My thread about the Brooks barbican got me interested in other folks' opinions on courier bags. I'm thinking of getting another one; one better suited to riding than the one I have.

I have an Eddie Bauer model I got at Target. (see attached) Good size, super-smooth zippers, and a good selection of different compartments. The back has a separate compartment for a laptop, which zips open like a book, so one doesn't have to remove one's lap top when going through the airport.

The Eddie Bauer print on the back is reflective.

The only problem with it is that since it was not made for cyclists or motorcyclists, it slips around my side sometimes while biking, so I never use it while biking. Shame.

I'm considering the following bags as a replacement:

Aerostich courier - $87
[img]
Looks well thought-out, but doesn't seem to have any sub-pockets; just one big compartment.

Brooks Barbican
Looks really nice, but costs $350. I love the integrated belt to keep it from coming around when riding, and the fact that it looks dressy enough that I won't look like a fool if I use it for work too. I'll have to think on this one.

Timbuk2 Messenger
Looks like a great design. I love the reflective stripe option, reflective tabs on the ends of the cover straps, and organizer pockets. It doesn't seem to have the triangular cross section shape that the Aerostich does. I'm curious if it "comes around" like my Eddie Bauer does... $100 seems to be a fair price. The liner is waterproof. Many color schemes and setups to choose from.

Banjo Bros
Don't know anything about this, but it was recommended by a nice fellow in my Barbican thread. Looks just like the Aerostich to me.

Chrome Messenger
Again, it's hard to tell about this bag from pix online. Anyone got one? Thoughts?

Any bags you've got experience with, please post a mini-review and a pic or a link. Let's make this a resource thread for when the question comes up again.