505oh505

I just bought a campy super record pista crankset (nos and dirty cheap)... well, half of it, the drive side. the only problem is that the length is 177.5 (??). so I've been looking for a crank arm but can only find a 175 or a 180. if I used the 175 would my leg fall off or something? would I drift to the left when I pedal?

has anyone tried this? how did it work out?

ShaneRidesBikes

why would you want something longer than 175?

505oh505

cause it's campy s/r pista fool. also, I have this bike that was built for crit racing with a highass bottom bracket. I used 170's on my old ride with no death and that bb is an inch lower. the 177.5's are only a half inch longer.

dayvan cowboy

half inch means a lot when you're takin' real tight corners when ridin' fixed.

PluperfectArson

This is a terrible idea.

HandsomeRyan

Who buys half a crankset without knowing where the other half is coming from?

Someone who plans poorly-

TheDean

I seem to remember Sheldon strongly advising against this.

Scrodzilla

Sounds dumb.

Retro Grouch 

2 1/2 mm isn't very much. You wouldn't think it'd make much difference but my bet is it will feel wierd.

elTwitcho

As awesome as the one Super Record crank probably is, I'm pretty positive that two cranks that actually match is going to feel a lot better, even if they're cheap cranks as your saddle height is always going to be wrong for one of your legs with this setup.

Also, 177.5 is a stupid length unless you have really long legs or have a compelling reason to be using them. On the upstroke you're going to be raising your leg 15mm higher than you would with 170s and that personally sounds like a good way to get knee pains.

dsh

I'm sure your leg wont fall off, but any classiness you gained with the S/R crank, you lose because you have two different length cranks.

Scrodzilla

Cause and effect:

instant jackass

Yo!

Throw that on ebay and buy a matched pair.

bones_mcbones

you're going to **** up your body real bad. my cleat is out by like 5mm and I have to fix it cause it's ****ing me up

hairnet

I know someone who had a 170 and 172.5 set up. It ****ed up his leg on the longer crank because it caused him to rock side to side slightly. He would also over extend that leg at the bottom of the stroke because his saddle was set with the 170.


p.s. he didn't do it on purpose. A stupid mechanic replaced his damaged crank with the 172.5 thinking it was the same length as the other crank.

lz4005

Are your legs exactly the same length? Have you actually measured?
Buy your cranks accordingly.

timothyday

You should bend one of your saddle rails a little to lower or raise that half of your body a bit to compensate.

hairnet

I don't what what you should do if you ride with your street shoes but with clipless shoes you stack the cleat to compensate for a shorter leg.

beeftech

I lol'ed.

queerpunk

People change crank lengths by as little as 2.5mm because it can feel like a very big difference. I've ridden 165, 167.5, 170, and 172.5, and my body reacts to each differently. Jumping from 170s to 177.5, first of all, sounds like an uncomfortable change to make. And secondly, I really think that riding two cranks of different lengths at the same time would be very, very uncomfortable.

Scrodzilla

And just plain dumb.

Yo!

bones_mcbones

that's a whole lot of woman! Iggy don't stand a chance

Scrodzilla

I think this is the first time I've ever seen Iggy wearing a shirt.

hairnet

She's got some broad shoulders. Sure she's not a man?