Originally Posted by
StoicOne
It is a matter of man and machine, and how they accommodate one another. Bicycles are designed to place all the weight in a region not designed by nature to support weight. To some extent, the biology can adapt and this will result in less sensitivity over time. The standing joke is if you are placing too much weight on the seat, you should get off the seat and just use it for balance. Everyone, however, sits fully on the seat.
The sits bones, extensions of the hip, are the weigh bearing skeletal bones, and seats have been designed that have no nose, but only contact the sits bones. They feel uncomfortable at first, and getting the friction right, and adjusting your legs to provide balance, takes a little time, ... but it is more naturally supporting. These seats are rarely used and more expensive - showing that usually people adjust to the commonly used seats, and this might mean they spend less time on their bikes unfortunately. If you are heavier you might be interested in a specially designed seat :
http://www.bikemania.biz/ProductDeta...gyWonderMark9B
I have no connection with this company, other than having purchased a seat from them. They are a tad expensive, but with them, you can go long, and be seated in comfort.
That link doesn't work, but if this is the seat you're pointing at:
http://www.spongywonder.com/ then what you say might make sense
if you never got "out of the saddle". The "nose" of the conventional saddle is there to stabilize the bike when the rider pushes hard enough to lift their body weight with one leg. This is a common enough occurance for even moderately fit cyclists.
A properly adjusted conventional bicycle seat will support the rider's weight through the weight-bearing skeletal bones. If it's putting pressure on the soft tissues,
it's not adjusted properly or it doesn't match the rider's anatomy. End of story. I had a heck of time until I tried a WTB saddle. A WTB saddle was all-day comfortable, so I put one on every upright I had.
Because of other issues, my current day-to-day ride is really different:
http://home.comcast.net/~jeff_wills/jeff-big.jpg