New Chevy Equinox, 4-cyl, 2WD with the 2 tone leather. Then get better room and mileage than all those listed on the highway, and better overall than most.
I've always been a German driver, but this in on my top list when I shop around this summer.
As for Subaru, all I will say is our recent model Outback blew head gaskets constantly, and started rusting after 3 years keeping with Subaru's reputation so we sold that junk.
My current 13 year old Audi wagon doesn't have a spot of rust even though living in the NE all its life.