Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Cheapest way to get power? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/768190-cheapest-way-get-power.html)

ahsposo 09-15-11 04:53 PM

The cheapest way to get power is to Swift Boat yer honorable opponent. Sure worked for old what's his name...

LowCel 09-15-11 04:57 PM


Originally Posted by jmX (Post 13231896)
The wired powertap does have a good price, but does the computer log the data and allow you to save that out to a PC?

Yes, it does. I rode a wired pt for two or three years, sold it to a buddy of mine. He had it rebuilt (new rim and spokes), rode it for two years and it is still going strong.

Minion1 09-15-11 05:15 PM

Thanks Lowcell, good to know.
How much hassle is it to transfer between bikes? I'm guessing all the wires are external.

LowCel 09-15-11 05:44 PM


Originally Posted by Minion1 (Post 13232345)
Thanks Lowcell, good to know.
How much hassle is it to transfer between bikes? I'm guessing all the wires are external.

I had three different mounting kits so it wasn't bad at all. Just put one of the kits on each bike then all I had to do was swap wheels and the computer head. Only took a minute.

You can also use a regular rear wheel with a magnet and use the powertap head unit as a regular computer.

Drew Eckhardt 09-15-11 06:16 PM

1 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by tadawdy (Post 13227613)
I've decided to get a power meter, but it's a total splurge. I can't pay a lot for one on CL, where I see them on sale. The problem is these are built into nice wheels, and retain resale value. I assume a hub-based system will be cheapest, though heavy.

I basically need a whole power setup, for as cheap as I can (no iBike garbage).

You can get a complete used wired powertap setup for under $250 (first generation) or $350 (second generation).

I sold a 1040g Powertap SL wired hub in a 30mm deep Kinlin XR-300 rim with DT Revolution 2.0/1.5 spokes and alloy nipples on craigslist with electronics for $300 shipped.

Be sure to check the zero. The Cervo (aka Little Yellow Computer) has a test mode where it displays the torque offset. You want it to be "about 512" inch-pounds according to the manual with a tolerance around +/-8.

A bad zero often coincides with slope changes or non-linearities that lead to bogus power files.

Drew Eckhardt 09-15-11 06:19 PM


Originally Posted by eippo1 (Post 13227967)
Keep an eye out on ebay too. I've come across some elite hubs w/ no rim for fairly low prices. Then you could lace it to an open pro for a fairly inexpensive wheel like $500 or so, but then that makes the CC deal look even better. hmm

Looks like some on-line retailers are selling new Powertap hubs for not a lot of money, presumably as close-outs to make way for the lighter G3 hub.

You can get a Comp wired hub only for $280 (+ $95 electropack = $375 total) and Elite+ wireless for $500 (if you're already a Garmin user that's a pretty small premium for wireless).

Skinny Fred 09-15-11 07:35 PM

I think you should buy a used wired setup for <$400 or a new wireless ANT+, nothing in the middle. Wired commits you to this computer and this wheel until you replace the entire system, while ANT+ compatibility allows you to swap each piece independently. The price difference between the Competitive Cyclist Pro+ wheel deal and used seems too small.


Originally Posted by Minion1 (Post 13232241)
Has cycleops redesigned the hub assembly? If that is the case now would be the best time to buy an older model as retailers won't want to get stuck with older models.

There will be the new G3 with the separate electronics pod, but the new Pro seems to be a refinement (-20g) of the current Pro+.


Originally Posted by LowCel (Post 13232456)
I had three different mounting kits so it wasn't bad at all. Just put one of the kits on each bike then all I had to do was swap wheels and the computer head. Only took a minute.

What is a good price for the mounting kits? Competitive Cyclist lists them at $70 (!).


Originally Posted by Drew Eckhardt (Post 13232572)
You can get a complete used wired powertap setup for under $250 (first generation) or $350 (second generation).

First generation = 2005? That's pretty good resale value retention. Are these laced into nice rims?

LowCel 09-15-11 07:39 PM


Originally Posted by Skinny Fred (Post 13232955)
What is a good price for the mounting kits? Competitive Cyclist lists them at $70 (!).

I'm not real sure. I gave one to a member not too long ago. A lot of people have them laying around gathering dust.

Drew Eckhardt 09-15-11 08:00 PM


Originally Posted by Skinny Fred (Post 13232955)
First generation = 2005? That's pretty good resale value retention. Are these laced into nice rims?

As old as 2002. No newer than 2005ish where the SL wired was introduced. Most likely laced into a Mavic Open Pro.

tadawdy 09-15-11 08:18 PM

So what if I got a hub at a good price, and had it built into a rim I already have? How much would that service probably cost?

LowCel 09-15-11 08:28 PM

Probably 50 - 100 plus spokes / nipples.

tadawdy 09-15-11 09:10 PM

Thanks for all the recommendations, guys. After much hand-wringing, went with the Pro+ CC deal; I wanted new, preferred current tech, and this seemed like a good price point to get into power. Will use my phone until I get sick of that and buy a Garmin. Should get me through trainer sessions over the winter.

I really wanted to jump on a quote I got from November, but I couldn't justify spending more than what I did. I'm sure the wheel would be nicer than the Open Pro I ended up with, but I doubt the Open Pro will make me hate it.

For anyone else looking, the Pro and Elite hubs are supposedly on some sort of closeout, so it might be a good time to buy if you're like me.

bbattle 09-16-11 05:46 AM


Originally Posted by ultraman6970 (Post 13230974)
Che Copete?

Che Guevarra?

Skinny Fred 09-17-11 04:33 PM


Originally Posted by tadawdy (Post 13233355)
Will use my phone until I get sick of that and buy a Garmin.

To prevent confusion if someone reads this thread later, the Sony Ericsson Xperia "arc" (line) supports ANT+, and Wahoo Fitness makes an iPhone dongle. Most phones support Bluetooth. There was a pre-production Bluetooth/ANT+ translator presented at Interbike.

bikepro 09-17-11 07:33 PM


Originally Posted by Homebrew01 (Post 13230910)
Here's a no-frills New Powertap wheel for $600

http://www.competitivecyclist.com/pr...p+Wheel+091511

I bought this back in the spring and am completely satisfied. There is nothing wrong with wired. If you get the wired version, you also need to get the wiring cover for the Shimano electric shifters -- about $10. and conceals the wiring on the down-tube.

ultraman6970 09-17-11 07:49 PM

Che..chita?


Originally Posted by bbattle (Post 13234281)
Che Guevarra?


echappist 09-18-11 01:29 PM


Originally Posted by tadawdy (Post 13233133)
So what if I got a hub at a good price, and had it built into a rim I already have? How much would that service probably cost?

rim is $50, spokes another $30 or so. Build costs are usually $50.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:00 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.