Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Singlespeed & Fixed Gear (https://www.bikeforums.net/singlespeed-fixed-gear/)
-   -   Why not use a backpack? (https://www.bikeforums.net/singlespeed-fixed-gear/236095-why-not-use-backpack.html)

ryand 10-12-06 11:06 AM

do you guys know where i can buy a distressed courier bag?

(aka why wont this thread just die with the rest of them)

Ken Cox 10-12-06 11:23 AM

My 18 year-old son and I share a Chrome Metropolis, a Chrome Kremlin, a cotton newspaperboy bag, and various backpacks.

My son definitely prefers the backpacks and I definitely prefer the Chrome messenger bags and the cotton newspaperboy bag.

I prefer the messenger bags because they distribute the load better, for me, and I sense that I have a lower center of gravity with the messenger bags.
I forget I have them on my back.

My son prefers the packs because the load feels more directly attached to his body and therefore more controlled.

He rides a lot faster and more aggressively than do I, but I don't think that makes the difference as much as simple personal preference.

Pemdas 10-12-06 01:35 PM

this thread delivers. maybe, idk, i didnt read the whole thing. i started using my girlfriend's old timbuk2 a whileago. she wasnt using it and i found the design made the 12pack inside it very accessable. now that im takin classes and loadin it with books im def in the market for a backpack.

on a side note: these stupid fridge packs are makin it hard to shop for a new bag.

nolageek 10-12-06 02:05 PM

My $.02...

I was using a backpack for a while and I found that no matter where it was on my back it was always pulling back my shoulders and made my neck hurt if I was in the drops (sometimes, but rare). Plus, all that tight clocse contact was WAY hot in the New Orleans climate. I bought a discounted crumpler bag to test the mess bag configuration and found that it was much more comfortable and cooler (as in temperature.)

Plus, after I broke my collarbone last year backbacks HURT like hell when my shoulder gets sore. Which is odd, because I thought the backpack would be better.

After I started doing on-site appointments and needed to bring cabling, routers, modems, tools etc with me I had to upgrade to the bigger Jandd Iniki and haven't looked back. Messenger bags are doubleplus good while riding, IMHO.

celephaiz 10-12-06 02:28 PM

is it just me, or does this phrase


Originally Posted by xthugmurderx
i wish i would have had a backpack while messengering. that should would have been awesome. sure, you'd have to take it all the way off (OH NO!) when you need to get something out, but it's more comfortable, and better on your shoulder over time. you guys that aren't messengers try carrying 120 pounds in two copy boxes a few block with an over the shoulder bag. that **** KILLS. .


entirely contradict this one?



Originally Posted by xthugmurderx
remember kids...messenger bags are for messengering. not carrying schoolbooks.


it would seem that by your logic, you're better off using mess bags for non mess purposes.



*edit* gotta love people who take each word as literaly as possible without care for sentiment....

i guess i should have said, that in finding mess bags to be unsuitable for mess work, to state that mess bags are only for mess work is perhaps not entirely contradictory, but certainly a ridiculous statement. Why not either say mess bags are useless? - the actual extension of the logic. And yes they do have something to do with each other. the subject, mess bags, is the same.

and of course my point being, rather than nitpicking as mr not taking sides is doing, that if something is ill suited for the purpose someone states is it's only purpose (and they conceed that something else works better), yet many find it perfect for their own purposes, it cannot be only for messing. Wow that was truly a convoluted thought. Once again if the grammar police would take a doughnut break, they might see what i'm saying, nah probably not.

carleton 10-12-06 02:47 PM


Originally Posted by celephaiz
is it just me, or does this phrase entirely contradict this one?

Not taking sides here but, yeah it's just you.

The former expresses his desire for a backpack when he messengered. The second states that that messenger bags are made for messenger work (even though he didn't like using them)

One statement has nothing to do with the other although they are related by subject matter.

ryand 10-12-06 02:49 PM

carleton, why are you so smart and level headed?

my response would have been:
"no, you suck, let the thread die."

edit; why do i keep posting in here? ugh, im an idiot.

Placid Casual 10-12-06 04:53 PM


Originally Posted by ryand
my response would have been:
"no, you suck, let the thread die."

Do you spend a lot of time visiting the sets of television shows you don't like and trying to talk the cast and crew into not making the shows anymore? Just curious.

bmxdan 10-12-06 05:26 PM

I rock them both.
My backpack:
+ bigger than my messenger for large loads (non heavy ones)
+ Lots of pockets for EVERY LITTLE THING in my apartment
+lots of straps (chest and waist) to keep it from shifting
- doesnt colapse as well as my messenger when i stuff it under my pedicab (or other tight place) for storage due to all the padding
- Heavy loads make me unstable with my backpack (center of weight is about 6" behind my lower back) even when the bag is hiked up high.

Chrome lg messenger
+ Most of the weight is distributed along my chest by the strap and not on my shoulder
+ most comfortable while riding (hiked up high on my back, oh yeah)
+ stays in place with out using the extra strap
+ easy to grab items while in motion
+ most comfortable when carrying heavy medium sized loads.
- cant carry as much as my backpack
- not as much padding as my backpack for wierd pokey shaped objects
- too few pockets (as compared to my backpack)

those are the + and - of my two bags. my backpack is a large bmx backpack similar to this one.
http://www.danscomp.com/730013.php?cat=STREETWEAR
but bigger.

-

bicycle 10-12-06 05:37 PM


Originally Posted by xthugmurderx
and remember kids...messenger bags are for messengering. not carrying schoolbooks.

why not?

carleton 10-12-06 10:27 PM


Originally Posted by ryand
carleton, why are you so smart and level headed?

I have moments of clarity when the meds wear off.















(just kidding :D . Drug free)

Moximitre 10-12-06 10:33 PM

I rock a crappy Timbuk2 for everything except laundry. for that, I use what was called by the ArmyNavySurplusi bought it at, an "israeli air defense bag". It's a frickin huge backpacke that I can fit 45lbs of laundry in. and it's still comfy.

Israeli Air defense bags are the new white belt.
(i've always wanted to say that)


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:23 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.