I've updated my chart (see my previous post) since I had incorrectly described the components for the Specialized Rockhopper and I was able to get a price for it. The price for this is $700CAD list but will likely go for something like 650-675 CAD.

I am now looking seriously at the Gary Fischer Marlin and the Specialized Rockhopper since they appear very similar with respect to major components and are comparible in price. Should I look at any other components or are the major ones covered in my chart?

I will take the time to test ride these two as I feel very confident that it is one of these two bikes that I will buy. Again, big kudos to this thread as it educated me quite a bit and led me to decide between these two bikes.

Anyone have any strong opinions on my choice of Rockhopper vs. Marlin?