Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   Water bottles are dangerous on long term? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/862559-water-bottles-dangerous-long-term.html)

hillcrawler 12-14-12 04:54 AM

Water bottles are dangerous on long term?
 
Is it true that plastic water bottles getting unhealthy after a reasonable time? Maybe we should carry bottles made of metal or glass?

jimc101 12-14-12 05:05 AM

What evidence is there for this?

Homebrew01 12-14-12 05:13 AM

Glass sounds like a great idea.



Originally Posted by jimc101 (Post 15048597)
What evidence is there for this?

You don't need evidence, just say you read it on the Internet.

Ice41000 12-14-12 05:32 AM


Originally Posted by hillcrawler (Post 15048589)
Is it true that plastic water bottles getting unhealthy after a reasonable time? ...

They probably are. Mildly.

pdedes 12-14-12 05:32 AM

Or preface your statement with "Studies show ..."

roadwarrior 12-14-12 06:34 AM


Originally Posted by pdedes (Post 15048618)
Or preface your statement with "Studies show ..."

Studies done by the metal water bottle manufacturer's association show...

Do some research...certain plastics are not good for use for consumption, then look at the bottom of the bottle to see if it's made out of the bad plastic.

Andy Somnifac 12-14-12 06:35 AM

If it doesn't hurt too badly, think about the alternatives you suggested. Especially the 2nd.

Ouch.

hillcrawler 12-14-12 06:42 AM


Scientists in Germany have found that PET plastics -- the kind used to make water bottles, among many other common products -- may also harbor hormone-disrupting chemicals that leach into the water.
Now what? :D

Andy Somnifac 12-14-12 06:49 AM


Originally Posted by hillcrawler (Post 15048709)
Now what? :D

I raise you a white paper by some scientists finding it safe:

http://www.ilsi.org/europe/publicati...00pac_mat1.pdf

Conclusion: Everything and nothing will kill you.

RT 12-14-12 06:54 AM

...


jrobe 12-14-12 06:56 AM

Everyone who has used water bottles has (or will) eventually die.

hillcrawler 12-14-12 07:21 AM


Originally Posted by jrobe (Post 15048730)
Everyone who has used water bottles has (or will) eventually die.

Why don't you jump out of your window now? You'll eventually die.

Trsnrtr 12-14-12 07:21 AM

After 31 cycling seasons of drinking out of plastic water bottles, I can confirm that drinking out of plastic bottles has made me 31 years older. :thumb:

hillcrawler 12-14-12 07:31 AM


Originally Posted by Trsnrtr (Post 15048793)
After 31 cycling seasons of drinking out of plastic water bottles, I can confirm that drinking out of plastic bottles has made me 31 years older. :thumb:

Can you also confirm that you won't have colorectal cancer in the future because of that?

jolly_ross 12-14-12 07:32 AM

Please do not ride in front of me carrying glass bottles.

Nachoman 12-14-12 07:49 AM


Originally Posted by Homebrew01 (Post 15048603)
Glass sounds like a great idea.

:lol:

david58 12-14-12 07:52 AM


Originally Posted by hillcrawler (Post 15048822)
Can you also confirm that you won't have colorectal cancer in the future because of that?

Can you confirm for me that you won't because you didn't?

John_V 12-14-12 07:52 AM

With all the hazards on the road that confront us as cyclist, I'm thinking that the least of my concerns is a plastic water bottle.

FLvector 12-14-12 07:53 AM

Cycling is dangerous. Sell your bike. And insist that your grocery store switch all their milk and juice containers to glass.

SgtPepper64 12-14-12 07:55 AM

Probably the whole BPA thing. I learned that the number in the arrow-triangle on the bottom of standard plastic water bottles displays the concentration of BPA. 1 being the safest and 7 being the worst.

My orange juice bottle this morning has a 1, as well as my Costco\Poland Spring water bottles. However, going to a restaurant the other day I discovered that the new plastic containers they have to take your food home is a level 5 BPA container. Don't want to keep things in there too long.

There are many reusable bottles out there that are completely BPA free. REI carries them as well as other outdoor stores and CamelBak's and Hydrapak's bladders are BPA-free.

adclark 12-14-12 08:13 AM

How do you plan to drink from a glass or metal bottle while riding, not to mention how safe they would be if you dropped it? You can't squeeze the bottle so you would have to use both hands to unscrew a top.

topflightpro 12-14-12 08:13 AM

Yeah, except recent studies by the FDA say the concerns over BPA are overblown. The human body is pretty good about excreting excessive amounts of BPA before it really affects you.

ahsposo 12-14-12 08:22 AM

Everything is dangerous in the long term. Especially that cute girl updating her Facebook page while driving mommy's Escalade.

canam73 12-14-12 08:29 AM

I would think after a while all the surface BPA will have leached on out and it would get safer. That's why I only use other people used bottles that I collect from the road side after races and centuries and stuff.

Doohickie 12-14-12 08:42 AM


Originally Posted by SgtPepper64 (Post 15048880)
Probably the whole BPA thing. I learned that the number in the arrow-triangle on the bottom of standard plastic water bottles displays the concentration of BPA. 1 being the safest and 7 being the worst.

This is totally and categorically incorrect. The number refers to the type of plastic the bottle is made out of.

1- PETE (Polyethylene Terephthalate)
2- HDPE (High Density Polyethylene)
3- PVC (Polyvinyl Chloride)
4- LDPE (Low Density Polyethylene)
5- PP (Polypropylene)
6- PS (Polystyrene)
7- Other

The number is on there so the plastics can be sorted into the different types for recycling.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:39 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.