Who has experience with Selle SMP saddles?
#26
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 65
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
I'm in same boat. Looking at SMP Hybrid, Extra and TRK. That and the Terry Liberator Race, Fly Ti Gel and Falcon Y. All seem to get good reviews. And not so good. Extremely frustrating and none of my local shops carry these brands from what I've been able to tell. Guess I'll just have to pull the trigger.
#27
Decrepit Member
I'm in same boat. Looking at SMP Hybrid, Extra and TRK. That and the Terry Liberator Race, Fly Ti Gel and Falcon Y. All seem to get good reviews. And not so good. Extremely frustrating and none of my local shops carry these brands from what I've been able to tell. Guess I'll just have to pull the trigger.
To find a local dealer, click on your state on the map.
HERE is a list of Selle SMP test centers where you can test the various models.
Not a shill; just a happy customer.
#29
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 65
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Albabici is the U.S. distributor.
To find a local dealer, click on your state on the map.
HERE is a list of Selle SMP test centers where you can test the various models.
Not a shill; just a happy customer.
To find a local dealer, click on your state on the map.
HERE is a list of Selle SMP test centers where you can test the various models.
Not a shill; just a happy customer.
#30
Decrepit Member
Measure your sit bone distance. You can use several layers of corrugated cardboard to get an impression of your sit bones, then measure the distance between them.
Look at the saddle widths and rolloff to the edge to make sure the model you're looking at is wide enough to accommodate your sit bones.
Finally, use this table to narrow down your choices.
#31
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 65
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Thanks for posting all that good stuff, Scooper. A great help to myself and I'm sure others as well. I haven't ordered my saddle yet, think I found an outfit that'll let me test it mail-order. I'll post back when I've got it all sorted. Lots of variables!
#32
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: New York City
Posts: 176
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Hi did you get the Smp saddle?
#33
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Northern VA
Posts: 3,247
Bikes: Moots Vamoots, Colnago C60, Santa Cruz Stigmata CC, and too many other bikes I don't ride
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 152 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 7 Times
in
6 Posts
I was looking into these saddles when I first started cycling and having saddle issues. Its been 3 years and the thought still crosses my mind. When looking through all the options, I get so overwhelmed trying to figure out which model would be the one to start with. Biketiresdirect.com's warehouse is just down the street from me and they have a great demo program which would allow me to try them. the obvious answer is, "no real answer, just try one and start from there." but I'm more interested to know how others made that decision.
My question is mainly out of curiousity. My saddle is fine and I may never try the SMP, but with its un-orthodox shape its intriguing.
How many people have tried the SMP to find out it was the wrong shape, then moved onto the next shape, then the next...then BOOM BAM....total comfort?
My question is mainly out of curiousity. My saddle is fine and I may never try the SMP, but with its un-orthodox shape its intriguing.
How many people have tried the SMP to find out it was the wrong shape, then moved onto the next shape, then the next...then BOOM BAM....total comfort?
#34
Blast from the Past
Really happy with a change from a Romin (143mm) to Dynamic. Took me 3 to 4 rides to get it dialed in and now it is invisible. I'm a little more stable and incrementally more comfortable. The SMP shape seemed to be sensitive to tilt. I ended up with the saddle nose down 3.5 degrees (from back to front). At that tilt the front of the saddle curves up about 1.5 degrees which coincidentally was the same tilt as my Romin.
My experience was that tilt requires a little more attention when fitting the SMP design than flatter/wider saddles. The fit was entirely different with a degree or two change.
There are a couple of really good writeups on line by Steve Hogg and Colby Pearce on the SMP saddles.
My experience was that tilt requires a little more attention when fitting the SMP design than flatter/wider saddles. The fit was entirely different with a degree or two change.
There are a couple of really good writeups on line by Steve Hogg and Colby Pearce on the SMP saddles.
#35
Senior Member
I recently got a new bike that came with a Fizik Aliante saddle that was putting my lower region to sleep on rides. I bought a SMP TRK saddle off of Amazon because I thought there was a high chance I was going to have to return it. It solved my numb problem, my lower region likes it and it is super comfy. It is an acquired look, but if is comfy, who cares. If I was racing, I would probably pick a lighter and narrower saddle. But for endurance rides, it's great.
#36
Señor Blues
I had the "Extra". Hated it, sent it back.
#37
King Hoternot
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Oregon City, OR
Posts: 5,255
Bikes: 2015 Cannondale Evo Hi mod
Mentioned: 3 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 127 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
#38
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 2,853
Mentioned: 3 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1067 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 259 Times
in
153 Posts
Tried an SMP for a few weeks. Comfort was ok but due to curve in the top found that I was locked in one position only. I prefer to be able to slide back a little for climbing and forward a bit on the flats sometimes.
#39
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2015
Posts: 246
Mentioned: 2 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 84 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 5 Times
in
3 Posts
I found this page to be very helpful in choosing my SMP. It helps to read it in sections.. Jump around a bit. You should be able to narrow down the choices..then pay attention to the detail with nose up/down angle listed. This guy put a lot of work into the article. As somebody mentioned above your sitbone measurement and saddle width is going to be the initial key.
https://www.stevehoggbikefitting.com...ll-about-smps/
I narrowed to 2 choices, and was lucky to find a shop that had them within reasonable dist from where im located. They spent almost 2 hrs fitting me on my own bike going between my choices and one other suggestion. The SMP is expensive so i wouldnt buy without trying and im sure there are other saddles less expensive that would work. But im happy with mine and they didnt charge me for the fitting time which was really nice.
https://www.stevehoggbikefitting.com...ll-about-smps/
I narrowed to 2 choices, and was lucky to find a shop that had them within reasonable dist from where im located. They spent almost 2 hrs fitting me on my own bike going between my choices and one other suggestion. The SMP is expensive so i wouldnt buy without trying and im sure there are other saddles less expensive that would work. But im happy with mine and they didnt charge me for the fitting time which was really nice.
#40
Senior Member
I've been sitting on the Glider Carbon Rail for a couple of weeks now. I had a Selle Italia Flite on my Dogma for about a year I started having issues in the taint area. The Flite has a cutout but it didn't extend far enough towards the nose of the saddle to provide relief.
I purchased mine from Bike Tires Direct as the local LBS didn't carry them and BTD has a no questions asked return policy. I measured my sit bones by sitting on a piece of corrugated cardboard and measuring the distance between them. Then I went to the SMP website and compared the dimensions of their saddles with the one I was on. When it came and I took it out of the box I have to say I had my doubts but even on the first ride I was pleasantly surprised. Absolutely no pressure on the perineum. As far as the Eagle beak at the nose I find that when I'm in the drops it actually puts me in a position to get more power to the pedals. So far I have about 250 miles on it and I've stopped thinking about it while I'm riding.
Last week due to miserable weather I had my TCR on the trainer and man I really noticed the difference sitting on the Arione that's on the TCR. Looks like I'll be buying one for that bike as well. All I can say is it works for me.
I purchased mine from Bike Tires Direct as the local LBS didn't carry them and BTD has a no questions asked return policy. I measured my sit bones by sitting on a piece of corrugated cardboard and measuring the distance between them. Then I went to the SMP website and compared the dimensions of their saddles with the one I was on. When it came and I took it out of the box I have to say I had my doubts but even on the first ride I was pleasantly surprised. Absolutely no pressure on the perineum. As far as the Eagle beak at the nose I find that when I'm in the drops it actually puts me in a position to get more power to the pedals. So far I have about 250 miles on it and I've stopped thinking about it while I'm riding.
Last week due to miserable weather I had my TCR on the trainer and man I really noticed the difference sitting on the Arione that's on the TCR. Looks like I'll be buying one for that bike as well. All I can say is it works for me.
#41
Redefining Lazy
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: North Metro, MN
Posts: 1,923
Bikes: 2013 Cannondale Synapse 5 105, 2013 Giant Escape 3
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 13 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
OP, are you having issues with your current saddle?
I was having numbness on an, otherwise, very comfortable Toupe, so I started looking for other cutout saddles.
I tried the SMP Dynamic, based on the Steve Hogg blog, but sent it back to Nashbar.
I did several rides with a multi-tool and did MANY adjustments, but decided it wasn't for me.
I am now on a Selle Italia SLR Max Gel Flow. It has a massive cutout, firm, but comfortable padding, and it's a flat design, which I like.
A little spendy at $170, but it's been great and I never think about it, which is the purpose of any saddle.
Good luck.
S
I was having numbness on an, otherwise, very comfortable Toupe, so I started looking for other cutout saddles.
I tried the SMP Dynamic, based on the Steve Hogg blog, but sent it back to Nashbar.
I did several rides with a multi-tool and did MANY adjustments, but decided it wasn't for me.
I am now on a Selle Italia SLR Max Gel Flow. It has a massive cutout, firm, but comfortable padding, and it's a flat design, which I like.
A little spendy at $170, but it's been great and I never think about it, which is the purpose of any saddle.
Good luck.
S
#42
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 65
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
#43
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2013
Posts: 215
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
SMP 209, et, all.
I have particular trouble with tender skin in the crease of my crotch due to many years of the minor abrasion that can occur in that area. Excessive milage creates an open wound. It turns out that the area looks like it has been burned; a superficial abrasion is essentially a burn.
Over the last two or three years I've tried a number of saddles including most of the ones mentioned here, including SMP 209, Koobi, ADM Prologue, as well as Selle Anatomica, Brooks B17 Imperial (narrow) and a Gilles Berthoud.
I settled on the SMP for a while, but still found problems and had to sag on the last day of RAGBRAI because I couldn't sit in the saddle. I spent a ton of money on the leather saddles and will probably remain with them.
The relief of the SMP solved any penile problems and the overall shape was fine. I think one problem was that the saddle in the area of the cutout puts a lot of pressure in the area that causes me problems.
Of the leather saddles, the Giles Berthet seems to be the overall best, in some part because it is by far the highest quality, although you can get it on the auction site for less than the MSRP of the synthitics saddles. Even though non of the leather products are really broken in, they are reasonably comfortable. I suspect this is because there is still enough conformity to eliminate any sharp edges and the flex helps to eliminate rubbing friction. The ADM saddles caused problems because the nose seemed to have a distinct corner on the outside. But the Berthet is not readily available to touch and hold, let along use for a trial period which is useless on a leather saddle. When I was researching them, the consensus among endurance riders that they were the best option. I was finally converted; you just need a little faith.
The effects of the extra weight will be minimal for the average recreational ridee, even if you spend a lot of time going uphill, If you are riding at the highest UCI levels, you even need that extra pound to reach the minimum weight.
Over the last two or three years I've tried a number of saddles including most of the ones mentioned here, including SMP 209, Koobi, ADM Prologue, as well as Selle Anatomica, Brooks B17 Imperial (narrow) and a Gilles Berthoud.
I settled on the SMP for a while, but still found problems and had to sag on the last day of RAGBRAI because I couldn't sit in the saddle. I spent a ton of money on the leather saddles and will probably remain with them.
The relief of the SMP solved any penile problems and the overall shape was fine. I think one problem was that the saddle in the area of the cutout puts a lot of pressure in the area that causes me problems.
Of the leather saddles, the Giles Berthet seems to be the overall best, in some part because it is by far the highest quality, although you can get it on the auction site for less than the MSRP of the synthitics saddles. Even though non of the leather products are really broken in, they are reasonably comfortable. I suspect this is because there is still enough conformity to eliminate any sharp edges and the flex helps to eliminate rubbing friction. The ADM saddles caused problems because the nose seemed to have a distinct corner on the outside. But the Berthet is not readily available to touch and hold, let along use for a trial period which is useless on a leather saddle. When I was researching them, the consensus among endurance riders that they were the best option. I was finally converted; you just need a little faith.
The effects of the extra weight will be minimal for the average recreational ridee, even if you spend a lot of time going uphill, If you are riding at the highest UCI levels, you even need that extra pound to reach the minimum weight.
#44
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: New York City
Posts: 176
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
I have particular trouble with tender skin in the crease of my crotch due to many years of the minor abrasion that can occur in that area. Excessive milage creates an open wound. It turns out that the area looks like it has been burned; a superficial abrasion is essentially a burn.
Over the last two or three years I've tried a number of saddles including most of the ones mentioned here, including SMP 209, Koobi, ADM Prologue, as well as Selle Anatomica, Brooks B17 Imperial (narrow) and a Gilles Berthoud.
I settled on the SMP for a while, but still found problems and had to sag on the last day of RAGBRAI because I couldn't sit in the saddle. I spent a ton of money on the leather saddles and will probably remain with them.
The relief of the SMP solved any penile problems and the overall shape was fine. I think one problem was that the saddle in the area of the cutout puts a lot of pressure in the area that causes me problems.
Of the leather saddles, the Giles Berthet seems to be the overall best, in some part because it is by far the highest quality, although you can get it on the auction site for less than the MSRP of the synthitics saddles. Even though non of the leather products are really broken in, they are reasonably comfortable. I suspect this is because there is still enough conformity to eliminate any sharp edges and the flex helps to eliminate rubbing friction. The ADM saddles caused problems because the nose seemed to have a distinct corner on the outside. But the Berthet is not readily available to touch and hold, let along use for a trial period which is useless on a leather saddle. When I was researching them, the consensus among endurance riders that they were the best option. I was finally converted; you just need a little faith.
The effects of the extra weight will be minimal for the average recreational ridee, even if you spend a lot of time going uphill, If you are riding at the highest UCI levels, you even need that extra pound to reach the minimum weight.
Over the last two or three years I've tried a number of saddles including most of the ones mentioned here, including SMP 209, Koobi, ADM Prologue, as well as Selle Anatomica, Brooks B17 Imperial (narrow) and a Gilles Berthoud.
I settled on the SMP for a while, but still found problems and had to sag on the last day of RAGBRAI because I couldn't sit in the saddle. I spent a ton of money on the leather saddles and will probably remain with them.
The relief of the SMP solved any penile problems and the overall shape was fine. I think one problem was that the saddle in the area of the cutout puts a lot of pressure in the area that causes me problems.
Of the leather saddles, the Giles Berthet seems to be the overall best, in some part because it is by far the highest quality, although you can get it on the auction site for less than the MSRP of the synthitics saddles. Even though non of the leather products are really broken in, they are reasonably comfortable. I suspect this is because there is still enough conformity to eliminate any sharp edges and the flex helps to eliminate rubbing friction. The ADM saddles caused problems because the nose seemed to have a distinct corner on the outside. But the Berthet is not readily available to touch and hold, let along use for a trial period which is useless on a leather saddle. When I was researching them, the consensus among endurance riders that they were the best option. I was finally converted; you just need a little faith.
The effects of the extra weight will be minimal for the average recreational ridee, even if you spend a lot of time going uphill, If you are riding at the highest UCI levels, you even need that extra pound to reach the minimum weight.
#45
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: New York City
Posts: 176
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
I've been sitting on the Glider Carbon Rail for a couple of weeks now. I had a Selle Italia Flite on my Dogma for about a year I started having issues in the taint area. The Flite has a cutout but it didn't extend far enough towards the nose of the saddle to provide relief.
I purchased mine from Bike Tires Direct as the local LBS didn't carry them and BTD has a no questions asked return policy. I measured my sit bones by sitting on a piece of corrugated cardboard and measuring the distance between them. Then I went to the SMP website and compared the dimensions of their saddles with the one I was on. When it came and I took it out of the box I have to say I had my doubts but even on the first ride I was pleasantly surprised. Absolutely no pressure on the perineum. As far as the Eagle beak at the nose I find that when I'm in the drops it actually puts me in a position to get more power to the pedals. So far I have about 250 miles on it and I've stopped thinking about it while I'm riding.
Last week due to miserable weather I had my TCR on the trainer and man I really noticed the difference sitting on the Arione that's on the TCR. Looks like I'll be buying one for that bike as well. All I can say is it works for me.
I purchased mine from Bike Tires Direct as the local LBS didn't carry them and BTD has a no questions asked return policy. I measured my sit bones by sitting on a piece of corrugated cardboard and measuring the distance between them. Then I went to the SMP website and compared the dimensions of their saddles with the one I was on. When it came and I took it out of the box I have to say I had my doubts but even on the first ride I was pleasantly surprised. Absolutely no pressure on the perineum. As far as the Eagle beak at the nose I find that when I'm in the drops it actually puts me in a position to get more power to the pedals. So far I have about 250 miles on it and I've stopped thinking about it while I'm riding.
Last week due to miserable weather I had my TCR on the trainer and man I really noticed the difference sitting on the Arione that's on the TCR. Looks like I'll be buying one for that bike as well. All I can say is it works for me.
#46
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2013
Posts: 215
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
johnnyguy:
I use the Berthet on a 1999 Litespeed Ultima, the Brooks B17 Imperial on my Kestral, and the Selle Anatomia replaces the saddle on the Precor Exercycle at the gym. The Berthet probably wins out because it is higher quality and esthetically cooler, a bit like the Brooks Swallow. Molded frame, 2 layer 7 mm leather v. 1 layer 5 mm on Brooks, and the cover is held on using allen keyed screws finished off with a finishing washer. Easily replaceable and attractive. Mea culpa: Gilles Berthoud
I don't anticipate going back to the SMP or Adamo.
I use the Berthet on a 1999 Litespeed Ultima, the Brooks B17 Imperial on my Kestral, and the Selle Anatomia replaces the saddle on the Precor Exercycle at the gym. The Berthet probably wins out because it is higher quality and esthetically cooler, a bit like the Brooks Swallow. Molded frame, 2 layer 7 mm leather v. 1 layer 5 mm on Brooks, and the cover is held on using allen keyed screws finished off with a finishing washer. Easily replaceable and attractive. Mea culpa: Gilles Berthoud
I don't anticipate going back to the SMP or Adamo.
#47
Senior Member
Keep in mind that I'm not a mega distance rider but I do put in about 200 miles a week in 10+ hours. Longest ride to date on it is 55 miles.
#48
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Central Florida
Posts: 343
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 45 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 6 Times
in
2 Posts
Mrs. Inspclouseau has a Selle SMP that she has been testing for two weeks now. She went from agony, groin area falling a sleep and becoming very numb on her old saddle, to a new found love for riding.
Her only issue is that the saddle is tilted forward slightly. Any degree higher and the former pain starts again. So this has her leaning a bit too much weight forward, but we are still dialing in her fit.
Her only issue is that the saddle is tilted forward slightly. Any degree higher and the former pain starts again. So this has her leaning a bit too much weight forward, but we are still dialing in her fit.
#49
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: New York City
Posts: 176
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
I've been sitting on the Glider Carbon Rail for a couple of weeks now. I had a Selle Italia Flite on my Dogma for about a year I started having issues in the taint area. The Flite has a cutout but it didn't extend far enough towards the nose of the saddle to provide relief.
I purchased mine from Bike Tires Direct as the local LBS didn't carry them and BTD has a no questions asked return policy. I measured my sit bones by sitting on a piece of corrugated cardboard and measuring the distance between them. Then I went to the SMP website and compared the dimensions of their saddles with the one I was on. When it came and I took it out of the box I have to say I had my doubts but even on the first ride I was pleasantly surprised. Absolutely no pressure on the perineum. As far as the Eagle beak at the nose I find that when I'm in the drops it actually puts me in a position to get more power to the pedals. So far I have about 250 miles on it and I've stopped thinking about it while I'm riding.
Last week due to miserable weather I had my TCR on the trainer and man I really noticed the difference sitting on the Arione that's on the TCR. Looks like I'll be buying one for that bike as well. All I can say is it works for me.
I purchased mine from Bike Tires Direct as the local LBS didn't carry them and BTD has a no questions asked return policy. I measured my sit bones by sitting on a piece of corrugated cardboard and measuring the distance between them. Then I went to the SMP website and compared the dimensions of their saddles with the one I was on. When it came and I took it out of the box I have to say I had my doubts but even on the first ride I was pleasantly surprised. Absolutely no pressure on the perineum. As far as the Eagle beak at the nose I find that when I'm in the drops it actually puts me in a position to get more power to the pedals. So far I have about 250 miles on it and I've stopped thinking about it while I'm riding.
Last week due to miserable weather I had my TCR on the trainer and man I really noticed the difference sitting on the Arione that's on the TCR. Looks like I'll be buying one for that bike as well. All I can say is it works for me.
I appreciate your respond.
Last edited by johnyguy; 10-11-15 at 07:03 PM.