Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Singlespeed & Fixed Gear (https://www.bikeforums.net/singlespeed-fixed-gear/)
-   -   front wheel drum (https://www.bikeforums.net/singlespeed-fixed-gear/174580-front-wheel-drum.html)

cogsci 02-17-06 01:31 AM

front wheel drum
 
My track frame is not drilled for front brake, I want to ride with a front brake... some of the time.
Anyone ever used a front drum brake with some sort of release mechanism, maybe those bmx folding seat post clamps.
I know SRAM and Shimano both make these sort of hubs right now, I want to know if anyone knows if they work ok (with a bmx lever)

marqueemoon 02-17-06 01:37 AM

Here's an ANT with a drum brake, and it looks like the answer is yes.

http://www.antbikemike.com/images/Bi...r/iver3big.jpg

Fugazi Dave 02-17-06 01:47 AM

That's a really good idea, actually. Interesting.

frameteam2003 02-17-06 07:30 AM

The mallard drums are a little smaller and a lot better looking if you can find one

Surlyoldfart 02-17-06 07:46 AM

That's an SRAM drum I believe. looks slick. They are most often used on tandems and heavy tourers, so they should stop HARD, but they are heavy compared to a conventional front brake.

I've been wanting to put drum brakes front and rear on an old Schwinn Phantom style cruiser with 26" MTB rims. I think it would make an awsome battleship town cruiser.

lz4005 02-17-06 08:54 AM

Drum brakes are used on tandems and tourers because you can use them on long downhills to control your speed without the overheating failures you can get with rim brakes. I've seen them operated with click-shifters for that purpose. Other than that they don't work better than rim brakes. Better than nothing, though. And looks really nice.

max-a-mill 02-17-06 09:28 AM

off-topic but that bike is SOOOOO HOT!!!!!!

chicagoamdream 02-17-06 09:31 AM

This is surely more work than drilling the frame/chrome drilled fork from BikeWorks.

r-dub 02-17-06 09:32 AM

two of our cargo bikes have drum brakes. Significantly inferior stopping power compared to v's, and a ***** to patch a tube, but consistant power in any weather and under load...

lz4005 02-17-06 09:55 AM

I forgot about the all weather part. That is another plus.
I'm seriously thinking about putting one on my coaster brake Steamroller now.

trespasser 02-17-06 10:05 AM

this is what you want.

http://www.d1.dion.ne.jp/~amvna/net/...ma/breaki1.jpg
link

Joe Loco 02-17-06 10:18 AM


Originally Posted by trespasser

Hey... similar hubs are also available. One (negative) thing about these is there's a built-in elastomer which "prevents" you from locking up the hub / taking a header. But hey, perhaps you wanted to stop short? I've read that it's possible to disable this elastomer, but that remains unsubstantiated...

Also, I had thought the case for disc brakes is that they require an appropriate fork, due to the transfer of force / stress to the fork leg... anyone know why/how this should be different for front drum/roller brakes?

Aeroplane 02-17-06 11:32 AM

Probably the same reason coaster brakes don't require extra bracing in the rear, where most disk brakes do. Disc brakes are super-powerful, and these just aren't.

Plus, it looks like that arm on the drum brake goes a long ways up the fork. Maybe that plays a part too?

r-dub 02-17-06 11:52 AM

It's early, and I'm still trying to wrap my head around it, but I think there's also something about how the disc is braking directly against the fork, but the drum brake is braking against the drum shell...I think that the only force being exerted on the fork for drum brakes is the force of your hand and the lever pulling the pieces together.

marqueemoon 02-17-06 12:13 PM


Originally Posted by max-a-mill
off-topic but that bike is SOOOOO HOT!!!!!!

I agree. I think the drum brake looks a little chunky, but supposedly the builder went with that allow the rims to be fully powdercoated for a cleaner look.

HereNT 02-17-06 12:20 PM


Originally Posted by trespasser
this is what you want.
link

Damn - I need to get one of those for my Bianchi...

lz4005 02-17-06 12:20 PM

As I understand it, disc brakes need to be attached to _stiffer_, not necessarily stronger, frame/fork members in order to minimize flex that would make them not work properly.

This definitely goes in my mental file of what I'd have built if I had all the money in the world: custom frame with built-in threaded chain tensioners like the one on the Ant above, plus built-in tabs to hold the brake arms for a coaster rear hub and front drum brake. And non-machined powdercoated rims.

cogsci 02-17-06 01:15 PM


Originally Posted by chicagoamdream
This is surely more work than drilling the frame/chrome drilled fork from BikeWorks.

It would be more expensive, but it would allow you to convert the bike back to track form, by changing the wheel and unclipping the bmx lever. You wouldn't have to change the fork (pain in the ass)

chicagoamdream 02-17-06 01:28 PM


Originally Posted by cogsci
It would be more expensive, but it would allow you to convert the bike back to track form, by changing the wheel and unclipping the bmx lever. You wouldn't have to change the fork (pain in the ass)

Drilled forks w/o brakes will not compromise the trackiness of your bike, and unbolting a brake from the fork crown is certainly less work than unbolting the arm from the fork and switching wheels. That said, I kind of hope you do this.

cogsci 02-17-06 01:54 PM

Everyone knows front rim-brakes look stupid and will probably result in a months long dry spell, with spring approaching, I just can't afford that.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:48 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.