This thread is probably terrible to navigate. Sorry about that. I revived a 10 year old thread because it had my measurements in it. Should of posted a new thread. Right now looking at a surly midnight special which doesn't seem to be available for test ride. Still need to try more shops though.

The 54cm midnight special has a effective top tube of 555 vs the effective top tube of the 56cm is 570. Combined with drops the 54cm should be perfect I think. The 56cm being a tad big.

Found a shop not too far that has cross checks in stock, which are close enough in geo to confirm my size. They can order the midnight special from surly as well, they just don't carry them.