Originally Posted by
staehpj1
I guess it depends on when/where you tour, but I have always much preferred shoes with a lot of mesh for riding. I know from experience that, for me at least, mountain biking or trail running with waterproof shoes just means they won't drain well and will slosh. I have not toured in waterproof shoes but would expect the same problem.
I've got some SPD touring shoes with lots of mesh, Pearl Izumi I think, and I've done well with all manner of light socks to wool and waterproof socks for riding in 90degree temps to 35degree slush. I can feel the air go through them. I didn't mind the shoes being soaked since they would dry out eventually but another pair of Shimano touring shoes with leather don't dry out as quickly.