Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Singlespeed & Fixed Gear (https://www.bikeforums.net/singlespeed-fixed-gear/)
-   -   which white wheelset should i get? (https://www.bikeforums.net/singlespeed-fixed-gear/427562-white-wheelset-should-i-get.html)

bryyando 06-08-08 11:25 PM

which white wheelset should i get?
 
basically i narrowed it down to this seller. its pretty much the same wheel except for different hubs, pretty much my question is which hubs are better? or should i choose a different wheelset altogether?

http://cgi.ebay.com/AERO-TRACK-WHEEL...713.m153.l1262

http://cgi.ebay.com/WHITE-WEINMANN-D...713.m153.l1262

bdfresh 06-08-08 11:31 PM

well one is machine and one is not machine you have to decide if you want machined sidewalls or not. apples to apples one is green one is red...

matt wisconsin 06-09-08 12:00 AM

Depending on your budget, you might want to dish out the extra cash and get the velocitys. I actually have a pair of the weinmanns and sort of regret it. People complain about the seems splitting a lot, they come with metal shavings still in the rims, etc.
Just a heads up before you buy Weinmann. But I also know a lot of people who have no problems and I've put 30 or so miles on mine with no real issues yet.

peabodypride 06-09-08 09:38 AM

I've put hundreds of miles on my new weinmanns in the last two weeks, no problems. My old set showed a hint of seem splitting but I'm sure they took care of it.

rduenas 06-09-08 10:04 AM

Neither.

bryyando 06-09-08 04:57 PM

maybe i should be more informative on my post. im looking to spend less then 200 shipped. have a white rim, black spokes, and a fixed/free hub.

cc700 06-09-08 05:00 PM

i'm happy with my dp18/formula set. cheap bombproof heavy and good looking.

bryyando 06-10-08 09:10 PM

or is there another seller i could get this set up from?

joetotale 06-10-08 09:19 PM


Originally Posted by matt wisconsin (Post 6845507)
Depending on your budget, you might want to dish out the extra cash and get the velocitys. I actually have a pair of the weinmanns and sort of regret it. People complain about the seems splitting a lot, they come with metal shavings still in the rims, etc.
Just a heads up before you buy Weinmann. But I also know a lot of people who have no problems and I've put 30 or so miles on mine with no real issues yet.

Ugh, the metal shavings!! I went through three tubes within the first two days of having my DP-18s, before I sanded down the interiors of the rims. No issues after this fix, but still frustrating.

gehrkead 06-10-08 09:28 PM

I would personally pick the formula set myself. I have the same set but yellow rims and black hubs/spokes. If you take care of them right away they will a great set of wheels. Psst I got my set from Wheel and Sprocket and they took my offer of $120 on the asking price of $199, plus it helped I could pick them up in the store. But point is offer much lower and they will more than likely accept.

dervish 06-10-08 09:29 PM

velocity baby

JayNev 06-10-08 09:30 PM

if it was me, out of those 2 choices id get the unmachined dp-18s, to answer your question

matt wisconsin 06-10-08 10:00 PM


Originally Posted by joetotale (Post 6858470)
Ugh, the metal shavings!! I went through three tubes within the first two days of having my DP-18s, before I sanded down the interiors of the rims. No issues after this fix, but still frustrating.

rim tape.:thumb:

thegoodfight 06-10-08 10:01 PM

man, why white? Why not red, yellow or black? Why you gotta be racist and ****?

bryyando 06-10-08 10:04 PM

im asian... it matches my bike. how about from here? and thanks for the offer tip. oh yeah. i run a front brake does it really matter what if its machined or not?

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...m=360060579225

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...m=360058713847

bionnaki 06-10-08 10:44 PM

you should get the IRO rim set - you can specify white rims. $269 and a quality build - pretty decent hubs.

joetotale 06-11-08 12:26 PM


Originally Posted by matt wisconsin (Post 6858752)
rim tape.:thumb:

The rims were taped, which made it even more frustrating.

Johnny Nemo 06-12-08 12:14 AM

Get the all-Australian Velocity's. There's a reason why so many use them... bombproof!

bryyando 06-15-08 05:13 PM

what are some cheap white hubs? i can't decide between black rims white hubs and white rims black hubs

Kol.klink 06-16-08 02:27 PM

Get the wienmanns and don't look back, Velocitiy Deep-V's are basically the same rim, with possibly better finish. When some one slags them ask them to explain From a technical stand point why velocitiys are better, the explanations that follow will have priceless entertainment value.

peabodypride 06-16-08 03:24 PM

http://www.revolutionbicyclerepair.c...eepv-white.jpg
You see those little stickers? You're paying for them and nothing else.

I firmly believe that Weinmanns are on par with "real" Deep Vs--until someone comes up with an independent, empirical, scientific test on strength differences they will both last the lifetime of your bike and look just fine.

cue endless bashing and anecdotal evidence of destroying weinmanns in one day.

edit: I argued this with Oh No before and one has to remember I am strictly talking about the rims themselves. Build quality is entirely dependent and it's no doubt a hand-built wheel will stay true longer and be stiffer than a machine-made Weinmann/Formula. But rim-to-rim they are remarkably similar.

diff_lock2 06-16-08 03:30 PM

Cane Creeks look good.

trons 06-16-08 06:35 PM


Originally Posted by Kol.klink (Post 6891678)
Get the wienmanns and don't look back, Velocitiy Deep-V's are basically the same rim, with possibly better finish. When some one slags them ask them to explain From a technical stand point why velocitiys are better, the explanations that follow will have priceless entertainment value.

true dat

physh 06-16-08 06:55 PM

I have dp-18's laced to formulas. 200 miles for far of curb hopping city riding and they are still true.

idiq 06-16-08 07:17 PM


Originally Posted by peabodypride (Post 6892077)
You see those little stickers? You're paying for them and nothing else.

I firmly believe that Weinmanns are on par with "real" Deep Vs--until someone comes up with an independent, empirical, scientific test on strength differences they will both last the lifetime of your bike and look just fine.

cue endless bashing and anecdotal evidence of destroying weinmanns in one day.

edit: I argued this with Oh No before and one has to remember I am strictly talking about the rims themselves. Build quality is entirely dependent and it's no doubt a hand-built wheel will stay true longer and be stiffer than a machine-made Weinmann/Formula. But rim-to-rim they are remarkably similar.

Uh yeah, they're both cheap double-wall rims with the same rim design (no additional joints / sleeves) and aero profile. On that note, the price of deep-Vs has gone up considerably over the past 2 years, they now cost almost $40 through J&B (not retail) while the DP-18s are somewhat close to $20 (again dealer side)


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:12 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.