![]() |
hub failure?
I have never before heard of hubs failing or exploding as I have read here. Cheap hubs usually just have higher friction, don't roll as smooth as higher quality hubs but I've never seen one "fail". Is this "failure" due to skidding?
|
It is relatively easy to strip a hub if it has been poorly manufactured or the lockring/cog were not properly tightend. I think that's how all of mine have failed. It's not about the bearings, it's about the threads on the hub, usually.
What do you ride? |
I have seen hubs (in the past) “explode” but it was not very common and rare today.
Older hubs had a sequential pall engagement that made them roll easier but didn’t distribute all the force to all the palls equally. |
1 Attachment(s)
I've killed a Suzue Basic hub as it just couldn't cope with skidding. You are right that cheap hubs just can't take the abuse. But then no hub I know has been built with skidding in mind. Chubs maybe?
But this is the best hub failure I've seen: A Campy record track hub which is hardly a 'cheap' hub. This image is from http://www.sheldonbrown.com/harris/record-track.html |
The term exploding refers to the internal palls of a hub breaking so it no longer holds in the drive direction.
What you show in your picture is flange failure due to abuse. |
i've 'killed a chub' in that the bearings went on a brand new chub within 6 months. so new bearings etc... but also, when i put a new cog on recently, the threads where definitely a little eaten up. cheap alloy. so i'm just waiting for that day that i tear the cog off of my chub. granted, i don't skid.. but still, constantly slowing down hills puts enough pressure on the cog/threads/hub.
for more info on chubs and bearings, see: http://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=41630 |
Once I got a chub when this cha cha blond gave me some tight face and I almost lost my bearings and started to skid.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:58 PM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.