Gosh you guys are awesome. Thanks for all of the helpful replies! I have a $100 gift card to the LBS, so I plan on going there and trying stuff on and figuring it all out. I think I am most likely to go for th eggbeaters due to the price and one of my friends has them and loves them to death. The froggies look really nice though.

Don't mind falling, and it sounds like Sunday's ride will be the perfect time to do it.

Thanks a bunch!