Biclycle kicked out of my office building
#1
Thread Starter
San Juan Bike/Ped Coord
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 18
Likes: 0
From: San Juan, Puerto Rico USA
Bikes: 2010 Bianchi Vigorelli; 2009 Trek 7.5 FX; 2000 Schwinn Mesa GS, soon, very soon, Bianchi Vigorelli
Bicycle kicked out of my office building
After having received written permission from the building landlord in October 08 to use the freight elevator to store my bike in my office, today I was told I could no longer do that. The reason? He received an email from another office that stated that "some of my coworkers are concerned about [me] being permitted to bring my bike up to the 12th floor, because "it should not be permitted", and because "it may encourage others to do the same thing."
The terms of the written permission stated to avoid using the elevators during "rush hour" (i.e., 8am, noon, and 4pm.). I have come in as early as 6:30am to avoid bothering people...and leave later than most. I work for the Municipality of San Juan, in a 15 story building in San Juan's Hato Rey Financial District. The "landlord" is a colleague with substantially the same standing I have.
Shortly after I began riding to work, a new bike rack was put in place outside the building. I suspect it was put in place because of me. But I fear using it because I've a new Trek 7.5FX, the rack is exposed to the weather, and because after 4pm, normal quitting time, there is no one, no one around. I leave the office far later than that...and I am afraid of what I may (or may not find) on my way out of the building.
I had an interview this afternoon with the "landlord"...and he absolutely would not hear me. He could not state a single time when my use of the elevators affected others. I even offered to walk the bike up the 12 flights of stairs. Nada. He based his decision on the fact that he got an email.
But he suggested I get a cheaper bike so I could use the rack without fear.
Out of 800 employees, I am the only one who commutes, so this is seen as a "privilege".
Thanks for letting me vent.
The terms of the written permission stated to avoid using the elevators during "rush hour" (i.e., 8am, noon, and 4pm.). I have come in as early as 6:30am to avoid bothering people...and leave later than most. I work for the Municipality of San Juan, in a 15 story building in San Juan's Hato Rey Financial District. The "landlord" is a colleague with substantially the same standing I have.
Shortly after I began riding to work, a new bike rack was put in place outside the building. I suspect it was put in place because of me. But I fear using it because I've a new Trek 7.5FX, the rack is exposed to the weather, and because after 4pm, normal quitting time, there is no one, no one around. I leave the office far later than that...and I am afraid of what I may (or may not find) on my way out of the building.
I had an interview this afternoon with the "landlord"...and he absolutely would not hear me. He could not state a single time when my use of the elevators affected others. I even offered to walk the bike up the 12 flights of stairs. Nada. He based his decision on the fact that he got an email.
But he suggested I get a cheaper bike so I could use the rack without fear.
Out of 800 employees, I am the only one who commutes, so this is seen as a "privilege".
Thanks for letting me vent.
Last edited by orlandogotay; 02-25-09 at 09:13 PM. Reason: typo
#3
L T X B O M P F A N S R
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 2,334
Likes: 5
From: Malden, MA
Bikes: Bianchi Volpe, Bianchi San Jose, Redline 925
Do you have any "enemies" at work, or people who otherwise don't like you? I can't imagine someone being so petty as to complain like that. Sheesh. Why can't people just MYOB.
#6
From the first post.
Shortly after I began riding to work, a new bike rack was put in place outside the building. I suspect it was put in place because of me
#7
Yes, god forbid that others do the same and start riding bikes to work. Incredible. I teach at a small state school. Early on I was told that I couldn't bring my bike into my office. I simply ignored them. I also bought a Moulton, and in the unlikely event that someone would have pursued the issue, I would have simple taken the bike apart and carried the pieces into my office in a bag. I think it might be difficult for anyone to tell me not to bring bike parts into my own office.
I'm trying to start a bike coop here, and make the campus bike friendly with indoor parking. I'd even like to use the bike to teach green commuting, and health benefits of riding. They could even offer classes in frame building and geometry. It's incredible how small-minded some people can be. The paradigm needs to change. Good luck brother.
I'm trying to start a bike coop here, and make the campus bike friendly with indoor parking. I'd even like to use the bike to teach green commuting, and health benefits of riding. They could even offer classes in frame building and geometry. It's incredible how small-minded some people can be. The paradigm needs to change. Good luck brother.
#8
Ha ha HA! Me likey bikey!
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 311
Likes: 0
From: Ypsilanti, Michigan
Bikes: Trek 7.2 FX
As others will inevitably point out, offices and businesses have the right to prohibit people from bringing their bikes inside, given that there's no law saying they can't. Others yet will likely argue that bikes are often seen by the average person as a dirty, recreational thing that has no place inside of an office or professional environment, and that the average person has all the right to believe that. And of course, people do have the right to believe that.
And I have the right to say that those people are a bunch of snotty, dumbarse pricks.
And I have the right to say that those people are a bunch of snotty, dumbarse pricks.
#9
Senior Member

Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 2,369
Likes: 0
From: Reston, VA
Bikes: 2003 Giant OCR2
Here's an idea that many people love, but to my knowledge has not been done. Buy a crappy van for as cheap as possible, and park it in the parking lot permanently. Whether it runs or not is immaterial so long as the locks work. Use the van as a mobile storage locker inside which you leave your bike during work. If they're happy to give you a 6'x15' space to park for free, use it!
Bonus points for removing the engine and replacing it with a flower planter.
So ridiculous, like the bike was harassing anyone. Good luck however you handle it. For a more conventional approach, do you have the sort of relationship with your management that you can enlist their help in dealing with the assh*le landlord?
Bonus points for removing the engine and replacing it with a flower planter.
So ridiculous, like the bike was harassing anyone. Good luck however you handle it. For a more conventional approach, do you have the sort of relationship with your management that you can enlist their help in dealing with the assh*le landlord?
#10
Here's an idea that many people love, but to my knowledge has not been done. Buy a crappy van for as cheap as possible, and park it in the parking lot permanently. Whether it runs or not is immaterial so long as the locks work. Use the van as a mobile storage locker inside which you leave your bike during work. If they're happy to give you a 6'x15' space to park for free, use it!
That should speed up the bike approval process.
#11
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 790
Likes: 0
That sucks although i dont see the problem with using a bike rack. Of course you could work in an area with a high crime rate?
Buy a couple of U-locks and leave them on the rack. One for your rear triangle and rear wheel another around your front wheel\frame. Elements? Rain snow etc? Im in California and do not commute in the rain but I frequently lock up a carbon race bike with a power-meter (noon hammer ride) that you can guess was not cheap and only use one U-lock.
My work has never complained when I do take my bikes inside to my office but I am the one that feels improper for some reason...I can see the landlords point because I used to be able to leave an extra pair of shoes\gym bag at my Company's gym full time but I think I started a trend because after 6 months half the lockers had crap left overnight and they had to put a stop to that so now my shoes\crap stay in my office.
Buy a couple of U-locks and leave them on the rack. One for your rear triangle and rear wheel another around your front wheel\frame. Elements? Rain snow etc? Im in California and do not commute in the rain but I frequently lock up a carbon race bike with a power-meter (noon hammer ride) that you can guess was not cheap and only use one U-lock.
My work has never complained when I do take my bikes inside to my office but I am the one that feels improper for some reason...I can see the landlords point because I used to be able to leave an extra pair of shoes\gym bag at my Company's gym full time but I think I started a trend because after 6 months half the lockers had crap left overnight and they had to put a stop to that so now my shoes\crap stay in my office.
#12
I ride to work , but lock my bike up outside. Why would it be ok for me to bring my bike inside, especially after it's wet outside and all the grime is brought in to drip onto the floor? I leave my bike outside when it's wet out of respsect for the landlord, though i do lock it close to the building entrance to keep the rain off of it. Parking a bike in a single office isn't a big deal, but if the bike is in a walkway area it becomes a hazard - not to mention an eyesore (not everyone finds metal tubing, chains, cables and gears as appealing as I do).
If you owned the office space would you feel the same way?
If you owned the office space would you feel the same way?
#13
You have been descriminated against!! Call the media in, get Critical Mass to hold a 'round the clock rally, get a pro bono lawyer or call the ACLU or AARP 'er somthin'
Make a stink so it's more trouble to not let you bring your bike in. Beauracrats hate stink.
Make a stink so it's more trouble to not let you bring your bike in. Beauracrats hate stink.
#14
Randomhead
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 25,930
Likes: 4,825
From: Happy Valley, Pennsylvania
I've brought my bike inside any number of times. The floor of my lab is currently covered in ... footprints. There may be the slightest hint of a tire track on a really bad day.
#15
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 328
Likes: 0
From: Las Cruces, NM
Bikes: 2007 Surly Cross Check, 199? Novara Alpine
tough situation. On the one hand, you would think that your employer would be more sensitive to your needs. On the other hand, if cyclists want equality we need to accept that we can't expect to be special. Would it be possible for all of your co-workers to park bikes as well? It there is a good bike rack, I say use it. For now, there is no cultural norm that says bike commuting is ok. Until there is we must continue to use the best that is available to us. I say do your best to find a way to keep your bike in the building. If it doesn't work out, bite the bullet and park at the rack. While I would initially want to put a rack in a parking spot, that would probably only cause more trouble. Go with the flow and hope that it gets better.
#16
Bureaucrats hate people who make stink, too, and don't feel shy about retaliation. I would advise against a confrontational approach.
#18
Banned.
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 825
Likes: 0
From: Sioux City, Iowa
Bikes: Vision R40 Recumbent
I think cyclefreaksix was, in part at least, being sarcastic. Bicycle commuters are not a protected class, so there is no grounds for discrimination. That said though, I disagree with you on not making a stink. I would, but not because I felt discriminated against but because of the dumb reason for losing the privilege of parking my bike inside. "Just because I got an email."? I mean come on, the landlord can come up with a better reason then that.
#19
pedaler
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 255
Likes: 1
From: NYC
Bikes: 2023 Brompton C Line Electric
Here's an idea that many people love, but to my knowledge has not been done. Buy a crappy van for as cheap as possible, and park it in the parking lot permanently. Whether it runs or not is immaterial so long as the locks work. Use the van as a mobile storage locker inside which you leave your bike during work. If they're happy to give you a 6'x15' space to park for free, use it!
Bonus points for removing the engine and replacing it with a flower planter.
So ridiculous, like the bike was harassing anyone. Good luck however you handle it. For a more conventional approach, do you have the sort of relationship with your management that you can enlist their help in dealing with the assh*le landlord?
Bonus points for removing the engine and replacing it with a flower planter.
So ridiculous, like the bike was harassing anyone. Good luck however you handle it. For a more conventional approach, do you have the sort of relationship with your management that you can enlist their help in dealing with the assh*le landlord?
#20
Drops small screws


Joined: May 2008
Posts: 2,608
Likes: 9
From: NYC Metro Area
Bikes: Soma Grand Randonneur, modified Xootr Swift, Trek 1000SL with broken brifter from running it into a hotel porte-cochère
Is there a freight elevator? Offer to use it. Also offer to be there slightly earlier or later so you don't inconvenience people.
I realize you're not really inconveniencing anybody, but see if the offer works. That's one way bike messengers get around this.
I realize you're not really inconveniencing anybody, but see if the offer works. That's one way bike messengers get around this.
#21
Senior Member
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 281
Likes: 2
From: Cincinnati, OH
Bikes: '08 Schwinn Super Sport "Betty, '09 Trek 1.2 "Veronica"
He did and he did. He had a written agreement. If there wasn't anything in the the terms like a "people who are arseholes and complain because I'm helping the environment, but don't give a rat's arse and this agreement is void" clause, would he not have a binding agreement?
#22
Drops small screws


Joined: May 2008
Posts: 2,608
Likes: 9
From: NYC Metro Area
Bikes: Soma Grand Randonneur, modified Xootr Swift, Trek 1000SL with broken brifter from running it into a hotel porte-cochère
That's what I get for posting when sleep-deprived. Never mind...
#25
Senior Member

Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 13,237
Likes: 75
From: Fallbrook,Calif./Palau del Vidre, France
Bikes: Klein QP, Fuji touring, Surly Cross Check, BCH City bike
Shortly after I began riding to work, a new bike rack was put in place outside the building.
I had an interview this afternoon with the "landlord"...and he absolutely would not hear me. He could not state a single time when my use of the elevators affected others. I even offered to walk the bike up the 12 flights of stairs. Nada. He based his decision on the fact that he got an email.
But he suggested I get a cheaper bike so I could use the rack without fear.
Out of 800 employees, I am the only one who commutes, so this is seen as a "privilege".
Thanks for letting me vent.
__________________
Pray for the Dead and Fight like Hell for the Living

^ Since January 1, 2012
Pray for the Dead and Fight like Hell for the Living
^ Since January 1, 2012




