Originally Posted by
thenomad
As for fit: I'm not sure I have a bike in my ideal size. I think I have short arms which make the top tube reach an issue even when legs are fine. 5'9", 31" cycling inseam.
I've been looking for a 54cm frame for a bit. I feel that the 56 is too large and I need short stems and forward seat (would like a no-setback seatpost). I figured I'd better post here just to see what others think.
I've got a 56 Steel Trek and a 52 carbon Trek. I "made" the carbon fit but it is obviously out of proportion.
I'm now going to sell the carbon frame as seed money for a much nicer frame.
Think I should keep the 56 or go for 54 based on the pic of the steel bike? A longer stem might make it nicer for control?
The setup on both bike tells me you'd be happy on a 54 with a shortish top tube. Think Madone Performance Fit geometry. Look for a top tube of 54 cm or shorter. A moderately extend head tube will be helpful, too.