Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Singlespeed & Fixed Gear (https://www.bikeforums.net/singlespeed-fixed-gear/)
-   -   brooks seats (https://www.bikeforums.net/singlespeed-fixed-gear/408277-brooks-seats.html)

Sixty Fiver 04-17-08 02:08 AM

I have a leather fetish.

I'm also looking forward to testing the new Brooks as it may really help with some issues I have been having with regular saddles... a nerve impingement in my hip has been causing a lot of pain and it is exacerbated when there is any pressure on my perineal area.

I have a good collection of leather saddles that date back to the late 30's and without a doubt, these are the most comfortable saddles I own... only one of them is a Brooks (a B66).

I like the idea of owning a perfectly comfortable saddle that, if properly maintained, will last 100,000 miles and even know a fair number of vegans who ride on used leather saddles since they are simply the best. and

A saddle that might last the average person a lifetime is far better than a synthetic saddle with a limited lifespan while for me, 100,000 miles is about ten years of riding and above all else, I like to be comfortable.

captsven 04-17-08 05:48 AM

I have tried one Brooks saddle and could not get adjusted to it. I am in on the cut-out test and should be getting it soon.

My only question/issue is what do you do when it rains? I ride in the rain and I do not want to **** up the saddle. Do I need to do something special to it? I do have Proofhide frmo the previous saddle.

bonechilling 04-17-08 06:00 AM

Just make sure to Proofhide the bottom of the saddle, too. If you ride in the rain, I wouldn't worry about it. Your ass is on top, and should keep it reasonably dry, and the Proofhide on the bottom should do the same thing. If you're locking up in the rain, wrap a plastic bag around the saddle.

mattface 04-17-08 06:15 AM

ai had a Fizik Arione. It was OK, but I traded it for a brand new Brooks Professional, and that has been the most comfortable saddle for me yet. I also have a chopped B17, and a Selle Italia SLR, and an Old Avocet Racing, and a Turbo, and a Flite. To me the Avocet racing and the Turbo were the most comfortable. I haven't put many miles on the flite yet, but I intend to compare it to the SLR this summer.

stuckinatx 04-17-08 07:48 AM


Originally Posted by sp00ki (Post 6530925)
probably from lugging around five extra pounds of dead skin...

This rhetoric would be a lot more meaningful if you weren't running leather toe straps. I know you had them before you were vegan. I don't care.

freecycle 04-17-08 08:03 AM

im curios brooks-lovers, im a leather fiend and anything natural i can fit on me and my bike makes me happy...

but i ride dropped pretty low, and consistently, is there a brooks for my arse out there?? (running a very comfy, but slowly dying avocet mtb seat rite now)

04jtb 04-17-08 08:17 AM


Originally Posted by captsven (Post 6533866)
My only question/issue is what do you do when it rains? I ride in the rain and I do not want to **** up the saddle. Do I need to do something special to it? I do have Proofhide frmo the previous saddle.


Originally Posted by bonechilling (Post 6533894)
Just make sure to Proofhide the bottom of the saddle, too. If you ride in the rain, I wouldn't worry about it. Your ass is on top, and should keep it reasonably dry, and the Proofhide on the bottom should do the same thing. If you're locking up in the rain, wrap a plastic bag around the saddle.

+1 to this, but I've never proofhided mine and have ridden it in the rain 2 or 3 times, and it is OK still, but I think it had been proofhided before I got it (second hand)

Ohmyguinness 04-17-08 09:17 AM

I heard if you ride one long enough, you can become branded. Truth?

ianjk 04-17-08 09:39 AM


Originally Posted by sp00ki (Post 6530925)
probably from lugging around five extra pounds of dead skin...


1/2 extra lb. (actual diff. between my lightest and brooks) = 1/24 mph hour over varied terrain (based on statistics from Cornell reseach on bike weight vs speed). Well worth it for butt-comfort on long rides.

hxzero 04-17-08 09:56 AM


Originally Posted by freecycle (Post 6534410)
im curios brooks-lovers, im a leather fiend and anything natural i can fit on me and my bike makes me happy...

but i ride dropped pretty low, and consistently, is there a brooks for my arse out there?? (running a very comfy, but slowly dying avocet mtb seat rite now)

The Swift or Swallow are narrower than the B17, although these are almost prohibitively expensive ;\

mattface 04-17-08 10:19 AM


Originally Posted by freecycle (Post 6534410)
im curios brooks-lovers, im a leather fiend and anything natural i can fit on me and my bike makes me happy...

but i ride dropped pretty low, and consistently, is there a brooks for my arse out there?? (running a very comfy, but slowly dying avocet mtb seat rite now)

The Professional is better for low bars, and is slightly narrower than the B-17. If the Avocet racing fits you well (like it does me) then the Professional probably will also.

Quinn8it 04-17-08 10:20 AM


Originally Posted by hxzero (Post 6535148)
The Swift or Swallow are narrower than the B17, although these are almost prohibitively expensive ;\

Its a little better if you get the chrome instead of the Ti....
$186 shipped for a chrome swallow...
http://www.lickbike.com/productpage.asp?PART_NUM_SUB='0905-05'

freecycle 04-17-08 10:24 AM


Originally Posted by Quinn8it (Post 6535312)
Its a little better if you get the chrome instead of the Ti....
$186 shipped for a chrome swallow...
http://www.lickbike.com/productpage.asp?PART_NUM_SUB='0905-05'

thats not that bad, but still, for a seat? thats approaching what my wheelset cost me, once shipping is in...

my idea of extravagance was spending 74 bucks with shipping on a helmet..

the wheelset was unavoidable :D:D

monkeyking 04-17-08 11:53 AM


Originally Posted by Falkon (Post 6530832)
Yes. I'm getting to test the new brooks with a cutout that cures aids.

I just roll with the Kashimax 5Gold, which cures all feeling I used to have in my genitals / desire for sex, thus eliminating my chances of aids.

Exempt 04-17-08 11:59 AM

just as a side note for all you self righteous *******s who say brooks is murder

they dont use the leather unless the cow died of natural causes. Meaning they're trying to be 0 waste when it comes to the animal's death.

so go boil your heads

bonechilling 04-17-08 01:18 PM


Originally Posted by Exempt (Post 6536011)
just as a side note for all you self righteous *******s who say brooks is murder

they dont use the leather unless the cow died of natural causes. Meaning they're trying to be 0 waste when it comes to the animal's death.

so go boil your heads

So a captive-bolt gun is a "natural cause?"

freecycle 04-17-08 01:21 PM


Originally Posted by bonechilling (Post 6536488)
So a captive-bolt gun is a "natural cause?"

if one loves cows and fowl so much, one may go hug them. this is about seats, their comfort and their durability, not wishy-washy save the animals chatter. im sure there is a thread or two dedicated to that cause/ peta greenpeace websites.

all hippie treehugging is to be taken to a thread/forum that is dedicated to that cause, not inserted into a bike forum, one specifically about a leather seat manufacturer.

im sure im not the only one with this sentiment.

CliftonGK1 04-17-08 01:40 PM


Originally Posted by bonechilling (Post 6536488)
So a captive-bolt gun is a "natural cause?"

Sure. The cow got thunked in the temple with a high speed steel hammer.
Naturally, it didn't survive.

Bala 04-17-08 02:07 PM


Originally Posted by freecycle (Post 6536505)
if one loves cows and fowl so much, one may go hug them. this is about seats, their comfort and their durability, not wishy-washy save the animals chatter. im sure there is a thread or two dedicated to that cause/ peta greenpeace websites.

all hippie treehugging is to be taken to a thread/forum that is dedicated to that cause, not inserted into a bike forum, one specifically about a leather seat manufacturer.

im sure im not the only one with this sentiment.

You're not.

I have B-17s on both my bikes and love them.

bonechilling 04-17-08 02:08 PM


Originally Posted by freecycle (Post 6536505)
if one loves cows and fowl so much, one may go hug them. this is about seats, their comfort and their durability, not wishy-washy save the animals chatter. im sure there is a thread or two dedicated to that cause/ peta greenpeace websites.

all hippie treehugging is to be taken to a thread/forum that is dedicated to that cause, not inserted into a bike forum, one specifically about a leather seat manufacturer.

im sure im not the only one with this sentiment.

What I said had nothing to do with cow or fowl hugging. Your ignorant knee-jerk reaction just proves that you're absolutely the stupidest and least interesting new poster on this board in a while. Go complain about positive rise stems or something.

hxzero 04-17-08 02:16 PM

Why can't we all just smoke a j and chill out

freecycle 04-17-08 02:18 PM


Originally Posted by bonechilling (Post 6536800)
What I said had nothing to do with cow or fowl hugging. Your ignorant knee-jerk reaction just proves that you're absolutely the stupidest and least interesting new poster on this board in a while. Go complain about positive rise stems or something.

i dont feel its stupid or knee jerk, if that was a joke, alright, its just some pent up frustration from having to skip every second post during a discussion on the comfort and usability of bikes, because some people keep going on about how leather is cruel, etc etc.

*skips back to foo*

thanks for seat info! btw saw a honey brooks b17 for 75 bucks, if only it were black!

wolfbrother 04-17-08 02:48 PM

I just put a brooks on my bike and I really like it. Once it's broken in I think I'll like it even more. I think I'm going to put one on my other ride, too.

The only thing I don't like about it so far is how slippery it is. I wonder if any of my brooks-riding friends could tell me if this will get better or not . . .

mander 04-17-08 03:28 PM


Originally Posted by wolfbrother (Post 6537096)
I just put a brooks on my bike and I really like it. Once it's broken in I think I'll like it even more. I think I'm going to put one on my other ride, too.

The only thing I don't like about it so far is how slippery it is. I wonder if any of my brooks-riding friends could tell me if this will get better or not . . .

Yeah that goes away fast.

jetbike 04-17-08 07:11 PM


Originally Posted by RDRomano (Post 6533622)
World War Z, anyone?


Brooks saddles and Max Brooks.

Just get Mel and we have the set. You get a free steak.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:25 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.