You couldn't pay me to ride either one of them. The horn on a saddle is important for control of the bicycle. People who like these probably aren't that good at controlling a bike anyway, and never had a real saddle that fit properly. If you have a properly fitting saddle, the horn does NOT put any significant pressure on your bottom. If it does, either the back part of the saddle is the wrong width to fit your sit bones, or the tilt or some other adjustment on the saddle is wrong.