Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   cracked carbon frame? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/817840-cracked-carbon-frame.html)

Terry66 05-13-12 05:30 PM

cracked carbon frame?
 
I was cleaning my bike today and notices this "line" running up the back of the seat tube. I can't really feel anything, but the line is there. If the bike weren't white, I wouldn't even notice it. I flipped the bike upside down and snapped a pic. Also marked the area on a side pic. Just seems like a strange place for a cracked frame.

Thoughts?

http://www.watsonfx.com/crack.jpg

http://www.watsonfx.com/roubaix_side.jpg

echotraveler 05-13-12 05:38 PM

take it in for inspection by a specialized authorized dealer. Is the line a crack in the paint? a shadow? dirt?
are you the original owner?

ahsposo 05-13-12 05:41 PM

Cancer.

Terry66 05-13-12 05:51 PM


Originally Posted by echotraveler (Post 14218307)
take it in for inspection by a specialized authorized dealer. Is the line a crack in the paint? a shadow? dirt?
are you the original owner?

I am the original owner. The bike is a 2010. I cannot feel anything in the paint and I am fairly certain it isn't dirt as I have tried to clean it. I take off the wheels and clean the bike at least once a week (yeah, slightly OCD) and I just noticed it today.

I keep every thing, so I am going to take the receipt in and have the LBS look at it.

echotraveler 05-13-12 05:59 PM

keep us posted.

i've had great experience with specialized warranty. if you get a warranty replacement, ask for an upgrade to the sl3 frame! its awesome!

M_Wales 05-13-12 06:06 PM

Get it checked out...

I had my 2010 Raleigh Team SL frame looked at last week by the Raleigh rep. for a possible crack in the non-drive side chain stay. Turned out to be a hairline crack in the paint/clearcoat, and was told to keep and eye on it and let him know if it grows...

ultraman6970 05-13-12 06:31 PM

The problem with those cracks is that you dont know if its the frame or the paint unless you sand or peel the paint in the area in question.

TO me looks like a crack in the paint.

abstractform20 05-13-12 07:26 PM

dont worry, Specialized will sue that potential crack because it clearly rips off their "sloping" design from their top tubes.

catonec 05-13-12 07:51 PM

2 Attachment(s)
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=250008http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=250009pretty bike, Im not %100 on this but I always thought the seat tube was a non-loadbearing component of the frame which in my mind would reduce the chances of a crack developing in it. I definitely agree with the others that you should have it inspected but I wouldnt sweat it much.

vermilionx 05-13-12 07:53 PM

kewl bike.

i like those wheels.

still waiting for november wheels to stock up on their white FSW23s. >_<

StanSeven 05-13-12 07:55 PM

Yeah, it's a crack in the paint. CF doesn't crack all by itself - cracks come from impact or compression and don't happen in a straight line like that.

ColinL 05-13-12 07:56 PM

In that location it's certainly possible to be a scratch in the paint.

Terry66 05-13-12 08:09 PM

Thanks guys....I agree that it is odd to see a straight line crack. Even when scratching my fingernail across the area, I can't feel any imperfection in the surface, so I really think whatever it is appears to be under the clear coat. I'l have it checked out. My LBS is great, so I know they'll check it out and take care of it if it is a problem.

Also thanks for the compliments on the bike. It is a perfect bike for an old guy (46) like me. It isn't so aggressive that it is uncomfortable, but it is still a light and fast bike. Seems everyone in my riding groups are doing blacked out matte black bikes, so I kind of like the white/white look.

IcySmooth52 05-13-12 08:12 PM

Here's a pic of a carbon crack over a white paint. It's obviously into the resin, yours is not.
https://mail-attachment.googleuserco...h80vEEniNAwpLs

echotraveler 05-13-12 08:31 PM

when specialized sold you the bike thru the LBS they had already factored the cost of replacement...your LBS or specialized wont loose a single penny of profit from a frame exchange...in fact your LBS will profit a little bit... :)

alexaschwanden 05-13-12 08:59 PM

Duct tape it, but seriously take it in to the LBS to inspect it.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:17 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.