What kind of shoes???
 

Just wondering if anyone can recommend a good shoe for me... I don't use the clip-on BS cycling shoes because they anger me, what I'm looking for is shoe that is good to cycle in, but also is good for light hiking (visiting national parks - will be doing day hikes) and also little heavier built to keep my feet warm

I tried to do a tour last year (which didn't happen :( ) in a pair of Adidas runners, but my feet were cold as **** all the time and the soles were complete crap which I imagine would only kill my feet on any kind of trail.

Thanks for any suggestions!

Columbia makes a line of hiking shoes that will do all you want except keep your feet warm. That's what wool socks are for.

http://www.amazon.com/Columbia-Sport...N%3DB001TK2DFA

I've got a pair of New Balance 572s I really like. I commute in them daily and have done a lot of walking and a little hiking in them. They're very light and very comfortable. I highly recommend them. I also plan on wearing them on my first tours (overnights) this summer.

Like Cyclebum said, I think socks are where to look for proper warmth.

Can't give you specific advice, as I do use clipless pedals, but go for hiking boots rather than running shoes. They will have stiffer soles, which all the proper cycling shoes have.
For warmer weather, you could try Keen sandals. They make regular and cycling sandals, and they are identical, except for the clip on part.

Since you don' want clipless, go for light hiking shoes. Pick out a pair that say they are water resistant and use two layers of socks (one thin liner, on outer wool to keep your feet warm). Just make sure the hiking boots are large enough to accept two pairs of socks. Don't get them too small.

I use clipless MTB shoes, personally. They are functionally gym shoes, with a stiffer sole and cleats. They are easier to walk in than most cycling shoes and my feet don't seem to get cold, even if I am just wearing thin cycling socks. On the bike, I still get the advantage of clipless pedals.

The Keen shoes or Salomon's are great. I just got a pair of Merrells, but haven't cycled in them yet so can't say yet if they are any good. Make sure they are big enough that you can pu wool socks in there for warmth.

I guess it depends on when/where you tour, but I have always much preferred shoes with a lot of mesh for riding. I know from experience that, for me at least, mountain biking or trail running with waterproof shoes just means they won't drain well and will slosh. I have not toured in waterproof shoes but would expect the same problem.

I've got some SPD touring shoes with lots of mesh, Pearl Izumi I think, and I've done well with all manner of light socks to wool and waterproof socks for riding in 90degree temps to 35degree slush. I can feel the air go through them. I didn't mind the shoes being soaked since they would dry out eventually but another pair of Shimano touring shoes with leather don't dry out as quickly.

Correct. I also prefer well vented shoes with mesh or bike sandals. However, the OP complained about having cold feet. Shoes with lots of mesh don't help those with the OP's problem. Waterproof or water resistant shoes are good only because they aren't vented well, and would help keep the OP's feet warm. The OP could also get shoe covers for his bike shoes, but the OP does not have or want bike shoes or clipless pedals.

I think Trail Running shoes make good cycling shoes. They are comfortable enough to run in, but are stiff enough to be efficient when cycling. The ones with Gore-Tex or other waterproof linings will be a little warmer. But, as stated, will not provide as much ventilation in warmer weather. If you don't like clip-less pedals, might I suggest Power Grips. It's a simple strap that crosses the pedal and provides shoe support, but are easy to get in and out of.