Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Touring (https://www.bikeforums.net/touring/)
-   -   Surly LHT (26" wheel) fenders - need recommendation (https://www.bikeforums.net/touring/696867-surly-lht-26-wheel-fenders-need-recommendation.html)

thinknotes 11-22-10 01:00 PM

Surly LHT (26" wheel) fenders - need recommendation
 
Hello All

Am looking to add fenders to my Surly LHT (26" wheel size) and was wondering if you might be able to share your experiences. Much appreciate your help,

Warm wishes
Manju

robow 11-22-10 01:24 PM

See if you can find the fenders used by "twodeadpoets" who posts on this forum, I think he has a blog and photos. They're a little pricey but really lovely and functional.

LeeG 11-22-10 01:42 PM

I used SKS, they work fine and attach solidly. With1.75" tires I've got lots of room.


http://www.bikeman.com/FE1016.html

Mr. Fly 11-22-10 01:59 PM

2 Attachment(s)
I've been using Planet Bike's Cascadia fenders with very good results. They're longer and thus provide more protection than the other brands, were easy to install, and have been quite durable so far. Attached are two pictures to show you how they look fitted to my 26"-wheeled LHT. The one with the moustache bars have 26x1.6 Continental Sport Contacts; the one with the normal drop bars have 26x2.0 Schwalbe Kojaks.

adanthang 11-22-10 03:17 PM


Originally Posted by LeeG (Post 11826289)
I used SKS, they work fine and attach solidly. With1.75" tires I've got lots of room.


http://www.bikeman.com/FE1016.html

I also have the SKS's on my LHT. I've had no issues and would recommend them.

thinknotes 11-22-10 03:43 PM

Thanks Mr Fly. Would you know what size fenders you are using? Are these the 60mm ones?

Louis 11-22-10 04:59 PM

I posted some info about my LHT 52cm fender fit here. http://www.bikeforums.net/showthread...rucker-Fenders

paul2432 11-22-10 05:02 PM

I use the PB Hardcore fenders on mine. I am thinking about replacing the mudflap with the cascadia mud flap.

Paul

iforgotmename 11-22-10 05:18 PM

1 Attachment(s)
I have pb cascadias and they are great full coverage fenders. I have the 60mm fenders and they work well with tires from 1.5 to 2.1. The tires pictured are 1.75.

Mr. Fly 11-23-10 12:20 AM


Originally Posted by thinknotes (Post 11826967)
Thanks Mr Fly. Would you know what size fenders you are using? Are these the 60mm ones?

Yup, 60mm. I don't think the Cascadia come in any other size for the 26" version.

robow 11-23-10 12:28 AM

Here ya go, if you've got the $

http://www.woodysfenders.com/gallery...serialNumber=2

http://www.woodysfenders.com/store/

sstorkel 11-23-10 11:05 AM


Originally Posted by Mr. Fly (Post 11826377)
I've been using Planet Bike's Cascadia fenders with very good results.

I've used Planet Bike Cascadia and SKS fenders on my bikes. Build quality and coverage are about the same, but I found the PB fenders to be much easier to install than SKS. The PB fenders come with struts that are sized to fit the wheels they'll be installed on. My SKS fenders came with overly long struts that needed to be trimmed with a Dremel or other cutting tool. Assembly of the SKS struts was also a bit fiddly. The PB fenders arrived partially assembled. SKS fenders arrived completely disassembled, including a bag of numerous tiny bolts, washers, mounting studs, etc.

Unless you can save a ton of money by buying SKS, I can't see that they're worth the hassle (granted: it's probably a one-time hassle)...

Edit: Turns out I lied: I've actually got the PB Hybrid/Touring fenders, not the Cascadia...

positron 11-23-10 11:05 AM

Velo-Orange stainless 60mm fenders are great and affordable.

http://store.velo-orange.com/index.p...mm-26-atb.html

thinknotes 11-23-10 12:10 PM

Thanks all, this is very helpful.

LeeG 11-23-10 05:58 PM

two more cents. I'm not sure about the 26" PB Cascadias but the 700c ones I have on the Cross-Check are noticably wobblier than the SKS ones I had on before or the SKS on my 26" LHT. Not sure if it contributes to some of the hands off wobble that can occur with a rear load but I notice the struts are mounted higher up on the front fender than the SKS allowing more wobble in the fender. The top strut is pretty much useless given it's close placement to the fork crown mount. The reason I like them is that my foot doesn't hit the strut like it did on the SKS, this is not an issue with the 26" wheeled LHT and I don't have 26" Cascadias to make the comparison with the SKS like I did on the 700c Cross-check.

iforgotmename 11-24-10 08:39 PM


Originally Posted by LeeG (Post 11832976)
two more cents. I'm not sure about the 26" PB Cascadias but the 700c ones I have on the Cross-Check are noticably wobblier than the SKS ones I had on before or the SKS on my 26" LHT. Not sure if it contributes to some of the hands off wobble that can occur with a rear load but I notice the struts are mounted higher up on the front fender than the SKS allowing more wobble in the fender. The top strut is pretty much useless given it's close placement to the fork crown mount. The reason I like them is that my foot doesn't hit the strut like it did on the SKS, this is not an issue with the 26" wheeled LHT and I don't have 26" Cascadias to make the comparison with the SKS like I did on the 700c Cross-check.

That's interesting as I occasionally get a wobble if the rear load isn"t just right.

Doconabike 11-27-10 01:22 AM


Originally Posted by thinknotes (Post 11826050)
Hello All

Am looking to add fenders to my Surly LHT (26" wheel size) and was wondering if you might be able to share your experiences. Much appreciate your help,

Warm wishes
Manju

For my 26" Surly LHT, I've been very happy with the Planet Bike Cascadia fenders that were designed for 29er wheels. They were easy to mount, fit very well, and give great coverage. I found that using the 29er fenders gave very good coverage on a bike designed for 26" wheels.

If you are looking to order some, Google
"Planet Bike Cascadia 29er Front and Rear Bicycle Fender Set with 130mm Mud Flaps (Black, 65mm Wide)"
They fit very well with my wide tires "Schwalbe Marathon Supreme HS 382 Touring Road Bike Tire (26x2.00)"

Don't forget to consider the width of your tires before buying your fenders. If you ride on wide tires, a narrow set of fenders will fit poorly.

badamsjr 11-27-10 08:09 PM

2 Attachment(s)
I have the Planet Bike Cascadia's on my touring bike, as well, and like them. Plenty of room for my 26x1.5 Marathon's. Only problem I had was mounting the front on the 29er fork (used for disc brake and to raise the front a little). Made a 'bracket' that works well.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:21 AM.


Copyright 2021 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.