Originally Posted by dwightonabike
Thanks for all the advice ya'll. Keep it comin'! I think I'm starting to lean towards a Surly LHT, but I am a big guy (250 lbs) and would feel uncomfortable paying >1000$ for something I am unable to test. I love the guys at my LBS, maybe they will order one on spec for me, its at least worth a try.
I know this will just add to your problems but you might want to consider the Cannondale T800. I'm nearly as big as you and I used to ride a steel frame. Add the load of gear you need for touring and you can overwelm a steel frame pretty quickly. They ride nice without a load but loaded up mine tended to develop a high speed shimmy which it doesn't have unloaded. I also couldn't stand up to pedal because the bike tended to "noodle" down the road under load. The Cannondale is stiff as all get out unloaded but it is real smooth and stable with a load, even at high speeds and while standing. I can throw it around like a race bike under load without problems.