Help I can't stop!
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Help I can't stop!
We were given a Kuwahara tandem that I am guessing was made in the mid 80's It has a 7 speed freewheel and triple crank and came from the factory with downtube shifters. It has been changed over to Shimano brifters. The brakes are NGC982 cantilever's with new Cool Stop salmon pads. I have watched several U-tube videos and read articles from Sheldon Brown to try to find a adjustment method that will help braking. I have tried changing the length of the straddle cable and shoe adjustments to no avail. It just doesn't stop good enough to feel safe. I can't even lock the back wheel up when riding it single and the front is the same. I have new cables ordered but I don't expect them to help as the old ones seem free and don't have much friction. Unless I have missed something the only thing I can think of is that the rims are too smooth. I have even took a red scotch brite pad and alcohol to them but that didn't seem to change the very slick appearance and feel that they have. They are 27" aluminum that I assume it came with new. It does have the Arai drum brake that was disconnected when they changed the shifters. I have added a friction shifter for it and it works well now. Any ideas? can I take sandpaper or something to the rims to rough them up? My granddaughter & I really like riding the bike but I am afraid I am going to crash and hurt us both.
#2
Senior Member
Those pads are good, and aluminum rims should be good. Those brakes were fairly reputable in there day. Try these, roughly in this order:
There aren't any pulleys or cable travel adjusters in the system, are there?
Lube (grease, silicone, etc) the brake pivots.
Make sure the housing and cables aren't dirty or rusted together. Lube (light oil, chain lube, silicone, etc) the cables where they are inside housing.
Make sure the cable housing ends are cut cleanly and that the ferrules (housing ends) are snug.
Make sure there aren't sharp bends in the cable housing.
Lower the straddle cable as much as possible.
Scuff the pads with sand paper.
Adjust the pads such that they're parallel/flush with the braking surface of the rim when the lever is pulled. 0.5mm of toe-in can help with squealing, but otherwise the pads should be parallel.
If you want to spend $20 for better brakes, Tekro RX5 or Tektro 926 linear pull ("Mini-V") brakes should drop right in.
Another upgrade would be "compressionless" brake housing.
There aren't any pulleys or cable travel adjusters in the system, are there?
Lube (grease, silicone, etc) the brake pivots.
Make sure the housing and cables aren't dirty or rusted together. Lube (light oil, chain lube, silicone, etc) the cables where they are inside housing.
Make sure the cable housing ends are cut cleanly and that the ferrules (housing ends) are snug.
Make sure there aren't sharp bends in the cable housing.
Lower the straddle cable as much as possible.
Scuff the pads with sand paper.
Adjust the pads such that they're parallel/flush with the braking surface of the rim when the lever is pulled. 0.5mm of toe-in can help with squealing, but otherwise the pads should be parallel.
If you want to spend $20 for better brakes, Tekro RX5 or Tektro 926 linear pull ("Mini-V") brakes should drop right in.
Another upgrade would be "compressionless" brake housing.
#3
rebmeM roineS
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Metro Indy, IN
Posts: 16,216
Bikes: Bacchetta Giro A20, RANS V-Rex, RANS Screamer
Mentioned: 15 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 653 Post(s)
Liked 347 Times
in
226 Posts
I wonder if a large part of the problem is the brifters? Are they supposed to be compatible with canti's? Kool Stop salmon are the go-to pads for most situations.
I haven't dealt with canti's for a long time - I find V-brakes much easier to deal with and are usually easy replacements.
I haven't dealt with canti's for a long time - I find V-brakes much easier to deal with and are usually easy replacements.
__________________
Bacchetta Giro A20, RANS V-Rex, RANS Screamer
Bacchetta Giro A20, RANS V-Rex, RANS Screamer
#4
Full Member
Also check the amount of slack in the brake cable (rear). When you squeeze the brake handle, does the handle move before the canti's start to move and once the pads contact the rim, does continued squeezing not add much pressure and just removes more slack from the cable run? If this is the case, you need to figure a way to eliminate the slack
I had this slack issue with my Spyre disc brakes and was only able to resolve by fashioning and installing a compression spring to take slack out of the line. Different brake setup for sure, but similar likely cause as most of the components in the system are designed for shorter cable runs.
I had this slack issue with my Spyre disc brakes and was only able to resolve by fashioning and installing a compression spring to take slack out of the line. Different brake setup for sure, but similar likely cause as most of the components in the system are designed for shorter cable runs.
#5
Senior Member
Thread Starter
New cables & housings on the way. I'll check everything mentioned when I install them. The pads are hitting squarely and pivots cleaned and lubed. I am not against swiching to different brakes in fact I tried a set of caliper brakes that I had from my road bike and they are way too short. I will research the above mentioned brakes when I get home to my computer.
#6
Junior Member
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Ottawa
Posts: 171
Bikes: Merlin Road, Rivendell Road, Arvon custom tandme, Hi-Light G-7
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 24 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 11 Times
in
10 Posts
I don't think the Shimano brifters will pull enough cable for cantilever brakes when there is long cable run.
I use old 8 speed Ergopower lever with old Shimano cantilever (unknown vintage) on the front and it works fine but the rear never worked well because of insufficient cable pull + long cable run.
We've switch to disk for the rear which has different set of issues.
For brifters, if you have the appropriate mounting holes, long reach side pulls might work better. Rivendell sells at least one long reach sidepull which might work with brifters.
https://www.rivbike.com/collections/...tro-r559-allen
I use old 8 speed Ergopower lever with old Shimano cantilever (unknown vintage) on the front and it works fine but the rear never worked well because of insufficient cable pull + long cable run.
We've switch to disk for the rear which has different set of issues.
For brifters, if you have the appropriate mounting holes, long reach side pulls might work better. Rivendell sells at least one long reach sidepull which might work with brifters.
https://www.rivbike.com/collections/...tro-r559-allen
#7
Senior Member
Thread Starter
The bike does have holes for caliper brakes. They would need to be long reach.
#8
Full Member
I am not familiar with your bike but make sure that the holes are for brakes and not just for fenders. If they are intended for fenders, there might not be enough strength to withstand braking forces.
#9
Senior Member
#10
Senior Member
Thread Starter
How do I tell? The holes are centered in the fork and the bridge between the seat stays just like they are on my Centurion road bike. The top of the fork looks to be a very solid casting with lugs for the forks.
#11
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Will the Shimano 7 speed brifters work with them? I am not even sure they are right for the cantilever's that are on there but the lever does move about 1/2 - 2/3 of the way to the bars when I have the pads adjusted about 1/8" from the wheel. They just feel like the old bikes we rode as kids with chrome steel wheels and little brake pads.
#12
Senior Member
Will the Shimano 7 speed brifters work with them? I am not even sure they are right for the cantilever's that are on there but the lever does move about 1/2 - 2/3 of the way to the bars when I have the pads adjusted about 1/8" from the wheel. They just feel like the old bikes we rode as kids with chrome steel wheels and little brake pads.
#13
Senior Member
Thread Starter
In general, road brake levers (brifters, STI, Ergopower, etc) work with short reach calipers, long reach calipers, mini-V, cantilever, and road disc brakes. Sure, there are some particular models of brake and lever that don’t work so well together. I believe Shimano RSX and 105 7-speed STI shifters had short pull brake levers, consistent with other road brake levers. The throw you’ve described sounds correct. What’s the chance that those brake pads sat on a shelf in direct sunlight for 15 years?
#14
Full Member
My experience, though, tells me that a frame built to support cantilever brakes would not burden the frame with the cost to support side pulls.
Again, I am not familiar with your frame. If in doubt, take it to your LBS.
#16
Senior Member
Thread Starter
According to the link to the travel agents I have short pull levers and brakes so I don't think they would help. I did replace the back cable and housing today and shortened the housing from the lever to the first cable stop by several inches. I made sure all the ends were square and had ferules. The lever feels firmer and it seems to stop a little better but that may just be wishful thinking. I still can't lock up the back wheel when solo. The lever doesn't touch the bars. I understand that the NGC 982 brakes are well thought of and these seem to be in excellent condition. I am back to wondering about the braking surface on the rims. They are very smooth and look like they have some kind of a grey coating on the entire wheel, its shiny where the brakes run but you can still see the grey. Has anyone ran into wheels that were too slick other than chrome steel wheels?
#17
Senior Member
According to the link to the travel agents I have short pull levers and brakes so I don't think they would help. I did replace the back cable and housing today and shortened the housing from the lever to the first cable stop by several inches. I made sure all the ends were square and had ferules. The lever feels firmer and it seems to stop a little better but that may just be wishful thinking. I still can't lock up the back wheel when solo. The lever doesn't touch the bars. I understand that the NGC 982 brakes are well thought of and these seem to be in excellent condition. I am back to wondering about the braking surface on the rims. They are very smooth and look like they have some kind of a grey coating on the entire wheel, its shiny where the brakes run but you can still see the grey. Has anyone ran into wheels that were too slick other than chrome steel wheels?
#18
Senior Member
Thread Starter
The rear wheel says UAKI 27 X 1/18 W/O LA MADE IN JAPAN no other markings. I googled them but didn't find much but I am not a expert googler. Is that a word googler? I wonder what a LA is. Whatever it is I guess I don't have one.
#19
Senior Member
"LA" supposedly means "light alloy"
Those rims are not likely coated in anything beyond natural oxidation at this point.
#20
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Maybe I am just being a wimp and this thing is just plain hard to stop. Since I consider my most likely stoker "precious cargo" I really want to be as safe as possible. I do feel a little better since I got the arai drum brake hooked up to a friction shifter but its not very handy for quick stops. Its more like a drag brake for descents
#21
Full Member
Maybe I am just being a wimp and this thing is just plain hard to stop. Since I consider my most likely stoker "precious cargo" I really want to be as safe as possible. I do feel a little better since I got the arai drum brake hooked up to a friction shifter but its not very handy for quick stops. Its more like a drag brake for descents
Our first Tandem has cantilever brakes and when we purchased it we had is upgraded from bar end shifters to STI brifters. We never rode the bike with the original brake set up (other than one test ride around the block) when we purchased it so I had nothing to compare to. We lived in a flat area and I just thought stopping took longer. We subsequently moved to a very hilly areas and I quickly became very uncomfortable with the bikes braking ability on the hills so I added a drum brake. Fast forward 10 years and we buy our current bike with disc brakes and I was very uncomfortable at first not having the drum brake as I did not know how disc brakes performed. Now that I am used to the disc brakes, I would never consider going back to rim brakes, but there are a lot of bikes with them that people ride everyday without problem.
Looking back on it, I probably experienced the same thing you have, namely, changing to STI levels which do not have sufficient pull for the cantilever brakes. (I did have to improve the rear braking of the disc brake with a compression spring as I mentioned above, but with this thread it seems reasonable to assume we did experience the same behavior.)
That said, we never had an issue stopping with just cantilevers, it just took longer to stop. Once we starting riding the hills, we spent a few teeth grinding death grip on the brakes descents that was resolved with the drum.
I have never locked up the rear wheel, nor have I tried. I would suggest you go somewhere flat and without traffic, like a large empty parking lot, and with the stoker, get the bike up to speed and perform hard braking and take measurements of distance to full stop and see how it really is behaving. (For downhill stopping you will always have time to apply the drag brake). If the stopping distance is not to bad, perhaps you can just adjust your riding style to pre-anticpate the scenarios where you might have to come to a quick stop or you might also consider and setting your stoker up with a hand brake lever that controls the drum and work a communication protocol for the stoker to apply the drum brake while you are working both hand brakes. I have heard mentioned several times that on some teams, the stoker controls the drag brake.
#22
Full Member
You should be able to get as much braking power from rim brakes as from discs in dry weather. Enough to skid the rear tire without a stoker mounted.
Both our tandems came with cantilever brakes and STI levers. I was never fully happy with the rear braking on either one. I changed to mini-V Tektro 926 on one and XTR V with a change agent pulley on the other. Either bike will skid the rear wheel (and ruin the tire in the process!) The mini-Vs require an adjustable noodle to ease wheel removal and a very true wheel due to tight clearance.
Make sure your rim and pads are not contaminated with anything, use a good solvent and friction to clean. I am a big fan of Swissstop green pads. Powerful, quiet, long lasting and do not get embedded with grit. Depending on the flexibility of your seat stays, a brake arch stiffener may also make a difference.
Both our tandems came with cantilever brakes and STI levers. I was never fully happy with the rear braking on either one. I changed to mini-V Tektro 926 on one and XTR V with a change agent pulley on the other. Either bike will skid the rear wheel (and ruin the tire in the process!) The mini-Vs require an adjustable noodle to ease wheel removal and a very true wheel due to tight clearance.
Make sure your rim and pads are not contaminated with anything, use a good solvent and friction to clean. I am a big fan of Swissstop green pads. Powerful, quiet, long lasting and do not get embedded with grit. Depending on the flexibility of your seat stays, a brake arch stiffener may also make a difference.
#23
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: Upstate South Carolina
Posts: 1,092
Bikes: 1980's Spectrum 10 sp Campagnolo Centaur, 1990 Eddy Merckx 10 sp Campagnolo Centaur, Bushnell Tandem, Co-Motion Speedster Tandem
Mentioned: 5 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 185 Post(s)
Liked 102 Times
in
65 Posts
#24
don't try this at home.
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: N. KY
Posts: 5,940
Mentioned: 10 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 974 Post(s)
Liked 512 Times
in
352 Posts
If your brake levers don't bottom out against the bars, then the cable pull sounds okay.
You have cantilevers, not V-brakes, correct? V-brakes need more cable pull than newer shifter brake levers allow, so the levers bottom out. Mini-V brakes have the correct pull. The downside is mini-Vs have very little travel, so the pads need to be very close to the rims, and accurately aligned. It's fussy to set up correctly.
Are the pads pressing against the rims over their whole surface? Take off the front wheel and check the pad's wear patterns. EDIT -- you mentioned: " The pads are hitting squarely and pivots cleaned and lubed." I guess you could check anyway.
I don't think you need to roughen the rims. Factory roughened rims get completely smoothed out from pad wear, anyway.
You have cantilevers, not V-brakes, correct? V-brakes need more cable pull than newer shifter brake levers allow, so the levers bottom out. Mini-V brakes have the correct pull. The downside is mini-Vs have very little travel, so the pads need to be very close to the rims, and accurately aligned. It's fussy to set up correctly.
Are the pads pressing against the rims over their whole surface? Take off the front wheel and check the pad's wear patterns. EDIT -- you mentioned: " The pads are hitting squarely and pivots cleaned and lubed." I guess you could check anyway.
I don't think you need to roughen the rims. Factory roughened rims get completely smoothed out from pad wear, anyway.
Last edited by rm -rf; 05-07-18 at 02:47 PM.
#25
xlbs
Join Date: Jul 2015
Location: Bailieboro, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 89
Bikes: True North TI, Miyata 1000LT, Rodriguez tandem, Fontan vintage road, Sekine vintage road, Catrike recumbent
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 10 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 7 Times
in
6 Posts
Over years of playing around with cantilevers and road levers of various types, converting to V brakes with travel agents has always proven to be the best way to increase braking power (and modulation too) for us.
I took the time to get out my tape measure on several sets of brakes; the mechanical advantage of most good V brakes is immediately obvious.
Even if your brifters are not approaching the bars, if you are having trouble with full power you really owe it to your stoker (as above) to consider travel agents etc. I've challenged myself to find the most powerful pulling position on my brifters, and it's best with minimal pull where my hand/fingers are at maximum closing power just at the start of the action. Whenever my fingers are close to the bar I know that I have missed the best pulling position because my hand is weaker there.
Recently I have also experimented with setting my right brifter to the front brake that my stronger hand controls the most important brake on the bike.
Finally, caliper brakes are just not as powerful as V brakes with travel agents.
Drum brakes are great for setting some resistance on long descents, but they are a poor third cousin for stopping power.
I took the time to get out my tape measure on several sets of brakes; the mechanical advantage of most good V brakes is immediately obvious.
Even if your brifters are not approaching the bars, if you are having trouble with full power you really owe it to your stoker (as above) to consider travel agents etc. I've challenged myself to find the most powerful pulling position on my brifters, and it's best with minimal pull where my hand/fingers are at maximum closing power just at the start of the action. Whenever my fingers are close to the bar I know that I have missed the best pulling position because my hand is weaker there.
Recently I have also experimented with setting my right brifter to the front brake that my stronger hand controls the most important brake on the bike.
Finally, caliper brakes are just not as powerful as V brakes with travel agents.
Drum brakes are great for setting some resistance on long descents, but they are a poor third cousin for stopping power.