Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Crankset stiffness? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/832736-crankset-stiffness.html)

hyhuu 07-16-12 12:36 PM

Crankset stiffness?
 
When people talk about how one crankset is stiffer than another, what are we talking about here? Crankarms? Chainrings? Being a weak and mortal, I surely can't tell the difference between one to the next beside the total weigh so please elucidate me.

LowCel 07-16-12 12:43 PM

I have had quite a few bikes and quite a few cranksets. I have yet to notice a crank flex. I'm a firm believer that the frame / bb is going to flex enough to hide any crank flex I get.

I remember an article in a bicycling magazine a few years back testing cranks. The difference of flex from best to worst was in fractions of a mm. They even stated it wasn't nearly enough for anyone to ever notice.

adclark 07-16-12 12:57 PM

I haven't noticed any crank flex either. I have ridden bikes with square taper, Mega-EXO, and BB30. The only difference I feel is the flex in the frame, not the crank.

ddeadserious 07-16-12 01:08 PM

Crank flex is not an absurd thing to occur. On one of my fixed gears, I had 3-4mm of clearance between the end of the crank arm and the drive side chainstay. At some point, I flexed it enough to knock the paint off in that spot. It was a higher-end crankset on a very stiff aluminum frame, but I'm a fairly strong and heavy rider.

JustinHorne 07-16-12 01:17 PM

Especially when you're considering the vector of the force being applied to the crank, crank plex seems like a pretty minimal thing. If I had to guess, what most people attribute to crank flex is probably BB flex.

mazdaspeed 07-16-12 01:43 PM

****ty cranks and chainrings can flex noticeably but not any decent racing parts I've used.

zaqwert6 07-16-12 02:09 PM

You can flex them but it takes alot. The BB usually gives up first but either way, it takes a lot. I raced BMX alot and up until my 30s , where you do alot of standing starts and then literally torque the whole bike under you. I've twisted crank arms, BBs , pedal axles , bar stems ... pretty much you name it. But thats the price you pay if you ride the balance between strength and maximum light weight.

Seattle Forrest 07-16-12 03:46 PM

I thought I felt the left crank arm (6700) flex once, going up a ~20 % grade, toward the end of a long day when I was tired and just wanted to get to the top. But I've never felt it again, so it was probably in my imagination.

merlinextraligh 07-16-12 06:24 PM

Crankset stiffness?
 
Whether its the bb shell or the crank, there is definitely a difference with 10 speed external bearing cranks and the older internal bearing
Cranks

I can induce chain rub and. Even throw a chain on 9 speed and older cranks
. Never done that with new stuff either shimano or Fsa


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:59 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.