Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   A Sunday ride on my Scott went .......Snap, Crackle,Pop (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/965110-sunday-ride-my-scott-went-snap-crackle-pop.html)

texastwister 08-10-14 02:50 PM

A Sunday ride on my Scott went .......Snap, Crackle,Pop
 
4 Attachment(s)
My 07 CR1 is now wall art:D, I'am not sure what started all of the carnage , but pictures speaks a thousand words, the rear derailleur is twisted and cracked , and my wife wonders why I have 2 extra bikes ;) and now for some cool pics

TrojanHorse 08-10-14 03:02 PM

Did you shift into the spokes or did the parts all just implode simultaneously?

Time to go bike shopping. :)

achoo 08-10-14 05:15 PM

Looks like the FD fell off and pulled the RD off when it when around?

tagaproject6 08-10-14 05:20 PM

Ouch!
https://i.chzbgr.com/maxW500/1877053184/h3501C4A3/

redtires 08-10-14 05:24 PM

Holy crap! That's quite the compilation of failures!!

Germany_chris 08-10-14 05:34 PM

Hey look Shimano failed whoda thunk.

fstshrk 08-10-14 05:36 PM

Wow, are you all right? Did you end up falling badly?

If you love the bike, you can talk to Calfee about getting it fixed. Otherwise, does Scott have a crash replacement policy?

loimpact 08-10-14 05:46 PM

Ditto what Fstshrk said. You ok???

Though I often care less about me than the bike. I popped a tire the other night & wife asked if I was ok.

I said, "Ya, bike's OK I didn't lay it down."

She retorted with....."No, are YOU Ok!?!".

I said, "Oh ya, I'm fine." ;)

So, now you can tell the wife, "Hey, you always wanted me to get rid of one of the bikes, right? There ya go! Can I replace it tomorrow?" :p

texastwister 08-10-14 05:51 PM


Originally Posted by fstshrk (Post 17023952)
Wow, are you all right? Did you end up falling badly?

If you love the bike, you can talk to Calfee about getting it fixed. Otherwise, does Scott have a crash replacement policy?

It locked up and I unclipped just in time , Its already apart and really not worth the hassle of getting it fixed, its sorta like after a car is wrecked its never really the same , I had just did a descent at 38mph, so the good Lord was on my side !

rpenmanparker 08-10-14 05:52 PM


Originally Posted by fstshrk (Post 17023952)
Wow, are you all right? Did you end up falling badly?

If you love the bike, you can talk to Calfee about getting it fixed. Otherwise, does Scott have a crash replacement policy?

Yeah, I was thinking you could tell them you ran into providence.

rpenmanparker 08-10-14 05:53 PM


Originally Posted by texastwister (Post 17023996)
It locked up and I unclipped just in time , Its already apart and really not worth the hassle of getting it fixed, its sorta like after a car is wrecked its never really the same , I had just ascended at 38mph, so the good Lord was on my side !

You da man!

Lazyass 08-10-14 05:53 PM


Originally Posted by Germany_chris (Post 17023941)
Hey look Shimano failed whoda thunk.

Looks like the braze on ripped out of the carbon fiber tube. Nothing to do with Shimano.

texastwister 08-10-14 06:11 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Heres the Snap part of it

joejack951 08-10-14 06:11 PM


Originally Posted by Lazyass (Post 17024002)
Looks like the braze on ripped out of the carbon fiber tube. Nothing to do with Shimano.

And that tube looks round. Why wouldn't you (the OP) just slap on a clamp-on front derailler? Seems like a simple fix.

bt 08-10-14 06:13 PM

if i could ascend a mountain at 38mph i wouldn't be paying for new bikes....

gsa103 08-10-14 06:14 PM

I'm guessing RD into the spokes, pulls the chain to the outside as it goes, ripping the braze-on out of the frame.

My guess is that its totally recoverable. Clamp-on FD, new hanger & RD, and you're probably good to go. There's likely some damage to the seat tube, but it looks like it ripped out pretty cleanly and wouldn't compromise the strength. You'd want a more detailed inspection to confirm that though. Basically, check for any weakness around and especially between the holes. It becomes an ideal beater.

bt 08-10-14 06:15 PM


Originally Posted by joejack951 (Post 17024061)
And that tube looks round. Why wouldn't you (the OP) just slap on a clamp-on front derailler? Seems like a simple fix.

rear hanger looked messed up too, non-replaceble rear derailleur hangers on scotts.

Pirkaus 08-10-14 06:22 PM

Did the rear derailleur get into the wheel? Glad you got off without getting wrecked as badly as the bike.
Told to the Minister of Finance as see when the replacement is being ordered.
Pirk

Lazyass 08-10-14 06:29 PM


Originally Posted by gsa103 (Post 17024074)
I'm guessing RD into the spokes, pulls the chain to the outside as it goes, ripping the braze-on out of the frame.

It looks like the braze on just ripped off the carbon tube getting the chain caught in the crank arm/pedal while pedaling pulling the rear derailleur off. But who knows, weird.

Mike F 08-10-14 06:30 PM


Originally Posted by bt (Post 17024077)
non-replaceble rear derailleur hangers onscotts.

Doesnt help OP one bit but CR1's after 2010 had the detachable DRH :) When I was looking to buy my 2012 CR1 people were still telling me not too because of the non- detachable DRH.

surgeonstone 08-10-14 06:53 PM

Seriously sucks but good you're ok. Were you shifting when it occurred or was it all spontaneous. Do you recall where the abnormal sound began? Front or rear? Don't think I'd want to clamp an FD on that tube even after repaired.

texastwister 08-10-14 06:57 PM

1 Attachment(s)
I got lucky , the chain wegded in the back of the cassette and the base of the hub , the spokes do not look damaged but I will have the LBS check it out , this was the only third time out on the new wheelset too ! Heres a picture from a few weeks ago when all was well, :D

joejack951 08-10-14 07:02 PM


Originally Posted by bt (Post 17024077)
rear hanger looked messed up too, non-replaceble rear derailleur hangers on scotts.

The hanger is still there so there's a good chance it can be salvaged.

Dirt Road 08-10-14 07:03 PM

It was a nice looking bike. I'm glad you are OK.

texastwister 08-10-14 07:07 PM

1 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by surgeonstone (Post 17024173)
Seriously sucks but good you're ok. Were you shifting when it occurred or was it all spontaneous. Do you recall where the abnormal sound began? Front or rear? Don't think I'd want to clamp an FD on that tube even after repaired.

I was doing a steady Candace and no shifting ..........then KA-----BAM ! I'am real finicky about my bike maintance and how clean they are , I try to look 'um over after each ride , it would just bug me to much to piece it back together, its toast , put a fork in it , lol


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:54 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.