg/230 lb. Yeah, yeah, I'm trying to get back into shape. So is my difficulty with climbing out of the saddle simply a function of the load I'm hauling? Is it easier if you're lighter?

Of course it would be easier if you were in shape and carrying less weight.

wens 06-21-10 06:30 PM

[QUOTE=ktanner777;10997603]

Originally Posted by rousseau (Post 10990200)
Why is climbing out of the saddle so tough for me? It really wears me out when I do it, but I do enjoy it. I'm a recreational rider, so it matters not, aside from the fact that I'd like to do it more for my own enjoyment.

I'm a heavy guy at 104 kg/230 lb. Yeah, yeah, I'm trying to get back into shape. So is my difficulty with climbing out of the saddle simply a function of the load I'm hauling? Is it easier if you're lighter?[/QUOTE]

Of course it would be easier if you were in shape and carrying less weight.

Mostly for the sake of being contrary, but because it does have some relevance, these are not necessarily the same thing. At 5'9.5" and 175 or so I was in shape at the weight I wanted to be at for swimming. For cycling this would probably be less desirable, but I certaintly wasn't out of shape.

Terex 06-21-10 06:30 PM

[QUOTE=ktanner777;10997603]

Originally Posted by rousseau (Post 10990200)
Why is climbing out of the saddle so tough for me? It really wears me out when I do it, but I do enjoy it. I'm a recreational rider, so it matters not, aside from the fact that I'd like to do it more for my own enjoyment.

I'm a heavy guy at 104 kg/230 lb. Yeah, yeah, I'm trying to get back into shape. So is my difficulty with climbing out of the saddle simply a function of the load I'm hauling? Is it easier if you're lighter?[/QUOTE]

Of course it would be easier if you were in shape and carrying less weight.

Coming from the climbing capitol of America, Palm City, FL. :thumb:

umd 06-21-10 06:31 PM


Originally Posted by wens (Post 10997626)
Mostly for the sake of being contrary, but because it does have some relevance, these are not necessarily the same thing. At 5'9.5" and 175 or so I was in shape at the weight I wanted to be at for swimming. For cycling this would probably be less desirable, but I certaintly wasn't out of shape.

Well he did say in shape AND carrying less weight.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:19 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.