Originally Posted by
Autobus
How do I determine? Do collars go by the seatpost size or the frame tubing diameter?

Whoever makes the collar has no way of knowing the wall thickness of your seat tube, so your seatpost size is irrelevant. The outside diameter of your seat tube where the clamp will go is the dimension that's important. I think some of those clamps also have a lip at the top, slightly smaller, to locate them and keep them from slipping down when loosened.