Originally Posted by
staehpj1
I guess it depends on when/where you tour, but I have always much preferred shoes with a lot of mesh for riding. I know from experience that, for me at least, mountain biking or trail running with waterproof shoes just means they won't drain well and will slosh. I have not toured in waterproof shoes but would expect the same problem.
Correct. I also prefer well vented shoes with mesh or bike sandals. However, the OP complained about having cold feet. Shoes with lots of mesh don't help those with the OP's problem. Waterproof or water resistant shoes are good only because they aren't vented well, and would help keep the OP's feet warm. The OP could also get shoe covers for his bike shoes, but the OP does not have or want bike shoes or clipless pedals.