I took the brand new Blue Professional for its first ride Saturday and I'd say it felt just like the 30 year old Professional it replaced. I guess you might call this my "Trophy Brooks"

(did that come out of a pastor's mouth?).
This was only my third ride since November, so my bike booty has not yet broken in for the season. My impression is, you either have a butt for a Brooks or you don't.
If you are in NH I'd loan you one to try out. What can you leave as collateral?