Originally Posted by
Torrilin
Geometry does matter sometimes... but the bits most people worry over aren't the bits I have found actually matter. Effective top tube matters, tho given the OP's preferred riding position, not much. If he wants to try drops, it matters a lot more. The bottom bracket height matters a lot. It dictates chainstay length to a remarkable degree (especially if you're short), and affects all kinds of stuff with stopping, general handling and the bike's ability to handle heavy cargo. I wouldn't say there's a hard and fast point where the bottom bracket should be tho. Some of the guys here on BF can manage 40-50lb loads with much twitchier bikes than I can, because they're taller and heavier and just plain have more weight to shift around.
Sure, geometry matters to the extent it matches your use and intended riding position, but any geometry difference between the bikes the OP listed won't matter. Millimeters here and there may change things subtly, but for an upright bike that will be ridden relatively slowly, it won't really matter.