Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Water Bottles, Why? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/81600-water-bottles-why.html)

Stealthman_1 01-02-05 06:09 PM

Water Bottles, Why?
 
Since I've never seen anyone actually die of thirst while riding a bike, why do we carry waterbottles? We spend thousands of dollars to shave ounces, chucking a water bottle can be as much as a pound and a half! I would guess that kind of weight loss would allow a normal guy who can spin a 53-13 the ability to spin 50-12. What do you think?

rcams 01-02-05 06:14 PM

Because carrying and drinking two water bottles is chaper and more convenient than an ER visit for dehydration. Any ride over 30 minutes requires fluids.

Laggard 01-02-05 06:15 PM

Because you need water to stay hydrated and being dehydrated leads to a significant loss of performance.

I can't believe I'm answering this question.

LordOpie 01-02-05 06:16 PM

I know you're trying to be funny and entertaining, but I had a friend who got extremely ill from dehydration. The odd thing was, she had water in her camelbak. If she was alone, she would've died for sure cuz she was disoriented by the time anyone realized something was wrong.

hydrate or die

phantomcow2 01-02-05 06:21 PM

Why on earth would you need to drink when going on a long ride? :lol:

55/Rad 01-02-05 06:22 PM


Originally Posted by Stealthman_1
Since I've never seen anyone actually die of thirst while riding a bike, why do we carry waterbottles? We spend thousands of dollars to shave ounces, chucking a water bottle can be as much as a pound and a half! I would guess that kind of weight loss would allow a normal guy who can spin a 53-13 the ability to spin 50-12. What do you think?

I think we've all been thinking too much about the whole "who needs cycling shorts" debate.

55/Rad

Jonathon 01-02-05 06:28 PM

i dont use water bottles...i carry a really large water bottle strapped to my back =)

53-11 alltheway 01-02-05 06:30 PM


Originally Posted by Stealthman_1
Since I've never seen anyone actually die of thirst while riding a bike, why do we carry waterbottles? We spend thousands of dollars to shave ounces, chucking a water bottle can be as much as a pound and a half! I would guess that kind of weight loss would allow a normal guy who can spin a 53-13 the ability to spin 50-12. What do you think?

Hahahaha.....I know you are trying to mock me, but I still think you are funny as hell. Proceed by all means.....this forum gets a little dry sometimes......dry sometimes....dry........get it? (thread about water bottles....oh, never mind I'll take that joke back to the cheese factory)

pseudobrit 01-02-05 06:31 PM

Good idea.

I'm also going to throw away my component group controls and just wrap the cables around my handlebar to acheive the proper settings, ride in nothing but tighty whities and use solid rubber tires.

LordOpie 01-02-05 06:32 PM


Originally Posted by 53-11 alltheway
...this forum gets a little dry sometimes...

agreed, which is why many people enjoy having you here... to love or hate.

PS: fix your fookin' sig!

Stealthman_1 01-02-05 06:32 PM

Over at analictic cycling.com you can see that a frame mounted water bottle does make you more aerodynamic, so...while they would need to run the numbers if you strapped a 5 gallon Alhambra bottle to your back I bet you would substantially reduce your wake turbulance. You could even carry a gallon of water in it, cause we all no thanks to ZIPP that aero is much better than light weight!

slvoid 01-02-05 06:34 PM

Thats cause no one's dumb enough to go far enough without water to die.

That's like, "Why do we need a firesuit, I've never seen anyone burn to death walking next to a 2000 degree volcano flow without a firesuit.

ajst2duk 01-02-05 06:35 PM

Duh - I took that bait - how dumb

Retro Grouch 01-02-05 06:35 PM


Originally Posted by Stealthman_1
Since I've never seen anyone actually die of thirst while riding a bike, why do we carry waterbottles? We spend thousands of dollars to shave ounces, chucking a water bottle can be as much as a pound and a half! I would guess that kind of weight loss would allow a normal guy who can spin a 53-13 the ability to spin 50-12. What do you think?

I would think that weight reduction would allow a fellow like yourself to improve your performance enough to break the bicycling record across Death Valley. Why don't you try it?

Stealthman_1 01-02-05 06:35 PM


Originally Posted by slvoid
Thats cause no one's dumb enough to go far enough without water to die.

That's like, "Why do we need a firesuit, I've never seen anyone burn to death walking next to a 2000 degree volcano flow without a firesuit.

Hey good point, another corporate myth forced on us for white male greed...

Portis 01-02-05 06:36 PM


Originally Posted by Stealthman_1
Since I've never seen anyone actually die of thirst while riding a bike, why do we carry waterbottles? We spend thousands of dollars to shave ounces, chucking a water bottle can be as much as a pound and a half! I would guess that kind of weight loss would allow a normal guy who can spin a 53-13 the ability to spin 50-12. What do you think?

FYI, it's actually the water that you need. The bottles are fairly worthless without it. If you don't need water, then they have something else for you. It is called an IV and they will be happy to insert it once you pass out from dehydration.

slone130 01-02-05 07:04 PM

I don't think we need food either. Just think..if we all stop eating we could loose weight then those hills wouldn't be so hard. Of course eventually we'd all starve to death. But think of the abs we'd have.

Dchiefransom 01-02-05 07:06 PM


Originally Posted by 53-11 alltheway
Hahahaha.....I know you are trying to mock me, but I still think you are funny as hell. Proceed by all means.....this forum gets a little dry sometimes......dry sometimes....dry........get it? (thread about water bottles....oh, never mind I'll take that joke back to the cheese factory)

Is that the one you pass on the Riverbank Cheese & Wine Century??
When I fisrt started riding again, I dehydrated once and had softball sized cramps on each thigh. Hydration is no joke.

Surferbruce 01-02-05 07:18 PM

on my pista i just carry a bottle in my jersey pocket so it doesn't add any weight to my bike!

Chucklehead 01-02-05 07:23 PM

water bottles are a good source of entertainment. just "accidentally" chuck a full one into some poor idiot's spokes during a criterium and watch the fireworks. priceless.

ManBearPig 01-02-05 07:28 PM

Common sense is important.

I remember when my older brother was in late high-school, maybe early college, and he "got into" road biking for a short while. He once told me straight-faced, you don't need to carry along water unless you are going on a 2+ hour ride. I knew nothing about road cycling, but I almost instantly deduced he had confused food-related info with water-related info. He apparently read a cycling magazine that gave a 2-hour rule on food, and his mistaken recollection was that the 2-hr rule pertained to water.

Common sense, people.

phantomcow2 01-02-05 07:45 PM

Has anybody noticed that on this forum especially, the flaming threads are the ones with the most responses besides the sticky

skydive69 01-02-05 08:20 PM


Originally Posted by Stealthman_1
Since I've never seen anyone actually die of thirst while riding a bike, why do we carry waterbottles? We spend thousands of dollars to shave ounces, chucking a water bottle can be as much as a pound and a half! I would guess that kind of weight loss would allow a normal guy who can spin a 53-13 the ability to spin 50-12. What do you think?

Tell me your not serious! An athlete, you are obviously not!

On the subject of bike weight, rolling resistance weight is what counts most - that's why people spend big bucks on light wheelsets.

slvoid 01-02-05 09:36 PM

During the winter, I can ride hard for about an hour without any water. Summer, about a bottle per hour.

ajst2duk 01-02-05 09:50 PM

Actually - you're right, water is a waste of time. I carry beer in my bottles, helps me up those hills. The advantage with beer is that it contains all sorts of other goodies to keep you going, and the more you have, the quicker you seem to go.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:05 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.